A robust modification of the ordered-heterogeneity test

Abstract

An ordered heterogeneity (OH) test is a test for a trend that combines a non-directional heterogeneity test with the rank-order information specified under the alternative. We propose two modifications of the OH test procedure: (1) to use the mean ranks of the groups rather than the sample means to determine the observed ordering of the groups, and (2) to use the maximum correlation out of the 2^k − 1 – 1 possibilities under the alternative rather than the single ordering (1, 2, … , k), where k is the number of independent groups. A simulation study indicates that these two changes increase the power of the ordered heterogeneity test when, as common in practice, the underlying distribution may deviate from a normal distribution and the trend pattern is a priori unknown. In contrast to the original OH test, the modified OH test can detect all possible patterns under the alternative with a relatively high power.

Keywords:

• Comparing more than two groups
• k-sample test
• tests for trend
• non-parametric tests
• Spearman's rank correlation