156
Views
5
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

Developing Psychogeriatric Services in England: A Turning Point in the 1960s?

Pages 40-72 | Published online: 15 Jun 2015
 

Abstract

Attitudes towards autonomy and personal freedom changed in the 1960s in England, but hardly touched the needs of dependent older people. In particular, deeply embedded public and professional attitudes and priorities linked to little change in ‘psychogeriatric’ treatment for those who were mentally unwell. Total beds in psychiatric hospitals decreased, but those remaining were increasingly and disproportionately occupied by older people receiving custodial care, often long term, despite evidence that appropriate treatment could prevent admission and facilitate discharge. Widely publicised scandals of inhumane care of older people in psychiatric hospitals prompted a more responsive government approach to improving services.

Acknowledgements

I am grateful to Professors Pat Thane, Tom Arie and David Jolley for their comments.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author.

Notes

  [2]CitationThane, Old Age; CitationMeans and Smith, Welfare Services.

  [3]CitationMartin, ‘Medical Knowledge’.

  [4]CitationShorter, History.

  [5]CitationPorter, Madness, 9.

  [6]CitationBarham, Closing the Asylum.

  [7]CitationJones, Asylums and After, 188.

  [8]CitationScull, Decarceration, 150.

  [9]CitationLock, Conundrum.

 [10]CitationBallenger, Self, Senility.

 [11] e.g. CitationBerrios, ‘Affective Disorders’.

 [12]CitationMinistry of Health, Survey; CitationMinistry of Health, Hospital Plan; Ministry of Health, ‘Care of the Mentally Disordered’, memo, 4 September 1964, D/M150/01 (National Archives (TNA), MH154/11).

 [13]CitationBeveridge, Social Insurance, 92.

 [14]CitationWebster, ‘The Elderly’, 187.

 [15] Ibid., 188.

 [16]CitationGranshaw, ‘Fame and Fortune’ 201–202.

 [17]CitationRosen, Specialisation, 4–5, 31, 66, 72.

 [18]CitationWillcox, ‘Fifty Years’, 9.

 [19]CitationMacmillan, ‘Problems’, 175.

 [20] Hospital designations, except in quotes or when spanning more than one period, follows official terminology: 1890–1930 ‘Asylum’; 1930–1959 ‘Mental Hospital’; 1960 ‘Psychiatric Hospital’.

 [21]CitationGranshaw, ‘Fame and Fortune’, 206.

 [22]CitationKay, Beamish and Roth, ‘Study of Prevalence’.

 [23]CitationLewis, ‘Ageing and Senility’, 151.

 [24] Total number of items identified for various search terms:

  • ‘Elderly mentally ill’; ‘Elderly mentally infirm’; ‘Old age psychiatry’; ‘Psychogeriatric’; ‘Psycho-geriatric’ 21.

  • ‘Care of the elderly’; ‘Chronic sick’; ‘Geriatric’ 200.

  • ‘Psychiatry’, >1000.

 [25]CitationJefferys, Oral History.

 [27] E-mail to author.

 [28]CitationWarren, ‘Chronic Sick’.

 [29]CitationPost, Persistent Persecutory, 15.

 [30]CitationWarren, ‘Chronic Sick’.

 [31] Alwyn Lishman, interviewer Margot CitationJefferys, in Oral History.

 [32] Bergmann in CitationHilton, Guthrie Trust Witness Seminar, 10.

 [33] Felix Post, interviewer Margot CitationJefferys in Oral History.

 [34] McDonald, ‘A Rehabilitation Programme for Chronic Psychogeriatric Patients’, 1977, 3, (Arie archives).

 [35]CitationRoth, ‘Natural History’.

 [36]CitationWhitehead, Service of Old Age, 23–31.

 [37]CitationMartin, Adventure.

 [38]CitationMinistry of Health, Mental Infirmity, 2.

 [39]CitationMinistry of Health, Treatment.

 [40]CitationRowntree, Old People, 2.

 [42]CitationMass Observation, ‘Old Age’, 2.

 [43]CitationPhillips Report, 27.

 [44] Ibid., 74.

 [45] Ibid., 9.

 [46] Ministry of Health, memo, ‘Care of the Aged’, (SAC(MH)(49)4) Para 3 (TNA, MH133/502).

 [47]CitationBrooke, ‘Recent Progress’, 209.

 [48]CitationPhillips Report, 74.

