U.S.–Canada Cooperation: The U.S.–Canada Air Quality Agreement

Abstract

The impetus for the Canada–U.S. Air Quality Agreement was transboundary acid rain in eastern North America. This problem drove the parties to develop a bilateral agreement that not only addressed this issue, but also set up a broad and flexible framework to address other air quality problems. In 2000, the Ozone Annex to reduce smog and its precursor pollutants was negotiated. A transboundary particulate matter (PM) science assessment in 2004 led to the commencement of negotiation of a PM annex in late 2007. Over the course of 15 yr, Canada and the United States also developed innovative cooperative arrangements. Two transboundary airshed dialogues became important sources of practical on-the-ground cooperation in the Georgia Basin–Puget Sound and the Great Lakes Basin. In addition to providing the basis for ongoing international dialogue, these transboundary airshed projects resulted in changes to administrative practices as the parties exchange information and learn from each other in ways that benefit the airshed community. The nature of the Air Quality Agreement also enabled both Canada and the United States to address concerns each has had about specific pollutant sources and to address them in ways that avoided confrontation and resulted in air quality improvements for people living in the airsheds. Case studies of three of the “informal consultations” that have occurred under the agreement are described: where discussions occurred around a power plant in Michigan, a power plant in Saskatchewan, and a steel mill in Ontario. More than an agreement, this relationship has built a capacity to deal with common problems. Fostering such a relationship with its implicit transfer of knowledge and experience has opened doors for discussions on a new Clean Air framework in Canada and joint analyses of cross-border sulfur dioxide (SO₂) and nitrogen oxides (NO_x) emissions caps and trading. U.S. experience with cap and trading is highlighted for background and context. The flexibility inherent in the agreement provides a platform for future air quality issues and continued communication without borders.

Notes

¹The US-Canada Air Quality Agreements may be viewed at http://www.epa.gov/airmarkets/progsregs/usca/index.htm.

²The Transboundary PM Science Assessment may be viewed at: http://www.msc.ec.gc.ca/saib/smog/smog_e.html.

³The Border Air Quality Studies may be viewed at http://www.epa.gov/airmarkets/progsregs/usca/pilotproject.html.

⁴U.S.–Canada Emissions Cap and Trading Feasibility Study may be viewed at http://www.epa.gov/airmarkets/progsregs/usca/docs/feasstudy.pdf.