Abstract
In this article, I investigate how 2 young Tzotzil Mayan siblings playfully manipulate the sequential structure of adjacency pairs to align, to confront each other, and to challenge family roles and hierarchies. The young learners' intentional disruption reveals the early control of dialogic repetition typical of Mayan languages. More important, it illustrates the children's development of communicative competence as they reorganize greeting structures or reauthorize messages through frame shifts.
In the case of a greeting game, the siblings disrupt its inherent sequential structure using semantic counterpointing with different address terms. When conveying a question sent by an adult, the 4-year old playfully repeats it and recycles it across several turns in alignment with his younger brother and his grandfather. The subversion of the social organization of talk shows how the children interactively construct an emergent sibling culture that contests the social organization of the age-graded structure of the extended family.
The study contributes to the understanding of peer socialization in a small-scale society. One finds here how siblings' language play organizes and contests the social and moral order amidst everyday family life.
I dedicate this article to my beloved compadre Mol Petul Vaskis who passed away on December 20, 2005. His beautiful and eloquent Tzotzil will be deeply missed by his family and community. May his grandchildren remember the rhymes, stories, and advice he sweetly gave them and teach them to their children. I thank the Vaskis family of Nabenchauk, Zinacantan, Chiapas, México for their warmth and their unconditional support. I also acknowledge George Collier, Candy Goodwin and Amy Kyratzis's thoughtful comments and suggestions to a previous version of the manuscript. Research was funded by CONACYT Research Grant # 42585.
Notes
I dedicate this article to my beloved compadre Mol Petul Vaskis who passed away on December 20, 2005. His beautiful and eloquent Tzotzil will be deeply missed by his family and community. May his grandchildren remember the rhymes, stories, and advice he sweetly gave them and teach them to their children. I thank the Vaskis family of Nabenchauk, Zinacantan, Chiapas, México for their warmth and their unconditional support. I also acknowledge George Collier, Candy Goodwin and Amy Kyratzis's thoughtful comments and suggestions to a previous version of the manuscript. Research was funded by CONACYT Research Grant # 42585.
1 Age is given in years and months (years; months). Children's names are changed to respect the privacy of my collaborators.
3 M. H. CitationGoodwin (1990) also discusses parallelism in terms of “format tying” in children's arguments. See DuBois (in press) for parallel dialogic structures in what he calls “dialogic syntax.”
4 To quote some relevant studies, see CitationAissen, 1987; CitationBrazelton, Robey, & Collier, 1969; CitationBricker, 1973, Citation1974; CitationCancian, 1964; CitationG. Collier, 1975; Citationde León, 1998, Citation1999, Citation2001, Citation2005; CitationDevereaux, 1987; CitationGreenfield, 1997, Citation2004; CitationGreenfield, 2000, Citation2004; Brazelton, & Childs, 1989; CitationGreenfield & Childs, 1977; CitationHaviland, 1977, Citation1988, Citation1989, Citation1993, Citation1998, Citation2003, Citation2005; CitationMaynard, 2002; CitationRus & Collier, 2003; CitationVogt, 1970.
8 Examples are presented in Tzotzil orthographic conventions. Glosses: INT = interrogative; DEM = demonstrative; A = absolutive; 1 = first person; 2 = second person; CL = clitic.
9 The data were collected on May 25, 2004, in Nabenchauk, Zinacantan.
10 The extraction of the CVC verb root is normally done by young Tzotzil children at the onset of their first words. In fact, their early vocabularies are composed of mostly CVC roots (Citationde León, 1998, Citation1999). The same process has been documented in Tzeltal acquisition (CitationBrown, 1998).
11 In Citationde León (1998), I showed how Grandfather uses a register with parallel structure and alternating syntactic frames in his speech to young children.
Haviland
,
J. B.
1989
.
Sure, sure: Evidence and affect.
.
Text
,
9
:
27
–
68
.
Bricker
,
V.
1974
.
“
The ethnographic context of some traditional Mayan speech genres.
”
. In
Explorations in the ethnography of speaking
,
Edited by:
Bauman
,
R.
and
Sherzer
,
J.
368
–
388
.
Cambridge,
, England
:
Cambridge University Press.
.
Gossen
,
G. H.
1974a
.
Chamulas in the world of the sun: Time and space in a Maya oral tradition.
,
Cambridge, MA
:
Harvard University Press
.
Gossen
,
G. H.
1974b
.
“
To speak with a heated heart: Chamula canons of style and good performance.
”
. In
Explorations in the ethnography of speaking
,
Edited by:
Bauman
,
R.
and
Sherzer
,
J.
389
–
413
.
Cambridge,
, England
:
Cambridge University Press.
.
Fox
,
J.
1974
.
“
Our ancestors spoke in pairs: Rotinese views of language, dialect, and code.
”
. In
Explorations in the ethnography of speaking
,
Edited by:
Bauman
,
R.
and
Sherzer
,
J.
65
–
84
.
Cambridge,
, England
:
Cambridge University Press.
.
Goodwin
,
C.
and
Heritage
,
J.
1990
.
Conversational analyisis.
.
Annual Review of Anthropology
,
19
:
283
–
307
.
Aissen
,
J. L.
1987
.
Tzotzil clause structure.
,
Dordrecht,
, The Netherlands
:
D. Reidel.
.
Brazelton
,
T. B.
,
Robey
,
J. S.
and
Collier
,
G.
1969
.
Infant development in the Zinacanteco Indians of Southern Mexico.
.
Pediatrics
,
44
:
274
–
283
.
Bricker
,
V.
1973
.
Ritual humor in highland Chiapas.
,
Austin
:
University of Texas Press
.
Bricker
,
V.
1974
.
“
The ethnographic context of some traditional Mayan speech genres.
”
. In
Explorations in the ethnography of speaking
,
Edited by:
Bauman
,
R.
and
Sherzer
,
J.
368
–
388
.
Cambridge,
, England
:
Cambridge University Press.
.
Cancian
,
F.
1964
.
Interaction patterns in Zinacanteco families.
.
American Sociological Review
,
29
:
540
–
550
.
Collier
,
G.
1975
.
Fields of the Tzotzil: The ecological bases of tradition in Highland Chiapas.
,
Austin
:
University of Texas Press
.
de León
,
L.
1998
.
The emergent participant: Interactive patterns of socialization of Tzotzil (Mayan) children.
.
Journal of Linguistic Anthropology
,
8
:
131
–
161
.
de León
,
L.
1999
.
“
Verb roots and caregiver speech in Tzotzil Mayan acquisition.
”
. In
Language, cognition, and function
,
Edited by:
Michaelis
,
L.
and
Fox
,
B.
99
–
119
.
Stanford University: Stanford Center for Language and Information.
.
de León
,
L.
.
Paper presented at the annual meetings of the American Anthropological Association
.
Soldiers and curers: Children's play in Tzotzil and Ch'ol.
.
November
,
New Orleans, LA
de León
,
L.
2005
.
La llegada del alma: Lenguaje, infancia y socialización entre los Mayas de Zinacantán [The arrival of the soul: Language, childhood and socialization among the Mayans of Zinacantan].
,
Mexico City, México
:
CIESAS-INAH-CONACULTA.
.
Devereaux
,
L.
1987
.
“
Gender difference and the relations of inequality in Zinacantán.
”
. In
Dealing with inequality: Analysing gender relations in Melanesia and beyond
,
Edited by:
Strathern
,
M.
89
–
111
.
Cambridge,
, England
:
Cambridge University Press.
.
Greenfield
,
P. M.
and
Childs
,
C. P.
1977
.
Weaving skill, color terms, and pattern representation: Cultural influences and cognitive development among the Zincantecos of Southern Mexico.
.
Interamerican Journal of Psychology
,
2
:
23
–
48
.
Greenfield
,
P. M.
2004
.
Weaving generations together. Evolving creativity in the Maya of Chiapas.
,
Santa Fe, NM
:
Publications of the Santa Fe Center for Social Research
.
Greenfield
,
P. M.
2000
.
“
Culture and universals: Integrating social and cognitive development.
”
. In
Culture, thought, and development
,
Edited by:
Nucci
,
L. P.
,
Sace
,
G. B.
and
Turiel
,
E.
231
–
277
.
Mahwah, NJ
:
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
.
Greenfield
,
P. M.
2004
.
Weaving generations together. Evolving creativity in the Maya of Chiapas.
,
Santa Fe, NM
:
Publications of the Santa Fe Center for Social Research
.
Greenfield
,
P. M.
and
Childs
,
C. P.
1977
.
Weaving skill, color terms, and pattern representation: Cultural influences and cognitive development among the Zincantecos of Southern Mexico.
