1,313
Views
13
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

Why the Philippines Chooses to Import Rice

Pages 100-122 | Published online: 09 Feb 2016
 

ABSTRACT

Embedded in the debate in the Philippines over food security and food sovereignty are three conventional reasons why the country is a longstanding rice importer: geography, exploitative international policy pressure predicated on the dictates of neoliberalism, and colonial history. This paper argues that these conventional reasons share two limitations. First, they attribute mono-causal reasons for perennial rice imports, either in the form of geography, exogenous power, or history. While these perspectives are not wrong, each on its own is inadequate. Multiple, contributing factors have and will continue to abound. Second, each of these arguments limits Filipinos' agency. Through a four-part argument, I show how Filipinos have had more say in the reasons for serial rice imports than these conventional accounts allow.

Acknowledgments

The author would like to thank Dean Dr Christian George Francisco of De La Salle University-Dasmariñas for inviting me to his Social Science Department's January 2014 International Convention on ASEAN Community 2015, where I first presented this argument. Portia Reyes, Yoshi Nishizaki, seven anonymous reviewers, and the editors of Critical Asian Studies helped to make the final version vastly superior to the original.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author.

Notes on contributor

Jamie S. Davidson is an associate professor of Political Science at the National University of Singapore. His latest book is entitled Indonesia's Changing Political Economy: Governing the Roads (2015).

Notes

1As a result of the General Agreement on Trade and Tariffs negotiations in 1994, the country was granted its own schedule for the gradual liberalization of its rice imports.

2Clarete Citation2008; Tolentino and de la Peña Citation2011; Fabella Citation2014; Sicat Citation2014.

3Veneracion Citation2001; Royandoyan Citation2012. At this time rice began to lose its spiritual properties as it was transformed into a staple food (Aguilar Citation2013).

4Although an import duty was lifted in 1857 as a means to keep wages low, the policy had a lingering, depressive effect on rice production (Mears et al. Citation1974, 6).

5Ingram Citation1955, chapters 2–4.

6Latham Citation2009.

7Legarda Citation1999, 168.

8Constantino and Constantino Citation1978, 326–328. At the close of the nineteenth century Philippine revolutionary forces had defeated the Spanish but the Americans intervened and by 1902 they had gained control of most of the islands after a brutal suppression of Philippine fighters.

9Mears et al. Citation1974, Appendix 2.3, 335.

10Mears et al. Citation1974, Appendix 2.6, 334–335. The population grew from 9.5 million in 1916 to 15.4 million in 1937.

11From 1930 to 1935, the colony averaged 11,766 tons of imported rice (Mears et al. Citation1974, Appendix 2.1, 330).

12Wong Citation1999, 51.

13Golay Citation1961, 56.

14McCoy Citation1983.

15 Manila Times, February 2, Citation1965.

16Doronila Citation1992, 26. Pomeroy questions his nationalist credentials, however, because of his family's business dealings (Citation1974, 58–59).

17Golay Citation1961, 35, .

18Tiglao Citation1983.

19Golay Citation1961, 40–41.

20Henares was likely reacting to the expansion of sugar lands as a result of decontrol (see below). From 1960 to 1965, their annual growth surged to 6.1 percent, up from 1.9 percent during the previous five years (Treadgold and Hooley Citation1967, 119).

21That coconuts favor coastal regions less suitable for rice lessens their direct competition.

22Castillo Citation1975, 33, Table 2.1.

23Dawe, Moya, and Casiwan Citation2006.

24Dawe Citation2006, 3.

25Dawe Citation2006, 3.

26Dawe Citation2006, 4.

27Our Correspondent Citation2013. For decades, conservative groups led by the Catholic Church had stymied public debate and government action on the matter (Reyes Citation2002; Abinales and Amoroso Citation2005, 294–298).

28Overpopulation's impact on food security has worried Philippine intellectuals and officials for decades (Chioco Citation1958, 2; Mangahas Citation1975, 305; Salas Citation1985, 153).

29Dawe Citation2006, 6.

30In the Green Revolution's case, IRRI and Filipino scientists did produce modern, high-yielding varieties, otherwise known as “miracle seeds.” Combined with improved water control and higher use of fertilizers, these features produced a technological revolution.

31Bello Citation2009.

32Bello Citation2009, 54.

33Bello Citation2009, 55.

34Bello Citation2009, 57.

35Bello Citation2009, 59.

36Bello Citation2009, 60.

37See also Boyce Citation1993.

38Bello Citation2009, 55.

