Abstract
Labour market and social policies both affect and are affected by the process of trade liberalization and globalization. This two‐way interaction and the feedback effects are the focus of this paper. The analysis is mainly conceptual—but examples are illustrated throughout, based mainly in the context of labour markets in North America, Latin America and the Caribbean basin. Attention is paid to outlining the mechanisms whereby globalization and trade liberalization affect labour market and social policy initiatives, and the extent to which these pressures will lead to a harmonization of legislative and policy initiatives, and if that harmonization will necessarily be downward to the lowest common denominator. The paper concludes that: (1) the pressures will lead towards policy harmonization; (2) the harmonization generally will be downwards; (3) such harmonization is not always negative as generally perceived; (4) efficient regulatory and social policy initiatives will survive and indeed expand, with the “rent‐protecting” ones under most pressure to dissipate; and (5) pure distributional or equity‐oriented initiatives that have no positive feedback effect on efficiency, unfortunately, will also be under jeopardy to dissipate, and this is a serious policy concern. Alternatives for addressing this concern are discussed, as are their associated problems.
Notes
* Andrew Downes, Sir Arthur Lewis Institute of Social and Economic Studies, University of the West Indies, Cave Hill Campus, Barbados. Rafael Gomez (to whom correspondence should be addressed), Interdisciplinary Institute of Management, London School of Economics, Houghton Street, London WC2A 2AE, UK, and Centre for Industrial Relations and the Centre for International Studies at the University of Toronto. Morley Gunderson, University of Toronto and Centre for Industrial Relations and the Department of Economics.
For a discussion of the various dimensions of the deepening and widening of economic integration, see Castro‐Rea (Citation1996), Gunderson (Citation2001) and Gomez & Gunderson (Citation2002).
The issue of underinvestment in training in Latin America is emphasized in Berry (Citation2001) and Berry & Méndez (Citation1998). Possible market failures that can lead to underinvestment in training are discussed in Gunderson & Riddell (Citation2001b).
Gunderson & Riddell (Citation2001a). Cortázar (Citation2001) outlined negative effects of unemployment insurance (UI) in terms of increasing unemployment and fraud through people working in the underground economy while collecting UI. To alleviate these problems, he recommended mandatory UI savings accounts that the individual worker can draw on if unemployed. These would also replace the traditional high severance payments that are prominent in Latin America.
In spite of the reasons why minimum wages may be an exceedingly blunt instrument for reducing poverty, Morley (Citation1995) and Lustig & McLeod (Citation1997) found that minimum wage increases have been associated with reductions in poverty in Latin America.
Evidence of multinationals providing better pay and working conditions than domestic producers in the host countries is provided in Lim (Citation1976), OECD (Citation1999) and Jenkins (Citation1990), although Forrest (Citation1993) found that multinationals in Guadalajara, Mexico, did not do so.
For a discussion of the lack of enforcement in Mexico, see Areous (Citation1994).
This legislative‐induced shift to the informal sector is discussed in Harrison & Leamer (Citation1997), Lee (Citation1997), Maskus (Citation1997) and Portes (Citation1990). The growth of non‐standard employment in the USA, Canada and Mexico since the mid‐1980s is documented in a recent report of the North American Agreement on Labour Co‐operation (NAALC, 1996) and discussed in Roberts et al. (Citation1996).
With respect to the growth dimension, Rama (Citation1995) found that labour regulations such as minimum wages, severance pay or mandatory benefits tended not to have a negative effect on output growth, based on data from 30 Latin American countries.
Evidence that foreign direct investment is not attracted to countries of low labour standards is discussed in Stern (Citation1999, p. 21).
This is analogous to the idea that the main rationale for NAFTA was not so much to get the direct benefits from free trade, but rather to “lock in” the market‐oriented reforms that were occurring in Mexico (Prestowitz et al., Citation1991).
Aparicio‐Valdez (Citation1995) discussed such accords in Latin America and the Caribbean.
Castro‐Rea
J
(1996)
Towards a single North American policy? The effects of NAFTA on Mexican and Canadian domestic politics
in: C. Paraskevopoulos, R. Grinspun & G. Eaton (Eds)
Economic Integration in the Americas
(Brookfield, Edward Elgar)
pp. 88–102
Gunderson
M
(2001)
North American economic integration and globalization
in: P. Grady & A. Sharpe (Eds)
The State of Economics in Canada: Festschrift in Honour of David Slater
Kingston, Queen's University Press)
pp. 355–377
Gomez
R
Gunderson
M
(2002)
The integration of labour markets in North America
in: G. Hoberg (Ed.)
