American soccer at a crossroad: MLS’s struggle between the exigencies of traditional American sports culture and the expectations of the global soccer community

ABSTRACT

With the formation of Major League Soccer (MLS) in 1996 the United States joined the soccer world by featuring a profession league on the very top of its soccer pyramid. However, over the past 25 years, MLS has encountered two formidable obstacle in its navigating treacherous waters. On the one side it faced the Scylla of the Big Four North American sports leagues that have created a sports culture that MLS entered but could not fully embrace; and on the other side MLS encountered the Charybdis of the global soccer world’s very own culture which MLS had to address and accord special attention. The paper highlights the tension that MLS has faced throughout its existence.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.

Correction Statement

This article has been republished with minor changes. These changes do not impact the academic content of the article.

Notes

1. Markovits and Rensmann, Gaming the World, 17-24.

2. We use the concept of core-semi-periphery-periphery as the crux of our presentation by following this framework developed by authors of the so-called ‘dependencia’ school of political economy best represented by scholars such as Andre Gunder Frank, Ernesto Laclau and, of course Immanuel Wallerstein.

3. Strutner et al. ‘Making Soccer “Major League” in the USA and Beyond’, 23–36.

4. Esser, ‘Take 2: Why Soccer Is Un-American and 10 Ways to Fix It.’

5. Guttmann, A Whole New Ball Game, 51-62.

6. Thorn, ‘History Awakens: 2 February 1876 and the Founding of the National League.’

7. Spirn, A Scientific Sport Fit for Gentlemen, 49-58.

8. Gorn et al. A Brief History of American Sports, 169-174.

9. Thus, for example, the federation was called United State Football Association (USFA) from its founding in 1913 until 1945 blithely ignoring the fact that the term ‘football’ had come to mean a different game in the United States. In 1945, the federation renamed itself United States Soccer Football Association (USSFA) still refusing to surrender the name ‘football’ to reality in the American sports space. Not until 1974 did the federation surrender the word ‘football’ in its appellation calling itself United States Soccer Federation (USSF) the name it continues to bear.

10. ‘What Was the Soccer War?’

11. Markovits, Tomlinson and Young, ‘Introduction: Mapping Sports Space’.

12. Markovits and Rensmann, Gaming the World, 95.

13. Norman, ‘Football Still Americans’ Favorite Sport to Watch.’

14. Borchers, ‘Analysis | The NFL Has the Most Protests. It Is Also the Most American Sports League.’

15. ‘NHL Totals by Nationality ‑ 2018‑2019 Stats.’

16. March 7, 20,182:45PM ESTMLS CommunicationsFollow@ mls_pr. ‘MLS Retains Status as Youngest, Most Diverse League in North America.’

17. ‘Global Club Soccer Rankings.’

18. Harris, ‘MLS TV Ratings Slump 19% during Regular Season; Playoffs Take a Nosedive.’

19. Comcast Corporation. ‘Premier League Pushing Huge Viewership Gains for NBC Sports Group.’

20. Harris, ‘MLS Fails to Close TV Ratings Gap with Premier League and Liga MX.’

21. Webb, ‘Why Soccer Is Un-American.’

22. Gough, ‘U.S. Major Sports: Average Attendance 2019.’

23. Werner, ‘Most-Watched Soccer Games on US TV for June 25-3 July 2018.’

24. Werner, ‘Most-Watched Soccer Games on US TV for June 24-7 July 2019.’

25. Lukas, ‘NFL vs MLS: Revenue, Salaries, Viewership and Ratings.’

26. Adgate, ‘Hockey’s Big Pay Day Is Coming.’

27. Seifert, ‘CFL Commissioner Jeffrey Orridge Wants a Piece of American Sports.’

28. Smith, ‘Major League Soccer’s Most Valuable Teams 2019.’

29. ‘Forbes Releases 21st Annual NHL Team Valuations.’

30. The International Football Association Board. ‘Laws 1-17.’ Laws, Chapter 4, IFAB

31. ‘Clash and Burn: MLS: Back to Square One’, 275.

32. Sibor, ‘An Oral History of Major League Soccer’s Frenzied First Season.’

33. ‘Clash and Burn: MLS: Back to Square One’, 273.

34. ‘An Oral History of Major League Soccer’s Frenzied First Season.’

35. Marthaler, ‘Goofy Soccer Rule Era for MLS Is, Hopefully, Gone for Good.’

36. Abnos, ‘All of MLS’s Crazy Roster Rules, in One Flowchart.’

37. March 2, 20,186:00PM ESTMLS CommunicationsFollow@ mls_pr. ‘MLS Roster Rules and Regulations 2019.’ MLSsoccer.com, Major League Soccer, 9 March 2019

38. Joe Devine and Kristen Heneage. ‘MLS Salary Cap Explained.’ YouTube, Tifo Football

39. ‘List of Competitions.’ FBref.com

40. ‘Major League Soccer – Champions.’ Worldfootball.net

41. Fleming, ‘Is MLS Really Just An Early Retirement Home?’

42. Jolly, ‘Football’s Working-Class Roots.’

43. ‘Europe: Football Fans by Country and Gender 2016 I Statistic.’

44. Nadeau, ‘Fascism and Football.’

45. https://news.gallup.com/poll/224,864/football-americans-favourite-sport-watch.aspx?g_source=Politics&g_medium=newsfeed&g_campaign=tiles

46. https://www.bustle.com/articles/28282-does-america-even-like-soccer-a-state-by-state-breakdown-of-soccer-fandom

47. Data Access and Dissemination Systems (DADS). ‘American FactFinder – Results.’ American FactFinder – Results, 5 October 2010

48. ‘Historical Presidential Election Information by State.’ 270toWin.Com.

49. Lindner and Hawkins, Globalization, Culture Wars, and Attitudes towards Soccer in America.”

50. Pallien, ‘Soccer Scores Big In The U.S.’

51. ‘r/Cringe – FIGHT AND WIN! Seattle Sounders Fan Leading the Crowd with an Impressively Bad Chant.’ Reddit.

52. ‘Clash and Burn: MLS: Back to Square One’, 276.

53. John Wall Street. ‘MLS “Masquerading as Authentic Soccer”, Growth in Major Markets Stunted.’

54. Rosenberg, ‘There Is an Anti-Fascist Rebellion Brewing in the Pacific Northwest. And Soccer Is at the Center of It.’

55. ‘Timbers Soccer History.’

56. Leitch, ‘It’s Good That MLS Has Finally Accepted That It’s a Second-Tier Soccer League.’

57. Strutner et al. ‘Making Soccer “Major League” in the USA and Beyond: Major League Soccer’s First Decade.’

58. Bondy, ‘Soccer Will Soon Be America’s Third-Favorite Spectator Sport.’

59. Centres, ‘Most Popular Youth Sports: Youth Sports Leagues Milford.’