 [49]CitationMinistry of Health, Cost of the NHS, 219.

 [50]CitationAbel-Smith, ‘A Hospital Commissioner’, 128–130.

 [51]CitationOECD, ‘Health expenditure’.

 [52]CitationJones, Making of Social Policy, 209.

 [53]CitationButler, ‘Age-Ism’.

 [54]CitationComfort, ‘On gerontophobia’.

 [55] Levy, ‘Stereotype Embodiment’, 333.

 [56] Thane, Old Age, 406.

 [57]CitationTownsend, Family Life, 186.

 [58]CitationThomson, ‘The Elderly who Live Alone’, 477.

 [59]CitationMacmillan, ‘Preventive Geriatrics’, 1439.

 [60]CitationExton-Smith, ‘Investigation’, 186.

 [61]CitationBaker, Slow Euthanasia.

 [62]CitationMartin, ‘Medical Knowledge’, 450.

 [63]CitationRudd, Human Relations, 65.

 [64]CitationNorton, ‘Geriatric Nursing in Training’.

 [65] Lionel Cosin, interviewer Margot CitationJefferys, in Oral History.

 [66] Arie to author, e-mail, December 2011.

 [67]CitationArie, ‘Diagnosis and Assessment’, 541.

 [68]CitationCurrie, ‘Doctors and Ageism’.

 [69]CitationTownshend, ‘My Generation’.

 [70]CitationMcCartney and Lennon, ‘When I'm 64’.

 [71]CitationTownsend, Family Life, 28.

 [72]CitationThane, ‘Declining Birth-Rate’.

 [73]CitationRobinson, ‘Public Attitudes’.

 [74]CitationBBC, Hurt Mind.

 [75]CitationWHO, Mental Health Problems, 10.

 [76]CitationAnon. ‘Welfare Services’.

 [77]CitationWebster, ‘The Elderly’, 166.

 [78]CitationThane, ‘Equality’, 13.

 [79]CitationAge UK, ‘Our History’.

 [80]CitationAnon. ‘Living and partly living’.

 [81]CitationLaing and Esterson, Sanity, 31–264.

 [82]CitationGoffman, Asylums; CitationGoffman, Stigma.

 [83]CitationWalk, ‘Psychiatry in the 1870s’.

 [84]CitationMartin, Adventure.

 [85] Race Relations Act 1965; Sexual Offences Act 1967; Abortion Act 1967; Suicide Act 1961.

 [86]CitationPercy Report, 304–306.

 [87]CitationJones, 1845–1959, 184.

 [88]CitationPercy Commission, 44 files (TNA, MH121).

 [89]CitationPercy Report, 6.

 [90] Ibid., 27.

 [91]CitationBrooke, ‘Factors’.

 [93]CitationMinistry of Health, Report for the Year 1960, 96.

 [95]CitationMinistry of Health, Activities 1964, 8.

 [96]CitationDHSS, Statistics, 24.

 [97]CitationCook, Dax and Maclay, ‘Geriatric Problem’, 382.

 [99]CitationTownsend, ‘National Survey’, 229.

[100]CitationSmith, Gibb and Martin, ‘Metamorphosis’.

[101]CitationFine, ‘Disturbed Patient’.

[102] Tony Whitehead, ‘Avoiding Sedatives’, (AEGIS/1/10/A,32).

[103]CitationEnoch, ‘Elderly Disturbed’.

[104]CitationKidd, ‘Rejection’, 457.

[105]CitationKay, Roth and Hall, ‘Special Problems’, 971.

[106]CitationArie, ‘Day Care’, 89.

[107]CitationMinistry of Health, Health and Welfare, iii.

[108]CitationTooth and Brooke, ‘Trends’, 712.

[109] e.g. CitationSheldon, Social Medicine 196–198; and CitationRowntree, Old People, 48–54.

[110]CitationConnolly, ‘Social and Medical’, 97.

[111]CitationKay, Roth and Hall, ‘Special Problems'.

[112]CitationConnolly, ‘Social and Medical’, 99.

[113]CitationPowell, ‘Opening Speech’, 6.

[114]CitationCawley and McKeown, ‘Services’, 135.

[115]CitationMinistry of Health, Report for 1960, 98.

[116]CitationMinistry of Health, Hospital Plan, 5.

[117]Mental Health and Social Policy.