39Bello Citation2009, 55.

40Cullather Citation2010, chapters 6 and 9.

41Salas Citation1985, 117.

42Boyce Citation1993, 62.

43Barker Citation1984.

44Bello Citation2009, 56.

45A World Bank report cited by Bello (Citation2009, 56).

46Bello Citation2009, 56.

47Salas Citation1985, 186; Doronila Citation1992, 154.

48Tadem Citation1986, 22–23.

49Tadem Citation1986, 23. See also Herdt Citation1987; Boyce Citation1993, 25–26, Table 2.7; and Balisacan, Fuwa, and Debuque Citation2004, 231–233.

50Tadem Citation1986, 50.

51Cited in Tadem Citation1986, 52. See also Fegan Citation1989, 138–139. On the National Food Authority (NFA), see below.

52“More rice from China & Indonesia,” Bulletin Today, November 23, 1984.

53Tadem Citation1986, 53.

54Tadem Citation1986, 59.

55Tadem Citation1986, 61. Putzel's conclusions echo that of Tadem's (1992, 142).

56David Citation2003, 197.

57See Philippine Statistics Authority; available online at http://countrystat.bas.gov.ph (accessed May 11, 2015).

58Kerkvliet Citation1977, 75–76; Houston Citation1953, 61.

59These clauses were contained in the 1946 Bell (later the Philippines-USA) Trade Act (Pomeroy Citation1974, chapter 2).

60Import licenses bred “ten-percenters” among bureaucrats and legislators (Golay Citation1961, 77).

61Golay Citation1961, 49. Because the base was so low, some found the growth unimpressive (Sicat Citation1972, 5–7).

62Sicat Citation1972.

63Belarmino Citation1965; Fegan Citation1989.

64Republic of the Philippines, Bureau of Agriculturial Economics Citation1960, 17, Table 7; Ruttan, Soothipan, and Venegas Citation1966.

65Slater Citation2010, 93–102.

66Lobaton Citation1963. The law's passage was merely the continuation of prolonger attempts of nationalist elites to “Filipinize” the country's commerce. This had included efforts in the grain sector (with the pre-WWII establishment of the National Rice and Corn Corporation) and the retail sectors (with the passage of the 1954 Nationalization Retail Trade Act) (Wickizer and Bennett Citation1941, 178–181; Hau Citation2014, 31–32).

67The IMF, World Bank, and USA supported the move (Hawes Citation1987, 37).

68Hawes Citation1987.

69Intal and Power Citation1991, 150, 176.

70Treadgold and Hooley Citation1967.

71Sicat Citation1972, 13. Such relevant legislation as the 1951 Minimum Wage Law excluded agricultural laborers (Doronila Citation1992, 63).

72Sicat Citation1972, 3.

73Barker, Herdt, and Rose Citation1985, 123, Table 9.1.

75Mendoza Citation2011b, 17, Table 12.

76Among the lowest in Asia, yields had hardly increased since the 1920s (Mears et al. Citation1974, 27–29, 336, Appendix 2.3).

77Barker Citation1984, 194, Appendix 1; Wurfel Citation1988, 60.

78Boyce Citation1993, 134, citing Fegan Citation1989, 131. See also Wolters Citation1984, 187.

79Abinales and Amoroso Citation2005, 215–216.

80Apiraksirikul and Barker Citation1976.

81Retail prices, especially in Manila, often increased anyway because retailers anticipated the pattern and restricted supplies (Mangahas Citation1968).

82Editorial Citation1965.

83Landé Citation1964; Sidel Citation1999.

84Barker, Herdt, and Rose Citation1985, 254–255.

85Tanchuling Citation2010.

86Balisacan and Sebastian Citation2006. Balisacan has since become the Socioeconomic Planning Secretary in President Benigno Aquino's cabinet; Sebastian at the time headed the state's Philippine Rice Research Institute (PhilRice).

87Balisacan and Sebastian Citation2006.

88Balisacan and Sebastian Citation2006, 5.

89Sebastian, Bordey, and Alpuerto Citation2006, 46. The research intensity ratio compares the total research and development financing of a commodity with its gross value added. The standard recommendation for developing countries is one percent.

90David Citation2003, 203.

91Ordoñez Citation2010.

92David, Citation2003, 202.

94The marked increase in spending on irrigation was seen as a reaction to the 2008 rice crisis. The NIA's 2012 budget of 24.4 billion pesos was three times its budget ten years earlier (Basilio Citation2012). For specifics of its shortfall, see Serafica Citation2013. The NIA's poor performance is in contrast with its success under Marcos (Ricks Citationn.d.).

