ABSTRACT
This article focuses on violent conflict among indigenous groups in the Eastern Woodlands of North America from the seventeenth to the late eighteenth century. Amerindian groups struggled here against European domination and among themselves for various reasons. However, warfare was conceived in spiritual and religious terms and remained a highly ritualized affair. With their long and intense history of martial interaction and the prominent role of women in the war complex, the Iroquoian Amerindians of the Eastern Woodlands are an interesting case of collective violence in non-state societies. In contrast to many stratified pre-industrial societies, neither war nor religion had to legitimize domination by an elite class. Both spheres were individual, kinship, or communal affairs. But religious beliefs played a role in motivating and justifying raids and warfare, which were sanctified by the need to satisfy the souls of dead kinsmen. Failure to avenge a relative’s death meant provoking the wrath of the deceased’s soul. The torture and killing of captives was often a sacrifice to deities and a means to renew the spiritual strength of lineages, clans and villages. While Iroquois women did not go on the war path themselves, the female elders of the clans had, in contrast to most other societies, a say on issues of war and peace and female relatives played a crucial role in instigating raids in revenge for killed relatives. Beyond this, they actively participated in the ritual torture of captives.
Disclosure statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).
Notes
1 Anthony Wallace (Citation1966, 84–88) suggested a useful typology of religious or cult institutions: While rituals can be performed by everybody in individualistic cults, this task is assumed by part-time practitioners in shamanic cults, groups of laymen in communal cults, and a professional clergy in ecclesiastical cults. As he made clear, several cult institutions may coexist in any community (see also Winkelman Citation1986; Waal Malefijt Citation1989, 228–240; Earle Citation1997, 143–192, 204–208; Harris and Johnson Citation2007, 273–284; Boyer and Bergstrom Citation2008, 123–124; Otterbein Citation2009, 23–33).
2 The expansion of European settlement is discussed in detail in Salisbury (Citation1996).
3 See, for example, the map in Salisbury (Citation1996, 454).
4 The Iroquois League – also called the Five Nations by the British and, in analogy to their dwellings, ‘People of the Longhouse’ (in Seneca: Haudenosaunee) by themselves – was a confederation of several groups of horticulturalist villagers akin in culture and speaking related languages of the Iroquoian family. They lived in several villages in the area Southeast of Lake Ontario. The five groups that founded the confederation probably in the late fifteenth century were the Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga, and Seneca. They were joined by the Tuscarora in the early eighteenth century, so after then also referred to as the Six Nations (Wolf Citation1982, 165; Richter Citation1992, 1, 31).
5 The Huron or Wendat (‘Dwellers of the Peninsula’ or ‘Islanders’, alluding to their settlement area between the Lakes Huron and Ontario) were a confederacy of several groups who were culturally similar to the Five Nations and also spoke languages of the Iroquoian family. The Huron confederay was composed of ‘four different collections or assemblages of grouped family stocks’, the individual names were Attignawantan, Attigneenongnahac, Arendahronons, and Tohontaenrat (CitationJesuit Relations, vol. 16, 227). In the following, the term ‘Iroquois’ will be employed for the groups pertaining to the League while ‘Iroquoian’ refers to members of the language group including both Iroquois and Huron, among others.
6 The Iroquois were estimated at 20,000 to 30,000 around 1600 (Richter Citation1992, 40; see also Tooker Citation1978, 421 for the number of warriors during the seventeenth century). There were between 18,000 and 22,000 Huron in the early seventeenth century (Heidenreich Citation1978, 369–370).
7 Tribe is used here not as a synonym for ethnic group or community but as an analytic term. It refers to a particular type of social and political organization, i.e., to collectivities integrated by the means of pan-tribal associations, such as clans or age-sets, that cross-cut residential groups (cf., e.g., Service Citation1971, 99–132). As many authors have argued, most of these non-state societies were not clearly bounded units of language, culture and self-identification (cf. already Southall Citation1970). As a matter of fact, differences in language, culture, political affiliation, and self-identification did rarely if ever coincide. Pre-colonial notions of membership and distinction and the meaning and historicity of the concepts ethnic community and nation are discussed in Gabbert (Citation2006, Citation2015) and Bird-David (Citation2017). In present-day North America ‘tribe’ is a legal concept denoting political units of North American Indians recognized as such by the U.S. government and accepted as such by the indigenous people (see, e.g., McCulloch and Wilkins Citation1995).