[118]CitationMinistry of Health, Care of the Aged.

[119]CitationWHO, Mental Health Problems.

[120]CitationFish and Williamson, ‘Delirium’.

[121]CitationKidd, ‘Misplacement’.

[122] Anon. ‘Psychogeriatric Assessment Unit’ (c. 1963) PP/RFK/C.8, Wellcome Library (WL).

[123] Rudolf Freudenberg, memo, ‘Psychogeriatric Units’, 30 October 1963, 2 PP/RFK/C.8 (WL).

[124]CitationMorton, Barker and Macmillan, ‘Joint Assessment’.

[125] Eric Morton, interviewer Margot Jefferys, in Oral History.

[126] Arie, interviewer Hazel Houghton, in Oral History.

[127]CitationWattis, ‘Geographical Variations’.

[128]CitationSheldon, Social Medicine; CitationRowntree, Old People.

[130]CitationTownsend, Family Life, 222–223.

[131]CitationParsons, ‘Swansea's Old Folk’.

[132]CitationWilliamson, Stokoe, Gray, and Fisher, ‘Old People at Home’.

[133]CitationWilliamson, ‘Screening’.

[134]CitationDepartment of Health, National Dementia Strategy.

[135]CitationCooper, Brown and Kalton, ‘Pilot Study’.

[136]CitationHopkins and Cooper, ‘Psychiatric Referral’.

[137]CitationSampey, ‘Trends’.

[138] e.g. CitationPost, ‘Senile Psychiatric Disorders’; and CitationEnoch, ‘Elderly Disturbed’.

[139] Morgannwg Hospital Management Committee, ‘Psychogeriatrics and Related Problems’ (1963) PP/RFK/C.8 (WL).

[140]CitationBergmann, ‘Mental Aspects’.

[141]CitationWatts and Watts, Psychiatry in General Practice, 140.

[142] Tony (Anthony) Whitehead, Cited in: Anon., ‘Aged ‘Could Be Spared Misery’’, Guardian, 7 October 1974, 6.

[143]CitationKay, Beamish and Roth, ‘Study of Prevalence’.

[144]CitationTownsend, Last Refuge, 281.

[145]CitationPhillips Report, 83.

[146]CitationBrothwood, ‘Organisation’, 99.

[148]CitationBrothwood, ‘Organisation’, 111.

[149]CitationPost, Significance.

[150]CitationPost, Persecutory States 7–8, 11.

[151]CitationWarren, ‘Chronic Sick’.

[152]CitationPost, Clinical Psychiatry of Late Life.

[153] Robinson in CitationHilton, Guthrie Trust Witness Seminar, 10.

[154] Arie, interview by author, 2004.

[155]CitationArie, ‘Remembering Felix’.

[157]CitationCorsellis, ‘Cerebral Degeneration’, 292.

[158]CitationCorsellis, Ageing Brain, 54.

[159]CitationAlzheimer, ‘On Certain Peculiar Diseases’, 75–76.

[160] E-mail to author.

[161]CitationSchwartz and Stark, ‘Distinction’, 178.

[162]CitationNHS, Findings; and CitationDHSS, Ely.

[163]CitationJones, 1845–1959, 25–29.

[164] Ibid., 100–101.

[165]CitationRowntree, Old People, 69–70.

[166]CitationTownsend, Last Refuge, 27.

[167] Robb and Tooth, meeting 25 May 1965 (AEGIS1/1,81–92).

[168] Ibid.

[169]CitationDHSS, Ely, 175.

[170]CitationAbel-Smith, ‘A Hospital Commissioner’, 133.

[171] Maurice Hackett, ‘Old People in Mental Hospitals’, Times, November 18, 1965, 13.

[172] Helen Hodgson, ‘Elderly Patients’. Guardian, March 29, 1966 (AEGIS, 1/2/A,94).

[173] Lord Strabolgi et al. ‘Old People in Mental Hospitals’, Times, November 10, 1965, 13.

[174]CitationRobb, ‘Preface’, Sans Everything, xiii.

[175] Lord Strabolgi et al. ‘Old People in Mental Hospitals’, Times, November 10, 1965, 13.

[176]CitationFenton, ‘They Can Not Defend Themselves’, 34; CitationNHS, Findings, 19.

[177] Arie, e-mail, 26 April 2009.

[178]World in Action, Ward F 13 (Granada Television, 1968).

