Abstract
The impressive growth of the Chinese economy in the past three decades has attracted a lot of attention and hence the research interest of many scholars and policy makers. One of the focuses in the literature is the role of productivity in China's economic growth. This paper aims to revisit the debate about the role of productivity in China's growth, to provide an updated estimate of productivity growth and hence to make a contribution to the understanding of China's economic growth in recent years. Its objective is to propose and apply a growth accounting technique to assess economic performance in China, in particular the role of technological progress in China's recent growth. The findings about the latter may have important policy implications for the sustainability of China's economic growth in the future.
Acknowledgements
The author would like to thank Jinghai Zheng, Zheng Yuxin and participants of China Productivity Workshop (Tsinghua University, 2007) for helpful comments and suggestions, comments from two anonymous referees are also appreciable.
Notes
5. The Japanese and German figures are estimated by Dougherty and Jorgenson (Citation1996).
7. For surveys of the measurement of economic openness, see Harrison (Citation1996).
8. China officially became a WTO member in November 2001.
9. In agriculture, the state sector is very small. However, private ownership of land has ceased to exist in China since 1949.
12. There are of course many other environmental factors affecting economic performance. For example, Sala-i-Martin (Citation1997) identified more than 60 variables that may be related to economic growth. Due to data constraints (requirement of data for 29 regions and over 13 years), only three factors are considered in this study.
14. In total, there are 31 regions in mainland China. In this study, Tibet is excluded due to missing data. In 1997 Chongqing became a municipality supervised directly by the central government and is included in Sichuan province in this study.
15. See Appendix A for the classification of Chinese regions.
16. This rate of depreciation is chosen for consistency with the estimation of domestic capital stock (see Appendix B). For most Chinese regions, the initial value of foreign capital stock in 1978 was assumed to be zero.
17. It is argued that this indicator of economic reform or marketisation may be biased due to its ignorance of many other factors. The author is currently investigating other measures of marketisation for the regions, such as the one developed by the National Centre for Economic Research, Beijing (Wang Citation2004).
18. There are many different ways of measuring economic openness. For a brief survey, see Harrison (Citation1996) and Edwards (Citation1998).
19. It is noted that the consistency and efficiency of the estimates from some of the models is an issue of controversies (Battese and Broca Citation1997). All models in this study are estimated using FRONTIER 4.1 developed by Coelli (Citation1996).
World Bank
.
1993
.
The East Asian Miracle, a World Bank Policy Research Report
,
Oxford
:
Oxford University Press
.
Krugman
,
P
.
1994
.
The myth of Asia's miracle
.
Foreign Affairs
,
73
(
6
)
:
62
–
78
.
Young
,
A
.
1994
.
Lessons from the East Asian NICs: a contrarian view
.
European Economic Review
,
110
:
641
–
80
.
Kim
,
JI
and
Lau
,
L
.
1994
.
The sources of economic growth in the East Asian newly industrialised countries
.
Journal of the Japanese and International Economies
,
8
:
235
–
71
.
Ito
,
T
and
Krueger
,
AO
, eds.
1995
.
Growth Theories in Light of the East Asian Experience
,
Chicago
:
University of Chicago Press
.
Young
,
A
.
1995
.
The tyranny of numbers: confronting the statistical realities of the East Asian growth experience
.
Quarterly Journal of Economics
,
110
(
3
)
:
641
–
80
.
Fu
,
TT
,
Huang
,
CJ
and
Lovell. ed
,
CAK
.
1999
.
Economic Efficiency and Productivity Growth in the Asia-Pacific Region
,
Cheltenham
:
Edward Elgar
.
Wu
,
YR
.
2002
.
The Macroeconomics of East Asian Growth
,
Cheltenham and Northampton
:
Edward Elgar Publishing
.
Sachs
,
JD
and
Woo
,
WT
.
1997
.
Understanding China's economic performance
.
NBER Working Paper 5935 National Bureau for Economic Research
World Bank
.
1977a
.
China 2020: Development Challenges in the New Century
,
Washington, DC
:
World Bank
.
Maddison
,
A
.
1998
.
Chinese Economic Performance in the Long Run
,
Paris
:
OECD Development Centre
.
Wang
,
XL
and
Meng
,
L
.
2001
.
A reevaluation of China's economic growth
.
China Economic Review
,
12
(
4
)
:
338
–
46
.
Chow
,
GC
.
2002
.
China's Economic Transformation
,
Malden
:
Blackwell Publishers
.
Borensztein
,
E
and
Ostry
,
JD
.
1996
.
Accounting for China's growth performance
.
American Economic Review
,
86
:
225
–
8
.
(Papers and Proceedings)
Fleisher
,
BM
and
Chen
,
J
.
1997
.
The coast-noncoast income gap, productivity and regional economic policy in China
.
Journal of Comparative Economics
,
25
:
220
–
36
.
Woo
,
WT
.
1998
.
“
Chinese economic growth: sources and prospects
”
. In
The Chinese Economy
,
Edited by:
Fouquin
,
M
and
Lemoine
,
F
.
Paris
:
Economica
.
Chow
,
GC
and
Lin
,
AL
.
2002
.
Accounting for economic growth in Taiwan and mainland China: a comparative analysis
.
Journal of Comparative Economics
,
30
(
3
)
:
507
–
30
.