95Balisacan and Sebastian Citation2006, 6.

96Ortigas Citation1953, 120–121; Unnevehr Citation1985.

97Timmer Citation1989.

98Balisacan and Sebastian Citation2006, 6. Clarete estimates that the cost of the government's rice price and import policies averaged 22.77 billion pesos annually (Citation2008, 188, Table 7.6).

99Clarete Citation2008; Sicat Citation2014.

100Balisacan and Sebastian Citation2006, 13.

101Putzel Citation1992; Riedinger Citation1995.

102As of mid-2014, CARP had achieved eighty-four percent of its redistribution target of 5.37 million hectares, or some sixteen percent of the country's total land area with approximately 2.6 million recipients having received on average 1.2 hectares (Fabella Citation2014, 1).

103Fabella Citation2014.

104Monsod and Piza Citation2014.

105Royandoyan Citation2012; Ibon Citation2012.

106Monsod and Piza Citation2014, 2.

107The DA does not publish data on ARBs in ARCs. The general belief is that the number is one-third to one-half. (Interview with Roehlano Briones, Philippines Institute of Development Studies, Manila, June 13, 2014.)

108Palmer Citation1975.

109The Agri-Agra Reform Credit Act of 2009 mandates that ten percent of this must be made to ABRs (Martin Citation2014).

110Interview with Hazel Tanchuling, Rice Watch and Action Network, Manila, June 2, 2014.

111Balisacan and Sebastian Citation2006, 6.

112Fabella Citation2014, 9–11.

113Palmer Citation1975, 40–46.

114David Citation2003, 213.

115Hutchcroft and Rocamora Citation2003; Hicken Citation2009.

116Anderson Citation1988, 31.

117Cabling and Dawe Citation2006, 10.

119Mendoza Citation2011a.

120“The Philippines plans to hold its 2012 import tender for 500,000 tons of rice in March.” Citation2012 The official self-sufficiency gap that year was eight percent.

121Balisacan et al. Citation2010, 18, Table 3.

123Official estimates also fail adequately to discount the country's sizable corn-eating population (approximately 7.5 percent) and the some eleven million citizens working abroad (Mendoza Citation2011a).

124Dedace and Edep Citation2010; Ubalde Citation2011.

125In late 2011, the NFA began auctioning a limited number of licenses to importers. Outcomes are perceived to be largely predetermined.

126Tadem Citation1986, 43–44; Clarete Citation2008, 181–184.

127Reyes Citation1999.

128Among others, see Adraneda Citation2007; Rice importation “premature” 2010; Bondoc Citation2014.

129Bordadora Citation2011.

130Tiglao Citation2012.

131Meanwhile, farm-gate prices had fallen from 15 pesos in 2010 to 13.5 pesos per kilogram. Although retail prices remained flat at thirty-one pesos, the international rice price had risen about twenty percent from 2010 to December 2011 (Tiglao Citation2012).

132Anonymous interview with former NFA Head, Manila, July 24, 2014.

133Pefianco Citation2003.

134Tolentino and de la Peña Citation2011, 165, note 6.

135Abelgas Citation2013. This is not to deny that coconut and corn famers on average are worse off than rice farmers.

136The totals are: 18.0 million metric tons in 2012, 18.4 million in 2013, and 18.9 million in 2014. See Philippine Statistics Authority, http://countrystat.bas.gov.ph (accessed May 11, 2015).

137Mangahas Citation1968.

138Wong Citation2011, 602–604.

139Cabling and Dawe Citation2006; Ramos Citation2000; Hayami and Kikuchi Citation2000, chapter 8.

140Macairan Citation2014.

141Winters Citation2011, chapter 4.

142Arshad Citation2007.

143Hutchcroft Citation1999.

Additional information

Funding

Research for this article was supported by the National University of Singapore through its Academic Research Fund [grant # R-108-000-070-112].

Log in via your institution

Log in to Taylor & Francis Online

PDF download + Online access

  • 48 hours access to article PDF & online version
  • Article PDF can be downloaded
  • Article PDF can be printed
USD 53.00 Add to cart

Issue Purchase

  • 30 days online access to complete issue
  • Article PDFs can be downloaded
  • Article PDFs can be printed
USD 172.00 Add to cart

* Local tax will be added as applicable

Related Research

People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read.

Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine.

Cited by lists all citing articles based on Crossref citations.
Articles with the Crossref icon will open in a new tab.