Reading Ronaldo: contingent whiteness in the football media

Abstract

Ever since his introduction to the first team at Manchester United FC, Cristiano Ronaldo Dos Santos Aveiro has been recognized as one of the footballing world’s most stand out football players. In turn, Ronaldo has drawn the attention of scholars working across a number of disciplines. While sports economists and sociologists of sport, amongst others, have contributed to a growing literature about Ronaldo and the social implications of his on and off-field behaviour, few critical analyses have considered the racialized aspects of Ronaldo’s representations, or how audiences make sense of his racialized or ethnic identity. Using images of Ronaldo, which we presented to and discussed with self-identified physically active white British men, we explore what it is that representations and audience interpretations of Ronaldo reveal about the complexities of white male identity formation. We do this to understand better how white male identities can be read and interpreted through and in the context of football. Facilitated by our conception of contingent whiteness, we argue that white British men’s interpretations of Ronaldo’s whiteness are inextricably linked to discourses of ‘race’, masculinities and football.

Notes

1. Chadwick and Burton, ‘From Beckham to Ronaldo’, 2008; Papp-Váry, ‘The Use of Sports Celebrities in Advertising’, 2011.

2. Cashmore and Cleland, ‘Fans, Homophobia and Masculinities in Association Football’, 2012; Cole, ‘Jocks in Jocks: Sportsmen and Underwear Advertising,’ 2014. Hall and Gough, ‘Magazine and Reader Constructions of ‘Metrosexuality’and Masculinity’, 2011.

3. Carrington, ‘Fear of a Black Athlete’, 2002a; Carrington, Race, Representation and the Sporting Body, 2002b; Carrington and McDonald, ‘Race’, Sport and British Society, 2001; Hylton, Race and Sport, 2009; Vincent and Harris, ‘They Think It’s All Dover!’ Popular Newspaper Narratives and Images About the English Football Team and (Re)Presentations of National Identity During Euro’, 2013.

4. Carrington, ‘What’s the Footballer Doing Here?’ 2008, 427.

5. Frankenberg, White Women, Race Matters. The Social Construction of Whiteness, 1993; Jensen, The Heart of Whiteness: Confronting Race, Racism, and White Privilege, 2005.

6. Harris, ‘Whiteness as Property’, 1993.

7. Scheurich (1998, cited in Leonardo, 2004, 138).

8. Hartigan, ‘Establishing the Fact of Whiteness’, 1997, 496.

9. Garner, ‘The Uses of Whiteness: What Sociologists Working on Europe Can Draw from Us Research on Whiteness’, 2006; Garner, Whiteness: An Introduction, 2007.

10. Miles and Brown, Racism, 101.

11. Hall, The Spectacle of the ‘Other’, 2002; Stone et al., ‘White Men Can’t Jump’: Evidence for the Perceptual Confirmation of Racial Stereotypes Following a Basketball Game, 1997.

12. Hylton, Race and Sport, 2009; Long and Hylton, ‘Shades of White’, 2002.

13. Garner, Whiteness: An Introduction, 2007; Leonardo, ‘The Color of Supremacy: Beyond the Discourse of ‘White Privilege’, 2004.

14. Mills, Racial Exploitation and the Wages of Whiteness, 2004.

15. Gillborn, ‘Education Policy as an Act of White Supremacy’, 2005.

16. Ansley, White Supremacy (and What We Should Do About It), 1997, 592.

17. Astaire, Sol Searching: Authorised Biography, 2014.

18. BBC, ‘Sol Campbell: England Captaincy Race Claim Stuns Former FA Chief’, 2014.

19. hooks, Talking Back: Thinking Feminist, Thinking Black., 1989, 113.

20. Bonilla-Silva, Racism without Racists, 2003).

21. Bradbury, ‘Institutional Racism, Whiteness and the under-Representation of Minorities in Leadership Positions in Football in Europe’, 2013; Burdsey, ‘Obstacle Race’, 2004; King, Offside Racism: Playing the White Man, 2004a.

22. King, Play the White Man: The Theatre of Racialised Performance in the Institutions of Soccer, 2000, 5.

23. Bonilla-Silva, ‘The Linguistics of Color Blind Racism: How to Talk Nasty About Blacks without Sounding “Racist”’, 2002; Bonilla-Silva and Baiocchi, Anything but Racism: How Sociologists Limit the Significance of Racism, 2008; Hartigan, ‘Establishing the Fact of Whiteness’, 1997; hooks, Black Looks: Race and Representation, 1992.

24. Rabaka, ‘The Souls of White Folk: W.E.B. Du Bois’s Critique of White Supremacy and Contributions to Critical White Studies’, 2007, 2.

25. Doob, The White Racist Movement: Its Revelation, 2002; Glover, Ugly on the Diamonds: An Examination of White Privilege in Youth Baseball, 2007; Leonardo, The Color of Supremacy: Beyond the Discourse of ‘White Privilege’, 2004; McDonald, ‘Mapping Whiteness and Sport’, 2005; McIntosh, ‘White privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack’, 1989; Mills, White Ignorance, 2007.

26. Mac an Ghaill, Contemporary Racisms and Ethnicities: Social and Cultural Transformations, 1999; Mac an Ghaill, ‘The Irish in Britain: The Invisibility of Ethnicity and Anti-Irish Racism’, 2000; Mac an Ghaill, British Critical Theorists: The Production of the Conceptual Invisibility of the Irish Diaspora, 2001; Mac an Ghaill and Haywood, Gender, Culture and Society, 2007; Nayak, White Lives, 2005; Nayak, ‘After Race’, 2006.

27. Garner, ‘The Uses of Whiteness: What Sociologists Working on Europe Can Draw from Us Research on Whiteness’, 2006; Hylton, Race and Sport, 2009; Mac an Ghaill, Contemporary Racisms and Ethnicities: Social and Cultural Transformations, 1999; Mac an Ghaill, ‘The Irish in Britain: The Invisibility of Ethnicity and Anti-Irish Racism’, 2000.

28. Nayak, ‘After Race’, 2006, 417.

29. Satzewich, ‘Whiteness Limited’, 2006, 276.

30. Lewis, Long and Hylton, ‘Integration and Othering: The Experiences of Black and White New Migrants’, 2012; Long et al., Space for Inclusion? The Construction of Sport and Leisure Spaces as Places for Migrant Communities, 2011.

31. Roediger, The Wages of Whiteness, 1991; Teixeira and Rogers, America’s Forgotten Majority: Why the White Working Class Still Matters, 2000; Evans, Educational Failure and Working Class White Children in Britain, 2006.

32. Bérubé, How Gay Stays White and What Kind of White It Stays, 2003; Teunis, ‘Sexual Objectification and the Construction of Whiteness in the Gay Male Community’, 2007.

33. Dyer, White, 1997; Frankenberg, White Women, Race Matters, 1993; Travers, Women’s ‘Ski Jumping, the 2010 Olympic Games, and the Deafening Silence of Sex Segregation, Whiteness, and Wealth’, 2011; Ware, Beyond the Pale: White Women, Racism and History, 1992).

34. Mac an Ghaill, Contemporary Racisms and Ethnicities, 1999, 142.

35. Nayak, ‘After Race’, 2006.

36. Butler, Bodies That Matter: On the Discursive Limits of Sex, 1993.

37. Nayak, White Lives, 2005, 153.

38. Gillborn, ‘Education Policy as an Act of White Supremacy’, 2005, 489.

39. Thompson, ‘Summary of Whiteness Theory’, 2001.

40. King, Play the White Man, 2002; King, Offside Racism, 2004a; King, ‘Race and Cultural Identity’, 2004b.

41. Burdsey, ‘Obstacle Race’, 2004; Burdsey, British Asians and Football, 2007, 2011).

42. Ladson-Billings and Donnor, Waiting for the Call: The Moral Activist Role of Critical Race Theory Scholarship, 2008, 68.

43. Lawrence, ‘On White Men’s Representations of “Race”, Whiteness, Masculinities and “Otherness”’, 2013.

44. Frankenberg, White Women, Race Matters, 1993.

45. Brooks and Hébert, Gender, Race, and Media Representation, 2006.

46. Mason, Qualitative Researching, 1996, 56.

47. Yosso, Critical Race Media Literacy, 2002.

48. Marshall, ‘Sampling for Qualitative Research’, 1996.

49. Hall, The Spectacle of the ‘Other’, 1997.

50. Carrington, ‘Fear of a Black Athlete’, 2002a; Carrington, Race, Representation and the Sporting Body, 2002b.

51. Hylton, Race and Sport, 2009.

52. Ruiz, ‘Best Entertainer: Cristiano Ronaldo’, 2009, 36.

53. ibid., 36.

54. ibid., 36.

55. ibid., 36.

56. Beynon, Masculinities and Culture, 2002; Kimmel, The History of Men, 2005; Mac an Ghaill, Understanding Masculinities, 1996; Mac an Ghaill and Haywood, Gender, Culture and Society, 2007; Mangan, ‘Christ and the Imperial Playing Fields’, 2006.

57. O'Donnell, ‘Mapping the Mythical: A Geopolitics of National Sporting Stereotypes’, 1994.

58. Norman, ‘Embodying the Double-Bind of Masculinity’, 2011; Pringle, ‘Defamiliarizing Heavy-Contact Sports’, 2009.

59. Du Bois, Announcement, 2007 [1897], 8.

60. Nayak, ‘After Race’, 2006.

61. ‘Poxy’ is a generally derogatory adverb used in Britain.

62. Wagg, ‘Cristiano Meets Mr. Spleen’, 2010, 919–20.

63. Yuval-Davis, The Politics of Belonging : Intersectional Contestations, 2011, vii.

64. Mac an Ghaill, Contemporary Racisms and Ethnicities: Social and Cultural Transformations, 1999, 77.

65. Long and Hylton, ‘Shades of White’, 2002.

66. Mac an Ghaill, Contemporary Racisms and Ethnicities: Social and Cultural Transformations, 1999, 77–80.

67. Ladson-Billings and Donnor, Waiting for the Call: The Moral Activist Role of Critical Race Theory Scholarship, 2008, 68.

68. Lawrence, Representation, Racialisation and Responsibility, 2011, Lawrence, ‘On White Men’s Representations of “Race”, Whiteness, Masculinities and “Otherness”’, 2013.

69. Ladson-Billings and Donnor, Waiting for the Call: The Moral Activist Role of Critical Race Theory Scholarship, 2008, 286.