Wang
,
Y
and
Yao
,
YD
.
2003
.
Sources of China's economic growth 1952–1999: incorporating human capital accumulation
.
China Economic Review
,
14
:
32
–
52
.
Young
,
A
.
2003
.
Gold into base metals: productivity growth in the People's Republic of China during the reform period
.
Journal of Political Economy
,
111
(
6
)
:
1220
–
61
.
Wu
,
YR
.
2003
.
Has productivity contributed to China's growth?
.
Pacific Economic Review
,
8
(
1
)
:
15
–
30
.
Zheng
,
JH
and
Hu
,
AG
.
2006
.
An empirical analysis of provincial productivity in China (1979–2001)
.
Journal of Chinese Economic and Business Studies
,
4
(
3
)
:
221
–
39
.
Dougherty
,
C
and
Jorgenson
,
DW
.
1996
.
International comparisons of the sources of economic growth
.
American Economic Review
,
86
(
2
)
:
25
–
9
.
(Papers and Proceedings)
World Bank
.
1977a
.
China 2020: Development Challenges in the New Century
,
Washington, DC
:
World Bank
.
Bramall
,
C
.
2000
.
Sources of Chinese Economic Growth, 1978–1996
,
Oxford and New York
:
Oxford University Press
.
Chow
,
GC
.
2002
.
China's Economic Transformation
,
Malden
:
Blackwell Publishers
.
Garnaut
,
R
and
Song
,
L
, eds.
2003
.
China: New Engine of World Growth
,
Canberra
:
Asia Pacific Press
.
Wu
,
YR
.
2004
.
China's Economic Growth: A Miracle with Chinese Characteristics
,
London and New York
:
Routledge Curzon Press
.
Harrison
,
A
.
1996
.
Openness and growth: a time-series, cross-country analysis for developing countries
.
Journal of Development Economics
,
48
:
419
–
47
.
Lovell
,
CAK
.
1996
.
Applying efficiency measurement techniques to the measurement of productivity change
.
Journal of Productivity Analysis
,
7
:
329
–
40
.
Greene
,
WH
.
1997
.
“
Frontier production functions
”
. In
Handbook of Applied Econometrics II: Microeconomics
,
Edited by:
Pesaran
,
MH
and
Schmidt
,
P
.
81
–
166
.
Oxford
:
Blackwell
.
Coelli
,
T
,
Rao,
,
DSP
and
Battese
,
GE
.
1998
.
An Introduction to Efficiency and Productivity Analysis
,
Boston
:
Kluwer Academic Publishers
.
Kumbhakar
,
SC
and
Lovell
,
CAK
.
2000
.
Stochastic Frontier Analysis
,
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Färe
,
R
,
Grosskopf
,
S
,
Norris,
,
M
and
Zhang
,
Z
.
1994
.
Productivity growth, technical progress and efficiency changes in industrialised countries
.
American Economic Review
,
84
(
1
)
:
66
–
83
.
Lovell
,
CAK
.
1996
.
Applying efficiency measurement techniques to the measurement of productivity change
.
Journal of Productivity Analysis
,
7
:
329
–
40
.
Coelli
,
T
,
Rao,
,
DSP
and
Battese
,
GE
.
1998
.
An Introduction to Efficiency and Productivity Analysis
,
Boston
:
Kluwer Academic Publishers
.
Sala-i-Martin
,
X
.
1997
.
I just ran two million regressions
.
American Economic Review
,
87
:
178
–
83
.
(Papers and Proceedings)
Kumbhakar
,
SC
,
Ghosh,
,
S
and
McGuckin
,
J
.
1991
.
A Generalised Production Frontier Approach for Estimating Determinants of Inefficiency in US Dairy Farms
.
Journal of Business and Economic Statistics
,
9
(
3
)
:
279
–
86
.
Huang
,
CJ
and
Liu
,
JT
.
1994
.
Estimation of a non-neutral stochastic frontier production function
.
Journal of Productivity Analysis
,
5
:
171
–
80
.
Battese
,
GE
and
Coelli
,
T
.
1995
.
A model for technical inefficiency effects in a stochastic frontier production function for panel data
.
Empirical Economics
,
20
:
325
–
32
.
Wang
,
XL
.
2004
.
“
Marketisation in China
”
. In
China: Is Rapid Growth Sustainable?
,
Edited by:
Garnaut
,
Ross
and
Song
,
Ligang
.
Canberra
:
Asia Pacific Press
.
Harrison
,
A
.
1996
.
Openness and growth: a time-series, cross-country analysis for developing countries
.
Journal of Development Economics
,
48
:
419
–
47
.
Edwards
,
S
.
1998
.
Openness, productivity, growth: what do we really know
.
Economic Journal
,
108
:
383
–
98
.
Battese
,
GE
and
Broca
,
SS
.
1997
.
Functional forms of stochastic frontier production functions and models for technical inefficiency effects: a comparative study for wheat farmers in Pakistan
.
Journal of Productivity Analysis
,
8, no.4
:
395
–
414
.
Coelli
,
T
.
1996
.
A guide to FRONTIER 4.1: a computer program for stochastic frontier production function and cost function estimation
,
Armidale,
, Australia
:
Department of Econometrics, University of New England
.
CEPA Working Paper 96/7