8 However, women played an important role in hunting and trading among the Iroquois (Trigger Citation1987, 39; MacLeitch Citation2011, 136).
9 Each clan-segment possessed a certain number of titles that denoted the function of civil headmen at the different levels. In case of a headman's death, the title was passed to his successor who was generally chosen among the deceased's brothers or nephews. Since there were no rules of succession, personal qualities, such as generosity, eloquence, and intelligence, were important. If none of the deceased's brothers or nephews was considered qualified for the function another male clan member was chosen (Lafitau Citation1724, vol. 1, 471–472; Morgan Citation1851, 87–88; Tooker Citation1978, 424). In any case, candidates needed the support of the other headmen (Trigger Citation1987, 54–59; Lafitau Citation1724, vol. 1, 469–472; CitationJesuit Relations, vol. 10, 229–231).
10 Morgan similarly stressed that the ‘class of chiefs’ consisted of all ‘the celebrated orators, wise men, and military leaders’ (Citation1851, 101).
12 However, according to the French Recollect friar Gabriel Sagard women were ‘not admitted to many of the men's feasts, nor to any of their councils’ (Sagard-Théodat Citation[1632] 1939, 101; see also Heidenreich Citation1978, 371–372).
13 For the same justification of warfare in other indigenous groups in Eastern North America, see Lee (Citation2007, 713–715).
14 However, there were also cases of large-scale warfare in the late pre-contact period (see, e.g., Brandão Citation1997, 46).
15 See CitationJesuit Relations (vol. 1, 271–273; vol. 10, 227, 229; vol. 13, 37–43, 53–79; vol. 15, 171, 173; vol. 18, 31, 33; vol. 22, 259–267; vol. 39, 55–77); Radisson (Citation1885, 47–56); Lafitau (Citation1724, vol. 2, 266–270); Sagard-Théodat (Citation[1632] 1939, 161) for detailed accounts of the treatment and torture of captives.
16 The active role of indigenous women in the torture of captives is also stressed by Felicity Donohoe in her dissertation on gender and ritual violence in Eastern North America (Citation2013, especially 46–52).
17 Captives were burnt to appease the ‘manes’, the worshiped souls of the dead (Charlevoix Citation1761, vol. 1, 354).
19 Pomedli (Citation1991, 61). This author provides an intriguing analysis of the Huron's and Jesuit missionaries’ world view, focussing on their concepts of the soul.
20 CitationJesuit Relations (vol. 33, 225), emphasis there. See also Megapolensis ([1644] Citation1792, 524); Charlevoix (Citation1761, vol. 2, 131); CitationJesuit Relations (vol. 39, 207; vol. 42, 197). Soutanditenr is not part of the deity's name but a verb meaning ‘have mercy on us’ (Goddard Citation1984, 232). Agreskwe was invoked in various contexts (Wonderley Citation2009, 65–66). See Goddard (Citation1984) for a discussion of the term and related concepts. He concludes that Agreskwe was ‘an important member of the aboriginal pantheon. What is not clear is whether he is better considered a war god with certain non-martial functions, or a spirit of generalized functions that included special powers in connection with warfare and other dangerous activities’ (235). That Ondoutaeté referred to the deity's war–related aspect instead of being the name of a separate deity is indicated by the paragraph quoted in the text. Ondoutaeté meant ‘one who bears the reed mat of war’ or war bundle. These were sacks containing sacred items or charms carried along on war parties (Steckley Citation2007, 196).
