Dealing With Information Overload in Multifaceted Personal Informatics Systems

Abstract

Personal informatics systems are tools that capture, aggregate, and analyze data from distinct facets of their users’ lives. This article adopts a mixed-methods approach to understand the problem of information overload in personal informatics systems. We report findings from a 3-month study in which 20 participants collected multifaceted personal tracking data and used a system called Exist to reveal statistical correlations within their data. We explore the challenges that participants faced in reviewing the information presented by Exist, and we identify characteristics that exemplify “interesting” correlations. Based on these findings, we develop automated filtering mechanisms that aim to prevent information overload and support users in extracting interesting insights. Our approach deals with information overload by reducing the number of correlations shown to users by about 55% on average and increases the percentage of displayed correlations rated as interesting to about 81%, representing a 34 percentage point improvement over filters that only consider statistical significance at p < .05. We demonstrate how this curation can be achieved using objective data harvested by the system, including the use of Google Trends data as a proxy for subjective user interest.

Notes

¹ https://exist.io

² https://healthlab.tictrac.com

³ https://zenobase.com

⁴ https://gyrosco.pe

⁵ Additional findings from this analysis, including issues associated with information presentation, transparency, and fragmentation, are reported in Jones and Kelly (2016).

⁶ https://www.google.com/trends/

⁷ http://www.theweatherchannelmusic.com/

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Simon L. Jones

Simon L. Jones ([email protected], http://go.bath.ac.uk/simonjones) is a computer scientist with an interest in personal informatics, data mining, and information visualization; he is a Lecturer in human–computer interaction in the Department of Computer Science of the University of Bath.

Ryan Kelly

Ryan Kelly ([email protected], http://go.bath.ac.uk/rmkelly) is a researcher in human–computer interaction with an interest in visual representations of individual and collaborative action in digital technologies; he is a Research Associate in human–computer interaction in the Department of Computer Science of the University of Bath.