No Moscow stooges: identity polarization and guerrilla movements in Donbass

Abstract

The paper argues that the grounds for the conflict in Donbass were prepared when different sections of Ukraine’s population developed conflicting perspectives of the past, the role of Russia in Ukraine’s history, and of how relations with the West should evolve. These differences lay the foundations for what became polarized identities and mutually exclusive ideologies. The study goes on to explore a changing political landscape of a leaderless uprising and formation of a protest movement out of locally available ingredients, the emergence of armed militias in unfolding security vacuum and the developments on the battlefield. As the rebel-held territories drifted away from mainland Ukraine, their new identity was formed by the war. The paper argues that understanding the internal dynamic of the guerrilla war and population’s survival has been key to the resolution, which is increasingly unlikely.

Keywords:

• Ukraine
• conflict
• identity
• Russia
• Donbass
• rebels
• conflict resolution

Notes

1. Khmel’ko (2010).

2. Research and Branding Group. 5 October 2012. Каждый десятый украинец считает себя гражданином СССР.

3. Razumkov Centre findings in 2009 in Crimea were that ‘only 27.3% of representatives of the Slavic community consider themselves members of the Ukrainian political nation,’ 2009. National Security and Defence, Kiev, no. 5: 5.

4. Ethnic Composition of Population of the Russian Federation. 2010 National Census.

5. 2001 Ukrainian Census.

6. Kharlamov, Sergei. December 2014. Personal experience in 1984, Lvov.

7. History Project by Heinrich Boell Foundation in Ukraine, http://ua.boell.org/uk/categories/history.

8. Igor Semyvolos interview, Kiev, November 2015.

9. Kolsoe, 183.

10. http://www.igpi.ru/info/people/malink/1111152776.html.

11. Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine, Kiev, November 2015.

12. Volynets, Alexei. 13 May 2014. Язык из Киева уведет: украинизация на востоке. RusBalt News Agency.

13. Volkov, Sergey, Kiev-based expert. 2014 and 2015.

14. The other protagonist is Ukrainian Autocephalous Orthodox Church.

15. Dmitrii Vydrin interview, Kiev, 2014.

16. Oleh Protsyk interview 2015.

17. Vydrin, Ibid.

18. BBC Russian Service. 29 July 2014. Госкино Украины запретило “Белую гвардию” и “Поддубного”.

19. ‘Украинская культура – это не только Тарас Шевченко.’ 21 May 2015. Alexandr Roitburd interview, https://meduza.io/feature/2015/05/21/ukrainskaya-kultura-eto-ne-tolko-taras-shevchenko.

20. Radio Free Europe. 12 June 2015.

21. Left Bank. 8 May 2015.

22. TASS. 24 March 2015.

23. RIA Novosti Ukraine 4 November 2015. Власть надолго запустили механизм дискредитации гражданского актива.

24. Nikolay Sergienko, ex-deputy director of Ukrainian State Railway Company, died on 26 January. Other suicide victims were Alexei Kolesnik, ex-chair of Kharkov oblast council, Sergei Walter, Melitopol ex-mayor, Alexander Bordug, Melitopol ex-police chief, Mikhail Chechetov and Stanislav Melnik, ex-Party of Regions MPs, Alexander Peklushenko, Zaporojie ex-governor, and Sergei Melnichuk, former Odessa prosecutor. In April’s spat of killings Kolesnikov, Buzina and Sukhobok were murdered.

25. Mikhail Pogrebinskii. 7 December 2015. Украина стремительно движется к анархии и хаосу.

26. Chatham House, 2 December 2015.

27. Gaidutsky, Pavel. 7 June 2013. Украина – ЕС: проблемы интеграции.

28. Haran Olexiy, Zolkina, Maria. February 2014. Трудный путь Украины к европейской интеграции. PONARS Eurasia analytical memo no. 311.

29. Semyvolos interview, Ibid.

30. Volodymir Lipatsy interview, Kiev, November 2015.

31. Interview with a Kiev-based foundation representative, October 2014.

32. Victor Medvedchuk quoted by RBK Ukraine. 25 November 2015. Медведчук назвал “мифом” евроинтеграционные обещания украинской власти.

33. Kutsenko quotes Бекешкiна, Кучерiв, Небоженко. Полiтичний портрет Украiны. 1994. Sociological service of the ‘Democratic Initiatives’ centre/Kiev.

34. Research & Branding Group. 12 February 2014.

35. The Time. 4 Feb 2014. Leader of Far-Right Ukrainian Militant Group Talks Revolution With TIME. Simon Shuster.

36. CBS. 13 April 2014. Turchynov speaking at Ukraine’s Security Council.

37. Author’s interviews in Kiev and Donbass, October 2014.

38. TASS. 28 August 2014. East Ukraine militias seize large amount of Ukrainian armor – Kiev’s hacked data.

39. Russkaya Vesna. 10 October 2014. http://rusvesna.su/news/1413015517.

40. Petro, Nicolai N. 23 March 2015. Russia's Orthodox Soft Power. http://www.carnegiecouncil.org/publications/articles_papers_reports/727.

41. Dergachev, Vladimir, Kirillov, Dmitrii. 22 June 2015. Влезь или умри. Как выживает Донбасс. К чему пришли ЛНР и ДНР через год после референдума Gazeta.ru.