21 For similar rituals among other indigenous groups in Eastern North America, see Lee (Citation2007, 720–722).
22 Wonderley (Citation2009, 61, 66, 68) suggests that Agreskwe and Sky Holder designated the same deity or power.
23 The ritual torturing of captives was not universally practiced in the Americas, but was found amongst certain specific groups including the Carib (in the Caribbean), the Indians in the Colombian Cauca Valley, the Araucanians (Southern Chile and Argentina), the Tupinamba (coast of present-day Brazil), Natchez, Pawnee (on the Missouri), and, particularly elaborated, among the Indians of the North East (Montagnais, Huron, Iroquois and Susquehanna) (Gabbert Citation2020, 103).
24 See, for example, CitationJesuit Relations (vol. 13, 79; vol. 39, 219–221); Knowles (Citation1940, 189); Trigger (Citation1987, 74–75); Stueck (Citation2012, 104). For extended treatments of anthropophagy among the Iroquois and Huron, see Abler (Citation1980), Abler and Logan (Citation1988) and Stueck (Citation2012, 77–84). A discussion of and further references to the controversial issue of cannibalism in the Americas before and after the European conquest can be found in Schüren and Gabbert (Citation2020, 401–402) and Gabbert (Citation2020, 97–100).
25 The Iroquois population was probably reduced by more than a half due to epidemics in the first half of the seventeenth century (Richter Citation1992, 58–60).
26 However, Trigger (Citation1987, 664) considers looting as a more possible reason for the raids. In his succinct study of Iroquois warfare in the seventeenth century, Brandão (Citation1997) rightfully rejects any monocausal explanation. However, he also concedes that the Iroquois ‘fought over land’ (90) to defend or acquire hunting grounds for deer and beaver and to push back their enemies thus increasing the distance to their own villages. Participation in the fur trade was necessary as a means to acquire the highly coveted firearms.
27 This is not meant to suggest that these functions were the cause of the institution of warfare. As Wallace already stressed long ago, ‘the motive of a deed, and its effect [i.e., its function], may be very different. Still further, it is absolutely essential to keep in mind that neither intention nor function is a sufficient cause. The cause of the establishment of an institution is a sequence of antecedent circumstances’ (Citation1966, 169–170, emphasis there). However, I would argue that a cultural pattern, such as warfare, will only persist in the long run if it has positive effects for a sufficiently large part of or powerful social category in a society.
28 See, for example, Hoffman (Citation2011, 224–251) for an interesting interpretation of the use of war magic in Sierra Leone.
29 See for example the Mount Hagen people of Papua New Guinea (Strathern and Stewart Citation2013, 168–169, 177–178).
30 In their otherwise convincingly argued article, Robarchek and Robarchek (Citation2005) fail to address the collective dimension of raids.
Wallace, Anthony F.C. 1966. Religion. An Anthropological View. New York: Random House. Winkelman, Michael. 1986. “Magico-Religious Practitioner Types and Socioeconomic Conditions.” Behavior Science Research 20: 17–46. Waal Malefijt, Annemarie de. 1989. Religion and Culture: An Introduction to Anthropology of Religion. Prospect Heights, Ill.: Waveland Press. Earle, Timothy. 1997. How Chiefs Come to Power. The Political Economy in Prehistory. Stanford: Stanford University Press. Harris, Marvin, and Orna Johnson. 2007. Cultural Anthropology. Boston, MA: Pearson, Allyn & Bacon. Boyer, Pascal, and Brian Bergstrom. 2008. “Evolutionary Perspectives on Religion.” Annual Review of Anthropology 37: 111–130. Otterbein, Keith F. 2009. The Anthropology of War. Long Grove, IL: Waveland Press. Salisbury, Neal. 1996. “Native People and European Settlers in Eastern North America, 1600–1783.” In The Cambridge History of the Native Peoples of the Americas, edited by Bruce G. Trigger and Wilcomb E. Washburn, 399–460. Volume 1: North America, Part 1. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press. Salisbury, Neal. 1996. “Native People and European Settlers in Eastern North America, 1600–1783.” In The Cambridge History of the Native Peoples of the Americas, edited by Bruce G. Trigger and Wilcomb E. Washburn, 399–460. Volume 1: North America, Part 1. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press. Wolf, Eric. 1982. Europe and the People Without History. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Richter, Daniel K. 1992. The Ordeal of the Longhouse: The Peoples of the Iroquois League in the Era of European Colonization. Williamsburg, VA: University of North Carolina Press. Jesuit Relations. The Jesuit Relations and Allied Documents. Travels and Explorations of the Jesuit Missionaries in New France, 1610–1791. Edited by Reuben G. Thwaites. 73 vols (1896–1901). Cleveland, OH: The Burrows Brothers Company. Richter, Daniel K. 1992. The Ordeal of the Longhouse: The Peoples of the Iroquois League in the Era of European Colonization. Williamsburg, VA: University of North Carolina Press. Trigger, Bruce G. 1978. “Early Iroquoian Contacts with Europeans.” In Handbook of North American Indians, edited by Bruce G. Trigger, Vol. 15, 344–356. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution. Heidenreich, Conrad E. 1978. “Huron.” In Handbook of North American Indians, edited by Bruce G. Trigger, Vol. 15, 368–388. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution. Service, Elman R. 1971. Primitive Social Organization. 2nd revised ed. New York: Random House. Southall, Aidan W. 1970. “The Illusion of Tribe.” Journal of Asian and African Studies 5 (1–2): 28–50. Gabbert, Wolfgang. 2006. “Concepts of Ethnicity.” Latin American and Caribbean Ethnic Studies 1 (1): 85–103. Gabbert, Wolfgang. 2015. “Ethnicity in History.” In Ethnicity as a Political Resource. Conceptualizations Across Disciplines, Regions, and Periods, edited by University of Cologne Forum, 183–200. Bielefeld: transcript Verlag. Bird-David, Nurit. 2017. “Before Nation. Scale-Blind Anthropology and Foragers’ Worlds of Relatives.” Current Anthropology 58 (2): 209–219. McCulloch, Anne M., and David E. Wilkins. 1995. “'Constructing’ Nations Within States: The Quest for Federal Recognition by the Catawba and Lumbee Tribes.” American Indian Quarterly 19 (3): 361–388. Trigger, Bruce G. 1987. The Children of Aataentsic: A History of the Huron People to 1660. Montreal: McGill Queens University Press. MacLeitch, Gail D. 2011. Imperial Entanglements: Iroquois Change and Persistence on the Frontiers of Empire. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press. Lafitau, Joseph Francois. 1724. Mœurs des Sauvages Américains Comparées aux Mœurs des Premiers Temps. 2 Vols. Paris: Saugrain l'aîné – Hochereau. Morgan, Lewis Henry. 1851. League of the H O-D E'-N O-S A U-N E E or Iroquois. Rochester: Sage & Brother, Publishers. Tooker, Elisabeth. 1978. “The League of the Iroquois: Its History, Politics, and Ritual.” In Handbook of North American Indians, edited by Bruce G. Trigger, Vol. 15, 418–441. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution. Trigger, Bruce G. 1987. The Children of Aataentsic: A History of the Huron People to 1660. Montreal: McGill Queens University Press. Lafitau, Joseph Francois. 1724. Mœurs des Sauvages Américains Comparées aux Mœurs des Premiers Temps. 2 Vols. Paris: Saugrain l'aîné – Hochereau. Jesuit Relations. The Jesuit Relations and Allied Documents. Travels and Explorations of the Jesuit Missionaries in New France, 1610–1791. Edited by Reuben G. Thwaites. 73 vols (1896–1901). Cleveland, OH: The Burrows Brothers Company. Morgan, Lewis Henry. 