Project selection index for unsolicited public–private partnership proposals

Abstract

The careful assessment and evaluation of unsolicited public–private partnership (PPP) proposals prior to their implementation is very critical towards achieving effective outcomes including wider social benefits and value for money. This article aims to develop a pragmatic model (i.e. project selection index) that could be used to quantify the viability levels of unsolicited PPP proposals drawing on a well-defined set of evaluation criteria for unsolicited proposals. A questionnaire survey was conducted with experienced PPP experts and the fuzzy set theory was used to develop the model. The pragmatic model consists of three critical evaluation criteria groupings (CECGs); namely: value for money, financial feasibility and sustainable innovation. Among the three CECGs, value for money has the highest coefficient value of 0.36. The findings of this study will enable contracting authorities to objectively evaluate the viability levels of unsolicited PPP proposals prior to their implementations. In addition, proponents would be informed of the key and strategic areas to consider when preparing their unsolicited PPP proposals. Finally, this study contributes to the on-going international discussion on the effective ways of managing unsolicited PPP proposals.

Keywords:

• Evaluation criteria
• fuzzy theory
• project selection index
• public-private partnership
• unsolicited proposals

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.

Acknowledgement

This article forms part of a research project entitled ‘A best practice framework for PPP implementation for infrastructure development in Ghana’ from which other articles have been produced with different objective/scope but sharing the same background and methodology. The research project described is fully supported by the Hong Kong PhD Fellowship Scheme from the Research Grants Council (RGC) of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region and The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong.