Abstract
The paper analyzes the effects of military spending on economic growth in a small open stochastic endogenous growth model involving the supply-side and demand-side effects produced by military spending. We show that a rise in the military spending affects economic growth through four channels, including the crowding-out effect, the spin-off effect, the resource mobilization effect, and the portfolio effect. The net effect which depends on these four channels is ambiguous. Hence, we demonstrate that there exists an optimal defense burden that maximizes the economic growth rate.
Acknowledgments
We are grateful to the Editor and the anonymous referees for useful comments on the earlier version of this paper. Any remaining errors are our responsibility.
Disclosure Statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.
Notes
1 For the implications of the supply-side and demand-side effects, please also see Shieh, Lai, and Chang (Citation2002a), Dunne, Smith, and Willenbockel (Citation2005) Shieh, Chang, and Lai (Citation2007), Lin and Lee (Citation2006, Citation2012).
2 The implications of four channels can be stated as follows. The crowding-out effect implies that an increase in military spending will reduce aggregate investment and hence has a negative effect on the expected growth rate. The spin-off effect indicates that a rise in military spending has positive externalities on private production. Obviously, the impact of the spin-off effect on the expected growth rate is positive. The resource mobilization effect implies that a rise in military spending affects the private sector’s consumption propensity and hence has an ambiguous effect on the expected growth rate. The portfolio effect argues that a rise in military spending affects the private sector’s portfolio and then has an ambiguous effect on the expected growth rate.
3 The similar specification of the utility function can also be seen in Brito (Citation1972), Deger and Sen (Citation1983, Citation1984), van der Ploeg and de Zeeuw (Citation1990), Zou (Citation1995), Chang, Tsai, and Lai (Citation1996), Gong and Zou (Citation2003), Lin and Lee (Citation2006, Citation2012), Shieh, Chang, and Lai (Citation2007), and Lee and Lin (Citation2012).
4 Although these may be standard assumptions in these models, for Equation (Equation2
(2) ) point out that foreign military expenditure is exogenous, and that home military expenditure is a fixed share of output, h is a parameter it is not chosen optimally. So this is not an arms race model where military expenditure is endogenous. This point is suggested by an anonymous referee, to whom we are grateful.
6 We stress the importance of the supply-side effect and hence let α ≠ 0 holds.
8 Combining m = hz and Equation (Equation3
(3) ) can obtain z = (ahα)1/(1 − α)k, as shown in Equation (Equation5
(5) ).
9 For the proof, please see Appendix 1 which states the analytical process of macroeconomic equilibrium.
10 The expected growth rate has been derived in Appendix 1.
12 For the same notion, please refer to Dixit and Pindyck (Citation1994, 107) and Kamien and Schwartz (Citation1991, 269).
13 For the same notion, please refer to Turnovsky (Citation2000, ch. 15).
Shieh, J. Y., C. C. Lai, and W. Y. Chang. 2002a. “Endogenous Growth and Defense Expenditures: A New Explanation of the Benoit Hypothesis.” Defence and Peace Economics 13: 179–186. Dunne, J. P., R. P. Smith, and D. Willenbockel. 2005. “Models of Military Expenditure and Growth: A Critical Review.” Defence and Peace Economics 16: 449–461.10.1080/10242690500167791 Shieh, J. Y., W. Y. Chang, and C. C. Lai. 2007. “An Endogenous Growth Model of Capital and Arms Accumulation.” Defence and Peace Economics 18: 557–575.10.1080/10242690701261658 Lin, P. S., and C. T. Lee. 2006. “Military Spending, Stochastic Growth and Welfare.” Academia Economic Papers 34: 127–160. Lin, P. S., and C. T. Lee. 2012. “Military Spending, Threats and Stochastic Growth.” Bulletin of Economic Research 64: 8–19.10.1111/boer.2012.64.issue-1 Brito, D. 1972. “A Dynamic Model of an Armaments Race.” International Economic Review 13: 359–375.10.2307/2526030 Deger, S., and S. Sen. 1983. “Military Expenditure, Spin-off and Economic Development.” Journal of Development Economics 13: 67–83.10.1016/0304-3878(83)90050-0 Deger, S., and S. Sen. 1984. “Optimal Control and Differential Game Models of Military Expenditures in Less Developed Countries.” Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 7: 153–169.10.1016/0165-1889(84)90004-6 van der Ploeg, F., and A. de Zeeuw. 1990. “Perfect Equilibrium in a Model of Competitive Arms Accumulation.” International Economic Review 31: 131–146.10.2307/2526633 Zou, H. F. 1995. “A Dynamic Model of Capital and Arms Accumulation.” Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 19: 371–393.10.1016/0165-1889(93)00786-4 Chang, W. Y., H. F. Tsai, and C. Lai. 1996. “Effects of Anticipated Foreign Military Threat on Arms Accumulation.” Southern Economic Journal 63: 507–514.10.2307/1061184 Gong, L., and H. F. Zou. 2003. “Military Spending and Stochastic Growth.” Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 28: 153–170.10.1016/S0165-1889(02)00134-3 Lin, P. S., and C. T. Lee. 2006. “Military Spending, Stochastic Growth and Welfare.” Academia Economic Papers 34: 127–160. Lin, P. S., and C. T. Lee. 2012. “Military Spending, Threats and Stochastic Growth.” Bulletin of Economic Research 64: 8–19.10.1111/boer.2012.64.issue-1 Shieh, J. Y., W. Y. Chang, and C. C. Lai. 2007. “An Endogenous Growth Model of Capital and Arms Accumulation.” Defence and Peace Economics 18: 557–575.10.1080/10242690701261658 Lee, C. T., and P. S. Lin. 2012. “Military Threats and Growth: A Small Open Stochastic Growth Model.” Journal of Economics and Management 8: 259–282. Turnovsky, S. J. 2000. Methods of Macroeconomic Dynamics. 2nd ed. London: MIT Press. Lin, P. S., and C. T. Lee. 2012. “Military Spending, Threats and Stochastic Growth.” Bulletin of Economic Research 64: 8–19.10.1111/boer.2012.64.issue-1 Shieh, J. Y., W. Y. Chang, and C. C. Lai. 2007. “An Endogenous Growth Model of Capital and Arms Accumulation.” Defence and Peace Economics 18: 557–575.10.1080/10242690701261658 Shieh, J. Y., C. C. Lai, and W. Y. Chang. 2002a. “Endogenous Growth and Defense Expenditures: A New Explanation of the Benoit Hypothesis.” Defence and Peace Economics 13: 179–186. Shieh, J. Y., C. C. Lai, and W. Y. Chang. 2002b. “The Impact of Military Burden on Long-run Growth and Welfare.” Journal of Development Economics 68: 443–454.10.1016/S0304-3878(02)00022-6 Lin, P. S., and C. T. Lee. 2012. “Military Spending, Threats and Stochastic Growth.” Bulletin of Economic Research 64: 8–19.10.1111/boer.2012.64.issue-1 Deger, S., and S. Sen. 1995. “Military Expenditure and Developing Countries.” In Handbook of Defense Economics, vol. 1, edited by K. Hartley and T. Sandler, 275–307. Amsterdam: Elsevier.10.1016/S1574-0013(05)80013-4 Shieh, J. Y., C. C. Lai, and W. Y. Chang. 2002a. “Endogenous Growth and Defense Expenditures: A New Explanation of the Benoit Hypothesis.” Defence and Peace Economics 13: 179–186. Lin, P. S., and C. T. Lee. 2006. “Military Spending, Stochastic Growth and Welfare.” Academia Economic Papers 34: 127–160. Lin, P. S., and C. T. Lee. 2012. “Military Spending, Threats and Stochastic Growth.” Bulletin of Economic Research 64: 8–19.10.1111/boer.2012.64.issue-1 Dixit, A. K., and R. S. Pindyck. 1994. Investment under Uncertainty. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Kamien, M. I., and N. L. Schwartz. 1991. Dynamic Optimization the Calculus of Variations and Optimal Control in Economic and Management. 2nd ed. Amsterdam: North-Holland. Turnovsky, S. J. 2000. Methods of Macroeconomic Dynamics. 2nd ed. London: MIT Press.