[179]CitationNHS, Findings, 1.

[180]CitationRobinson, Hansard.

[181] Sue Freeman, ‘A Problem that Can't be Whitewashed’, Daily Express 8 Aug 1968.

[182] e.g. CitationWhitehead, Service of Old Age, 13.

[183] David Roxan, ‘Heartbreak Hospitals’, News of the World, August 20, 1967, 7.

[184]CitationDHSS, Ely, 6.

[185] Ibid., 134–135.

[186]CitationHowe, Conflict of Loyalty, 41–42.

[187]CitationDHSS, Ely, 128–133.

[188] Ibid., 123.

[189]CitationCrossman, Diaries, 3, 727.

[190] Robb and Whitehead, ‘Some Doctors and the Ombudsman’, (Draft) (AEGIS/I/8).

[191]CitationBridgen, ‘Hospitals, Geriatric Medicine’, 521.

[192] Robb, note of phone call, December 1966 (AEGIS/1/3,18).

[193] Brice Pitt, interview by author, 2004.

[194] Klaus Bergmann, interview by author, 2004.

[196]CitationGittins, Madness, 67–89.

[197]CitationBarton, Institutional Neurosis.

[198] Russell Barton, interviewer Diana Gittins, GC/244/2/19,14 (WL).

[199]CitationWhitehead, Service of Old Age, 91–102.

[200]CitationJolley, ‘Russell Barton’, 234.

[201]CitationJolley, ‘Whitehead’.

[202]CitationWhitehead, ‘Comprehensive’, 586. (copy in TNA, MH160/486).

[203] Robb and Tooth (AEGIS/1/1 81–92).

[204] Probably, Dr Tooth to Dr Boucher, memo, 4 October 1965, (TNA, MH160/486).

[205] Tooth, memo, 30 September 1965, (TNA, MH160/486).

[206] HF, ‘D Macmillan’, BMJ, 119.

[207] Ministry of Health, ‘Provision of Psychiatric Services for the Elderly.’ 12 November 1965, 1 (TNA, MH160/486).

[208] Ibid., 3.

[209]CitationBrothwood, ‘Organisation’, 110.

[210] Ibid.

[211]CitationWhitehead, Service of Old Age, 95.

[212]CitationRollin, ‘Barton’.

[213] Catherine Storr to Whitehead, letter, 27 November 1967. Penguin Books.

[214] Barton, ‘Foreword’, In: CitationWhitehead, Service of Old Age, 9.

[215]CitationWhitehead, Service of Old Age, 28.

[216] Ibid., 35.

[217]CitationGittins, Madness, 89.

[218]CitationJolley, ‘Whitehead’.

[219]CitationGittins, Madness, 92.

[220]CitationAnon. ‘Elderly in Hospital’ (Identified by Arie as his work).

[221] Arie, e-mail, 26 April 2009.

[222] Arie, in Oral History.

[223]CitationArie, ‘First Year’, 1181.

[224] Ibid., 1179, 1180.

[225]CitationWarren, ‘Chronic Sick’.

[226] Arie, in Oral History.

[227]CitationFry, ‘Keppel Club’.

[228] Ibid., 1597.

[229]CitationDHSS, Assessment Units; covering letter, March 1970, ECN778 (King's Fund).

[230]Mental Health and Social Policy.

[231]CitationWebster, ‘The Elderly’, 187.

[232]CitationMurphy, ‘The New Journal’.

[233]CitationArie and Jolley, ‘Psychogeriatrics’, 262.

[234]CitationGuthrie Trust Witness Seminar, foot notes 52–53.

[235] Arie in CitationHilton, Guthrie Trust Witness Seminar, 47.

[236]CitationWright, ‘Society and the Individual’.

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Claire Hilton

Claire Hilton is a PhD student at King's College London and a Consultant Old Age Psychiatrist. Correspondence to: Claire Hilton, Brent Memory Service, Fairfields House, Roe Green, London, NW9 0PS, UK.

Log in via your institution

Log in to Taylor & Francis Online

PDF download + Online access

  • 48 hours access to article PDF & online version
  • Article PDF can be downloaded
  • Article PDF can be printed
USD 53.00 Add to cart

Issue Purchase

  • 30 days online access to complete issue
  • Article PDFs can be downloaded
  • Article PDFs can be printed
USD 273.00 Add to cart

* Local tax will be added as applicable

Related Research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.