A comparison of balancing scores for estimating rate ratios of count data in observational studies

ABSTRACT

In this article, we conduct a Monte Carlo study to examine four balancing scores (BS1: propensity score, BS2: prognostic score, BS3: adjusted propensity score estimated by the estimated prognostic score, and BS4: adjusted propensity score estimated by the estimated prognostic score and other covariates) for adjusting bias in estimating the marginal and the conditional rate ratios of count data in observational studies. Simulation results show that BS1–BS4 are not much different in terms of estimating the marginal and the conditional rate ratios, however, choosing the appropriate matching algorithm is more important than selecting a balancing scores.

KEYWORDS:

• Count data
• Matching
• Observational studies
• Prognostic score
• Propensity score

MATHEMATICS SUBJECT CLASSIFICATION:

• 62P10
• 62P99