Capacity for Choice: Canada in the North American Economy
(Toronto, University of Toronto Press)
Berry
A
(2001)
Dangers and challenges: the new context of labor market policy in Latin America and in Canada
in: A. Berry (Ed.)
Labor Market Policies in Canada and Latin America: Challenges of the New Millennium
(Boston, Kluwer Academic)
pp. 1–50
Berry
A
Méndez
MT
(1998)
Training in Latin America: Its Impact and Potential for Growth, Employment, Equity and Poverty Alleviation
(Geneva, International Labour Office)
Gunderson
M
Riddell
C
(2001b)
Training in Canada
in: A. Berry (Ed.)
Labor Market Policies in Canada and Latin America: Challenges of the New Millennium
(Boston, Kluwer Academic)
pp. 243–267
Gunderson
M
Riddell
C
(2001a)
Unemployment insurance: lessons from Canada
in: A. Berry (Ed.)
Labor Market Policies in Canada and Latin America: Challenges of the New Millennium
(Boston, Kluwer Academic)
pp. 69–98
Cortázar
R
(2001)
Unemployment insurance systems for Latin America
in: A. Berry (Ed.)
Labor Market Policies in Canada and Latin America: Challenges of the New Millennium
(Boston, Kluwer Academic)
pp. 97–108
Morley
S
(1995)
Poverty and Inequality in Latin America: The Impact of Adjustment and Recovery in the 1980s
(Washington, Johns Hopkins University Press)
Lustig
N
McLeod
D
(1997)
Minimum wages and poverty in developing countries: a cross‐section analysis for developing countries
in: S. Edwards & N. Lustig (Eds)
Labor Market Reform in Latin America: Combining Social Protection and Market Flexibility
(Washington, Brookings Institute)
pp. 62–103
Lim
,
D
.
(1976)
.
Do foreign companies pay higher wages than their local counterparts in Malaysian manufacturing?
.
Journal of Development Economics
,
4
:
pp. 55–66
OECD
(1999)
Measuring Globalisation: The Role of Multinationals in OECD Countries
(Paris, Organization for Economic Co‐Operation and Development)
Jenkins
,
R
.
(1990)
.
Comparing foreign subsidiaries and local firms in LDCs: theoretical issues and empirical evidence
.
Journal of Development Studies
,
26
:
pp. 205–228
Forrest
,
D
.
(1993)
.
Relative earnings of permanent and casual employees in a Mexican city
.
Journal of Economic Studies
,
20
:
pp. 3–17
Myrdal
G
(1957)
Economic Theory and Underdeveloped Regions
(London, Duckworth)
Gunderson
,
M
.
(1996)
.
Regional productivity and income convergence in Canada under increasing economic integration
.
Canadian Journal of Regional Science
,
29
:
pp. 1–24
Areous
GB
(1994)
The Mexican model of labor regulation and competitive strategies
in: M. Cook & H. Katz (Eds)
Regional Integration and Industrial Relations in North America
(Ithaca, ILR Press)
pp. 52–65
Harrison
,
A
and
Leamer
,
E
.
(1997)
.
Labor markets in developing countries: an agenda for research
.
Journal of Labor Economics
,
15
:
pp. S1–S20
Lee
,
E
.
(1997)
.
Globalization and labour standards: a review of the issues
.
International Labour Review
,
136
:
pp. 173–190
Maskus
K
(1997)
Should core labor standards be imposed through international trade policy?
World Bank Working Paper 1817
Washington, DC
Portes
A
(1990)
When more can be less: labor standards, development and the informal economy
in: S. Herzenberger & J. Perez‐Lopez (Eds)
Labor Standards and Development in the Global Economy
(Washington, DC, US Department of Labor)
Roberts
K
Hyatt
D
Dorfman
P
(1996)
The effect of free trade on contingent work in Michigan
in: K. Roberts & M. Wilson (Eds)
Policy Choices: Free Trade Amongst NAFTA Nations
(East Lansing, MI, Michigan State University Press)
pp. 235–260
Rama
,
M
.
(1995)
.
Do labour market policies and institutions matter: the adjustment experience in Latin America and the Caribbean
.
Labour
,
24
:
pp. S243–S268
Stern
,
R
.
(1999)
.