.
Interamerican Journal of Psychology
,
2
:
23
–
48
.
Haviland
,
J. B.
1977
.
Gossip, reputation and knowledge.
,
Chicago
:
The University of Chicago Press
.
Haviland
,
J. B.
1988
.
“We want to borrow your mouth”: Tzotzil marital squabble.
.
Anthropological Linguistics
,
30
:
395
–
447
.
Haviland
,
J. B.
1989
.
Sure, sure: Evidence and affect.
.
Text
,
9
:
27
–
68
.
Haviland
,
J. B.
1993
.
Anchoring, iconicity, and orientation, in Guugo Yimidhirr pointing gestures.
.
Journal of Linguistic Anthropology
,
3
:
3
–
45
.
Haviland
,
J. B.
1998
.
Early pointing gestures in Zinacantán.
.
Journal of Linguistic Anthropology
,
8
:
162
–
196
.
Haviland
,
J. B.
2003
.
“
How to point in Zinacantán.
”
. In
Pointing: Where language, culture, and cognition meet
,
Edited by:
Kita
,
S.
139
–
170
.
Mahwah, NJ and London
:
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
.
Haviland
,
J. B.
2005
.
Whorish old man one (animal) gentleman: The intertextual construction of enemies and selves.
.
Journal of Linguistic Anthropology
,
15
:
81
–
94
.
Maynard
,
A.
2002
.
Cultural teaching: The development of teaching skills in Maya sibling interactions.
.
Child Development
,
73
:
969
–
982
.
Rus
,
J.
and
Collier
,
G.
2003
.
“
A generation of crisis in the Central Highlands of Chiapas: The cases of Chamula and Zinacantán, 1974–2000
”
. In
Mayan lives, mayan utopias
,
Edited by:
Rus
,
J.
,
Hernández
,
A.
and
Mattiace
,
S.
33
–
61
.
Lanham, Md
:
Rowman y Littlefield.
.
Vogt
,
E. Z.
1970
.
The Zinacantecos of Mexico.
,
New York
:
Holt, Reinhart & Winston.
.
de León
,
L.
1999
.
“
Verb roots and caregiver speech in Tzotzil Mayan acquisition.
”
. In
Language, cognition, and function
,
Edited by:
Michaelis
,
L.
and
Fox
,
B.
99
–
119
.
Stanford University: Stanford Center for Language and Information.
.
Brody
,
J.
1994
.
“
Multiple repetitions in Tojolobal conversation.
”
. In
Repetition in discourse: Interdisciplinary perspectives
,
Vol. 2
Edited by:
Johnstone
,
B.
3
–
14
.
New York
:
Ablex.
.
Goodwin
,
C.
and
Heritage
,
J.
1990
.
Conversational analyisis.
.
Annual Review of Anthropology
,
19
:
283
–
307
.
Schegloff
,
E.
and
Sacks
,
H.
1973
.
Opening up closings.
.
Semiotica
,
8
:
289
–
327
.
Duranti
,
A.
1997a
.
Linguistic anthropology.
,
Cambridge,
, England
:
Cambridge University Press
.
de León
,
L.
1998
.
The emergent participant: Interactive patterns of socialization of Tzotzil (Mayan) children.
.
Journal of Linguistic Anthropology
,
8
:
131
–
161
.
de León
,
L.
1999
.
“
Verb roots and caregiver speech in Tzotzil Mayan acquisition.
”
. In
Language, cognition, and function
,
Edited by:
Michaelis
,
L.
and
Fox
,
B.
99
–
119
.
Stanford University: Stanford Center for Language and Information.
.
Brown
,
P.
1998
.
Conversational structure and language acquisition: The role of repetition in Tzeltal.
.
Journal of Linguistic Anthropology
,
8
:
197
–
221
.
de León
,
L.
1998
.
The emergent participant: Interactive patterns of socialization of Tzotzil (Mayan) children.
.
Journal of Linguistic Anthropology
,
8
:
131
–
161
.
Rindstedt
,
C.
and
Aronsson
,
K.
2002
.
Growing up monolingual in a bilingual community: The Quichua revitalization paradox.
.
Language in Society
,
31
:
721
–
742
.
Cekaite
,
A.
and
Aronsson
,
K.
2004
.
Repetition and joking in children's second language conversations: Playful recyclings in an immersion classroom.
.
Discourse Studies
,
6
:
373
–
392
.