Figures & data
Figure 1. Stylized example of individual vs contextual effects. Dark dots represent cases from participant 1, clear dots from participant 2. Although participant 1 is less confident than 2, there is no effect of (average) individual confidence on the willingness to accept advice. There is, however, an effect of the contextual confidence: participants are less likely to accept advice for cases about which they are more confident (even though the case about which participant 1 is most confident, is a lower confidence level than even the lowest of participant 2).
Figure 2. The instruction text explaining the algorithmic advice.
Figure 3. Example of a (real) article as used in the experiment.
Figure 4. Visualisation of the procedure per news article.
Figure 5. Visualizations of the estimated effects of individual and contextual confidence on trust (left: following advice; right: asking for advice).
Table 1. Multi-level logistic regression models for trust in advice and task performance.
Figure 6. Visualization of the estimated effects of individual and contextual confidence on task performance.
