Abstract
In this work of normative political philosophy, I consider the ethical status of the South African government's responses to the Marikana massacre, where police shot and killed more than 30 striking miners, in light of a moral principle grounded on values associated with ubuntu. I argue that there are several respects in which the government's reactions have been unethical from an ubuntu-oriented perspective, and also make positive suggestions about what it instead should have been doing. Much of what I recommend amounts to contending that the government should have taken resolute steps towards seeking reconciliation of a specific sort that I show follows from ubuntu interpreted as an ethical theory.
Acknowledgements
This article is a more intricate exploration of ideas that first appeared as a brief op-ed piece (Metz Citation2013). For written comments on a prior draft of this article, I would like to thank two anonymous referees for Politikon. This article has also benefited from oral feedback received from Christopher Wareham and from the audience at Evaluating the Aftermath of Marikana: Commemorating the Massacre, held at the University of Johannesburg in August 2013.
Notes
1 There are of course other normative questions one could ask, such as whether non-governmental agents have reacted to Marikana ethically, or whether non-governmental agents acted ethically in the run up to Marikana. I set aside such issues for the sake of focus.
3 For discussion in the context of several traditional African societies, see Nkulu-N'Sengha (Citation2009).
5 For other philosophical interpretations of African ethics, see Bujo (Citation1997) and Gyekye (Citation1997), who deem vital force and the common good (respectively) to be foundational, and not an ideal of communal relationship, as I do.
6 This includes topics such as offering amnesty for political crimes (Metz Citation2011b), distributing political power and economic goods (Metz Citation2012a) and upholding human rights (Metz Citation2014b).
8 See Metz (Citation2011a, Citation2012b); Metz and Gaie (Citation2010) for answers to these and other important questions about how one might plausibly interpret ubuntu as an ethical principle.
10 Below I indicate that she continued to be defensive during the hearings.
11 Note as well that the African National Congress did not attend commemorations of the events at Marikana that were held a year after them, with some miners ‘disappointed that the government is not here to mourn with them’ (BBC News Citation2013; see also Alexander Citation2013, 616).
12 For ubuntu-based discussion of such reactions, see (Metz Citation2011b).
Alexander, Peter. 2013. “Marikana, Turning Point in South African History.” Review of African Political Economy 40 (138): 605–619. doi:10.1080/03056244.2013.860893. Nkulu-N'Sengha, Mutombo. 2009. “Bumuntu.” In Encyclopedia of African Religion, edited by Molefi Kete Asante and Ama Mazama, 142–147. Los Angeles: Sage. Metz, Thaddeus. 2011a. “Ubuntu as a Moral Theory and Human Rights in South Africa.” African Human Rights Law Journal 11 (2): 532–559. Accessed January 23, 2016 http://www.ahrlj.up.ac.za/metz-t. Metz, Thaddeus. 2014a. “Ubuntu: The Good Life.” In Encyclopedia of Quality of Life and Well-Being Research, edited by Alex Michalos, 6761–6765. Dordrecht: Springer. Metz, Thaddeus, and Joseph Gaie. 2010. “The African Ethic of Ubuntu/Botho: Implications for Research on Morality.” Journal of Moral Education 39 (3): 273–290. doi: 10.1080/03057240.2010.497609 Bujo, Bénézet. 1997. The Ethical Dimension of Community. Translated by Nganda C. N. Nairobi: Paulines. Gyekye, Kwame. 1997. Tradition and Modernity: Philosophical Reflections on the African Experience. New York: Oxford University Press. Metz, Thaddeus. 2011b. “Limiting the Reach of Amnesty for Political Crimes: Which Extra-Legal Burdens on the Guilty Does National Reconciliation Permit?” Constitutional Court Review 3: 243–270. Accessed January 23, 2016 http://www.pulp.up.ac.za/pdf/2011_11/2011_11.pdf. Metz, Thaddeus. 2012a. “Developing African Political Philosophy: Moral-Theoretic Strategies.” Philosophia Africana 14 (1): 61–83. doi: 10.5840/philafricana20121419 Metz, Thaddeus. 2014b. “African Values, Human Rights and Group Rights: A Philosophical Foundation for the Banjul Charter.” In African Legal Theory and Contemporary Problems: Critical Essays, edited by Oche Onazi, 131–151. Dordrecht: Springer. Gbadegesin, Segun. 1991. African Philosophy: Traditional Yoruba Philosophy and Contemporary African Realities. New York: Peter Lang. Iroegbu, Pantaleon. 2005. “Beginning, Purpose and End of Life.” In Kpim of Morality Ethics, edited by Pantaleon Iroegbu, and Anthony Echekwube, 440–445. Ibadan: Heinemann Educational. Gyekye, Kwame. 2004. Beyond Cultures: Perceiving a Common Humanity. Washington, DC: The Council for Research in Values and Philosophy. Masolo, Dismas. 2010. Self and Community in a Changing World. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. Metz, Thaddeus. 2011a. “Ubuntu as a Moral Theory and Human Rights in South Africa.” African Human Rights Law Journal 11 (2): 532–559. Accessed January 23, 2016 http://www.ahrlj.up.ac.za/metz-t. Metz, Thaddeus. 2012b. “An African Theory of Moral Status.” Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 15 (3): 387–402. doi: 10.1007/s10677-011-9302-y Metz, Thaddeus, and Joseph Gaie. 2010. “The African Ethic of Ubuntu/Botho: Implications for Research on Morality.” Journal of Moral Education 39 (3): 273–290. doi: 10.1080/03057240.2010.497609 Metz, Thaddeus. 2015. “A Theory of National Reconciliation.” In Theorizing Transitional Justice, edited by Claudio Corradetti, Nir Eisikovits, and Jack Rotondi, 119–135. Surrey: Ashgate. Tutu, Desmond. 1999. No Future without Forgiveness. New York: Random House. Louw, Dirk. 2006. “The African Concept of Ubuntu and Restorative Justice.” In Handbook of Restorative Justice, edited by Dennis Sullivan, and Larry Tifft, 161–172. New York: Routledge. Krog, Antjie. 2008. “‘This Thing Called Reconciliation … .’; Forgiveness as Part of an Interconnectedness-towards-Wholeness.” South African Journal of Philosophy 27 (4): 353–366. doi: 10.4314/sajpem.v27i4.31524 Villa-Vicencio, Charles. 2009. Walk with Us and Listen: Political Reconciliation in Africa. Cape Town: University of Cape Town Press. Alexander, Peter. 2013. “Marikana, Turning Point in South African History.” Review of African Political Economy 40 (138): 605–619. doi:10.1080/03056244.2013.860893. Metz, Thaddeus. 2011b. “Limiting the Reach of Amnesty for Political Crimes: Which Extra-Legal Burdens on the Guilty Does National Reconciliation Permit?” Constitutional Court Review 3: 243–270. Accessed January 23, 2016 http://www.pulp.up.ac.za/pdf/2011_11/2011_11.pdf.