1851. League of the H O-D E'-N O-S A U-N E E or Iroquois. Rochester: Sage & Brother, Publishers. Charlevoix, Pierre François-Xavier de. 1761. Journal of a Voyage to North-America Undertaken by Order of the French King. 2 Vols. London: R. and J. Dodsley. First edition in French 1744. Sagard-Théodat, Gabriel. [1632] 1939. The Long Journey to the Country of the Hurons. Edited by George Toronto. Champlain Society. Heidenreich, Conrad E. 1978. “Huron.” In Handbook of North American Indians, edited by Bruce G. Trigger, Vol. 15, 368–388. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution. Lee, Wayne E. 2007. “Peace Chiefs and Blood Revenge: Patterns of Restraint in Native American Warfare, 1500–1800.” The Journal of Military History 71 (3): 701–741. Brandão, José António. 1997. “Your Fyre Shall Burn No More”: Iroquois Policy Toward New France and Its Native Allies to 1701. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press. Jesuit Relations. The Jesuit Relations and Allied Documents. Travels and Explorations of the Jesuit Missionaries in New France, 1610–1791. Edited by Reuben G. Thwaites. 73 vols (1896–1901). Cleveland, OH: The Burrows Brothers Company. Radisson, Peter Esprit. 1885. Voyages of Peter Esprit Radisson, Being an Account of his Travels and Experiences among the North American Indians, from 1652 to 1684. Transcribed from Original Manuscripts in the Bodleian Library and the British Museum. Boston, MA: John Wilson & Son. Lafitau, Joseph Francois. 1724. Mœurs des Sauvages Américains Comparées aux Mœurs des Premiers Temps. 2 Vols. Paris: Saugrain l'aîné – Hochereau. Sagard-Théodat, Gabriel. [1632] 1939. The Long Journey to the Country of the Hurons. Edited by George Toronto. Champlain Society. Donohoe, Felicity. 2013. “Dancing with Scalps. Native North American Women, White Men and Ritual Violence in the Eighteenth Century.” PhD diss., University of Glasgow. Charlevoix, Pierre François-Xavier de. 1761. Journal of a Voyage to North-America Undertaken by Order of the French King. 2 Vols. London: R. and J. Dodsley. First edition in French 1744. Charlevoix, Pierre François-Xavier de. 1761. Journal of a Voyage to North-America Undertaken by Order of the French King. 2 Vols. London: R. and J. Dodsley. First edition in French 1744. Nation Iroquoise. [c. 1664] 2003. Nation Iroquoise: A Seventeenth-Century Ethnography of the Iroquois. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press. Pomedli, Michael M. 1991. Ethnophilosophical and Ethnolinguistic Perspectives on the Huron Indian Soul. Lewiston: The Edwin Mellen Press. Jesuit Relations. The Jesuit Relations and Allied Documents. Travels and Explorations of the Jesuit Missionaries in New France, 1610–1791. Edited by Reuben G. Thwaites. 73 vols (1896–1901). Cleveland, OH: The Burrows Brothers Company. Megapolensis, Johannes. [1644] 1792. “A Short ACCOUNT of the MAQUAAS INDIANS, in New-Netherland, Their Country, Stature, Dress, Customs and Magistrates.” In Historical Collections; Consisting of State Papers, and Other Authentic Documents; Intended as Materials for An History of the United States of America, edited by Ebenezer Hazard, Vol. 1, 517–526. Philadelphia: T. Dobson. Charlevoix, Pierre François-Xavier de. 1761. Journal of a Voyage to North-America Undertaken by Order of the French King. 2 Vols. London: R. and J. Dodsley. First edition in French 1744. Jesuit Relations. The Jesuit Relations and Allied Documents. Travels and Explorations of the Jesuit Missionaries in New France, 1610–1791. Edited by Reuben G. Thwaites. 73 vols (1896–1901). Cleveland, OH: The Burrows Brothers Company. Goddard, Ives. 1984. “Agreskwe, A Northern Iroquoian Deity.” In Extending the Rafters: Interdisciplinary Approaches to Iroquoian Studies, edited by Michael K. Foster, Jack Campisi, and Marianne Mithun, 229–235. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press. Wonderley, Anthony. 2009. At the Front of the Marvelous. Exploring Oral Narrative and Mythic Imagery of the Iroquois and Their Neighbors. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press. Goddard, Ives. 1984. “Agreskwe, A Northern Iroquoian Deity.” In Extending the Rafters: Interdisciplinary Approaches to Iroquoian Studies, edited by Michael K. Foster, Jack Campisi, and Marianne Mithun, 229–235. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press. Steckley, John L. 2007. Indigenous Studies: Words of the Huron. Waterloo, CA: Wilfrid Laurier University Press. Lee, Wayne E. 2007. “Peace Chiefs and Blood Revenge: Patterns of Restraint in Native American Warfare, 1500–1800.” The Journal of Military History 71 (3): 701–741. Wonderley, Anthony. 2009. At the Front of the Marvelous. Exploring Oral Narrative and Mythic Imagery of the Iroquois and Their Neighbors. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press. Gabbert, Wolfgang. 2020. “Human Sacrifice, Ritualised Violence and The Colonial Encounter in the Americas.” In The Cambridge World History of Violence, edited by Robert Antony, Stuart Carroll, and Caroline Dodds Pennock, 96–115. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Vol. III, 1500–1800 CE. Jesuit Relations. The Jesuit Relations and Allied Documents. Travels and Explorations of the Jesuit Missionaries in New France, 1610–1791. Edited by Reuben G. Thwaites. 73 vols (1896–1901). Cleveland, OH: The Burrows Brothers Company. Knowles, Nathaniel. 1940. “The Torture of Captives by the Indians of Eastern North America.” Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 82 (2): 151–225. Trigger, Bruce G. 1987. The Children of Aataentsic: A History of the Huron People to 1660. Montreal: McGill Queens University Press. Stueck, Adam. 2012. “A Place Under Heaven: Amerindian Torture and Cultural Violence in Colonial New France, 1609–1729.” PhD diss., Marquette University. Abler, Thomas S. 1980. “Iroquois Cannibalism: Fact Not Fiction.” Ethnohistory (Columbus, Ohio) 27 (4): 309–316. Abler, Thomas S., and Michael H. Logan. 1988. “The Florescence and Demise of Iroquoian Cannibalism: Human Sacrifice and Malinowski’s Hypothesis.” Man in the Northeast 35: 1–26. Stueck, Adam. 2012. “A Place Under Heaven: Amerindian Torture and Cultural Violence in Colonial New France, 1609–1729.” PhD diss., Marquette University. Schüren, Ute, and Wolfgang Gabbert. 2020. “Human Sacrifice and Ritualised Violence in the Americas Before the European Conquest.” In The Cambridge World History of Violence. Volume II, 500–1500 CE, edited by Matthew S. Gordon, Richard W. Kaeuper, and Harriet Zurndorfer, 390–410. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Gabbert, Wolfgang. 2020. “Human Sacrifice, Ritualised Violence and The Colonial Encounter in the Americas.” In The Cambridge World History of Violence, edited by Robert Antony, Stuart Carroll, and Caroline Dodds Pennock, 96–115. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Vol. III, 1500–1800 CE. Richter, Daniel K. 1992. The Ordeal of the Longhouse: The Peoples of the Iroquois League in the Era of European Colonization. Williamsburg, VA: University of North Carolina Press. Trigger, Bruce G. 1987. The Children of Aataentsic: A History of the Huron People to 1660. Montreal: McGill Queens University Press. Brandão, José António. 1997. “Your Fyre Shall Burn No More”: Iroquois Policy Toward New France and Its Native Allies to 1701. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press. Wallace, Anthony F.C. 1966. Religion. An Anthropological View. New York: Random House. Hoffman, Danny. 2011. The War Machines: Young Men and Violence in Sierra Leone and Liberia. Durham, NC: Duke University Press. Strathern, Andrew, and Pamela J. Stewart. 2013. “Religion and Violence in Pacific Island Societies.” In The Oxford Handbook of Religion and Violence, edited by Mark Juergensmeyer, Margo Kitts, and Michael Jerryson, 167–182. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Robarchek, Clayton, and Carole Robarchek. 2005. “Waorani Grief and the Witch-Killer's Rage. World View, Emotion, and Anthropological Explanation.” Ethos (Berkeley, CA) 33 (2): 206–230.