42. Rękawek, Kacper. 2015. ‘PISM Policy Paper no. 6 (108): Neither ‘NATO’s Foreign Legion’ Nor the ‘Donbass International Brigades:’ (Where Are All the) Foreign Fighters in Ukraine?’.

43. Walker, Shaun. 24 September 2015. The Guardian.

44. RIA Novosti. ДНР: иностранные наемники сражаются в Донбассе на стороне силовиков, 21 May 2015, ДНР: ополчение на 10–15% состоит из иностранных добровольцев, 10 September 2014.

45. Walker, Shaun. 24 July 2015. ‘We like partisan warfare.’ Chechens fighting in Ukraine – on both sides. The Guardian.

46. Blumminov, Alexei. «Интербригады»: Как это было в Испании и как это есть на Донбассе. 7 September 2015. Politnavigator.

47. Dergachev, Vladimir. 8 April 2015. Год хаоса и независимости: Как прошел год самопровозглашенной ДНР. Gazeta.ru.

48. Liga.net. Болотов руководил копанками регионала Ефремова – Ландик. 20 August 2014.

49. Vladimir Putin’s Annual News Conference. 17 December 2015.

50. ‘Novorossiya’ confederation was established in May 2014 by six DNR and LNR representatives.

51. Tsarev’s interview ‘Новороссии нужен мир.’ 19 September 2014. Russkaya Vesna.

52. Colonel Cassad. 4 September 2014.

53. Novopressa. http://novopressa.ru/articles/pavel-gubarev-buducshee-novorossii.html.

54. RIA Novosti. 3 November 2014.

55. Election Observation Mission Final Report. 2010. OSCE ODIHR: Warsaw.

56. Ostrov. 3 April 2015. Боевики «ЛНР» осуществили принудительное разоружение «казаков» в Петровском, Красном Луче и Лутугино.

57. RIA Novosti Ukraine. 30 November 2015.

58. Johnson, Reuben R. 12 June 2015. Lack of Funding Undermines Ukraine Air Power.

59. Russia Today. 22 September 2014. Порошенко: В боях на востоке Украины армия потеряла 65 процентов техники.

60. Alexei Miroshnichenko, an intelligence officer of SBU 5th Department, named 2.600 dead in Ilovaysk and 6–7.000 dead at Debaltsevo, press conference in Lugansk on 15 June 2015, Colonel Cassad.

61. Kiev May Now Have As Many as 16,000 Armed Deserters on Its Hands. 5 October 2015. Sputnik News.

62. Большое интервью генерала Петровского, или так говорит ‘Хмурый.’ 12 December 2014. http://www.ukraina.ru/interview/20141226/1011633098.html.

63. Video available at http://colonelcassad.livejournal.com/2015/06/15/.

64. Colonel Cassad. 25 September 2014.

65. Dergachev, Vladimir. 12 June 2015. В ЛНР казаки избивали наркоманов нагайками. Gazeta.ru.

66. Влезь или Умри, Ibid.

67. According to Ukraine’s State Emergency Service, 52,000 of registered IDPs returned immediately, and according to OSCE Special Monitoring Mission, 1200 were returning from Russia daily. 22 September 2014. Korrespondent.

68. Alexei Kachan, Lugansk political expert, interview, Kiev, November 2015.

69. Author’s interviews with international humanitarian practitioners based in Kiev, November 2015.

70. Kachan interview.

71. Kopat’ko: На Донбассе с трудом представляют, как жить вместе с теми, кто воевал против них, 30 November 2015. RIA Novosti Ukraine.

72. http://rian.com.ua/interview/20151130/1001245689.html.

73. Kachan, Ibid.

74. Alexandrov, Georgii. 7 December 2015. Воевать нельзя мириться. The New Times, no. 41.

75. Colonel Cassad. 7 June 2015.

76. Left Bank. http://society.lb.ua/war/2015/06/10/307826_boeviki_zablokirovali_edinstvenniy.html.

77. Barabanov, Ilya. 9 June 2015. Авторы поправок, очевидно, ставили перед собой цель составить документ максимально приемлемый для Киева. Kommersant.

78. Kopat’ko, Ibid.

79. Semyvolos, Ibid.

80. Agency website http://www.ukrspecexport.com.

81. Semyvolos, Ibid.

82. Ostrov 13 June 2015. Большинство украинцев готовы ради мира отказаться от оккупированных территорий. Survey by Sophia Social Studies Centre.

83. Colonel Cassad. 23 June 2015. http://colonelcassad.livejournal.com/2015/06/23/.

84. Igor Semyvolos interview, Kiev, 25 November 2015.

85. Alexei Kachan interview, Kiev, 26 November 2015.

86. Alexei Kachan interview, Kiev.

87. Volodymir Pritula interview, Kiev, November 2015.

88. Semyvolos interview.

89. Premier Yatseniuk speaking in Washington: ‘My government will never talk to terrorists until they are ‘behind bars or sitting in a prison cell.’ 10 June 2015. Quoted in ‘Ukrainian PM Blasts Separatists: ‘We Will Never Talk to Terrorists.’ Foreign Policy. https://foreignpolicy.com/2015/06/10/ukrainian-pm-blasts-russian-separatists-we-will-never-talk-to-terrorists/

90. Yermolayev, Andrei. 14 August 2015. Москва переиграла Киев, нужно срочно договариваться с Донбассом. Politobzor. http://politobzor.net/show-61904-andrey-ermolaev-moskva-pereigrala-kiev-nuzhno-srochno-dogovarivatsya-s-donbassom.html.