Labor standards and international trade
.
Integration and Trade
,
3
:
pp. 15–38
Prestowitz
C, Jr
Cohen
R
Morici
P
Tonelsm
A
(1991)
The New North American Order
(Washington, DC, Economic Strategy Institute)
Banting
K
Simeon
R
(1997)
Changing economies, changing societies
in: K. Banting, G. Hoberg & R. Simeon (Eds)
Degrees of Freedom: Canada and the United States in a Changing World
(Montreal and Kingston, McGill‐Queen's University Press)
pp. 23–70
Banting
K
Hoberg
G
Simeon
R
(1997)
Introduction
in: K. Banting, G. Hoberg & R. Simeon (Eds)
Degrees of Freedom: Canada and the United States in a Changing World
(Montreal and Kingston, McGill‐Queen's University Press)
pp. 3–22
Cassella
A
(1996)
Free trade and evolving standards
in: J. Bhagwati & R. Hudec (Eds) Fair Trade and Harmonization:
1
Economic Analysis
(Cambridge, MA, MIT Press)
pp. 119–156
Fields
G
(1995)
Trade and Labour Standards: A Review of the Issues
(Paris, Organization for Economic Co‐operation and Development)
Fields
G
Wan
H
Jr
(1989)
Wage setting institutions and economic growth
World Development
17
pp. 1471–1483
Freeman
R
(1994)
A hard‐headed look at labour standards
in: W. Sengenberger & D. Campbell (Eds)
Creating Economic Opportunities: The Role of Labour Standards in Economic Restructuring
(Geneva, International Labour Organization)
pp. 79–92
Stern
,
R
.
(1999)
.
Labor standards and international trade
.
Integration and Trade
,
3
:
pp. 15–38
Berry
,
A
.
(1997)
.
The income distribution threat in Latin America
.
Latin American Research Review
,
32
:
pp. 3–40
Berry
A
(2001)
Dangers and challenges: the new context of labor market policy in Latin America and in Canada
in: A. Berry (Ed.)
Labor Market Policies in Canada and Latin America: Challenges of the New Millennium
(Boston, Kluwer Academic)
pp. 1–50
Cline
W
(1997)
Trade and Wage Inequality
(Washington, DC, Institute for International Economics)
Richardson
,
D
.
(1995)
.
Income inequality and trade
.
Journal of Economic Perspectives
,
9
:
pp. 33–55
Wood
,
A
.
(1996)
.
How trade hurt unskilled workers
.
Journal of Economic Perspectives
,
9
:
pp. 57–80
Feenstra
,
R
and
Hanson
,
G
.
(1997)
.
Foreign direct investment and relative wages: evidence from Mexico's maquilladoras
.
Journal of International Economics
,
42
:
pp. 371–393
Brown
D
Deardorf
A
Stern
R
(1996)
International labor standards and trade: a theoretical analysis
in: J. Bhagwati & R. Hudec (Eds) Fair Trade and Harmonization:
1
Economic Analysis
(Cambridge, MA, MIT Press)
pp. 227–280
Charnovitz
,
S
.
(1992)
.
Environmental and labor standards and trade
.
The World Economy
,
15
:
pp. 335–356
Erickson
,
C
and
Mitchell
,
D
.
(1996)
.
Labour standards in international trade agreements
.
Labour Law Journal
,
47
:
pp. 763–773
Fields
G
(1995)
Trade and Labour Standards: A Review of the Issues
(Paris, Organization for Economic Co‐operation and Development)
Gunderson
,
M
.
(1999)
.
Labour standards, income distribution and trade
.
Integration and Trade
,
3
:
pp. 87–104
Maskus
K
(1997)
Should core labor standards be imposed through international trade policy?
World Bank Working Paper 1817
Washington, DC
Aparicio‐Valdez
,
L
.
(1995)
.
Hemispheric integration and labour laws
.
International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations
,
11
:
pp. 99–111
Additional information
Notes on contributors
* Andrew Downes, Sir Arthur Lewis Institute of Social and Economic Studies, University of the West Indies, Cave Hill Campus, Barbados. Rafael Gomez (to whom correspondence should be addressed), Interdisciplinary Institute of Management, London School of Economics, Houghton Street, London WC2A 2AE, UK, and Centre for Industrial Relations and the Centre for International Studies at the University of Toronto. Morley Gunderson, University of Toronto and Centre for Industrial Relations and the Department of Economics.