Abstract
Sport can be perceived as one of the contemporary key socializing agencies with which a significant number of children and youth come in to contact. The nature of this contact between the institution of sport and the individual is erratic, leading to the, often abrupt and unforeseen, termination of the individual's sporting career. In this essay, our aim is to draw wider attention to the personal adjustments young athletes undergo during and after their career has been institutionally terminated. Our analysis is embedded in theory as well as empirical, qualitative evidence gathered through semi-structured, long interviews with eight ex-varsity athletes. In shedding light on the personal consequences of structurally induced failure in sport, we seek to approach these issues from a socio-psychological angle and examine specific, personal layers of those via the lived experiences of ‘drop-out’ varsity athletes.Footnote1
Notes
1 The authors would like to acknowledge the massive contribution of Alan G. Ingham to the development and initial phases of this project. Alan played a significant and defining role in our academic development and in our appreciation for both psychology and sociology in scientifically making sense of contemporary sporting practices. Much to our regret, Alan passed away in 2005, but his personal as well as academic heritage has remained with us and will live on through the work of his grateful students and colleagues.
14 For instance, CitationBouton, Ball Four; CitationBrandmeyer and Alexander, ‘Dealing with Tempered Dreams’, 454–61; CitationHaerle, ‘Career Patterns’; CitationHill and Lowe, ‘The Inevitable Metathesis of the Retiring Athlete’; CitationJohnson, ‘After the Golden Moment’; CitationLerch, ‘The Adjustment to Retirement’; CitationMcPherson, ‘Sport Participation’; CitationRosenberg, ‘Geronotological Theory’; CitationRosenberg, ‘Athletic Retirement as Social Death’; CitationRozin, One Step from Glory.
15 Cf. CitationCurtis and Ennis, ‘Negative Consequences’; and see B. Couturie and J. Else, Disposable Heroes, Burbank Video, 1991.
23 See the case of Jim Otto in Couturie and Else, Disposable Heroes.
53 A scene from the movie, entitled Stick It, graphically illustrates the way coaches may misuse their position to lure athletes and parents into a specific sport activity. Although, the movie exclusively focuses on misleading participants for financial gain, we argue that reality is much more complex than that.
Ingham
,
A.
,
Chase
,
M.
and
Butt
,
J.
2002
.
From the Performance Principle to the Developmental Principle: Every Kid a Winner?
.
Quest
,
54
(
4
)
:
308
–
31
.
Martens
,
R.
1986
.
“
Youth Sport in the USA
”
. In
Sport for Children and Youth
,
Proceedings of the 1984 Olympic Scientific Congress
Edited by:
Weiss
,
M.
and
Gould
,
D.
Vol.10
,
27
–
33
.
Champaign, IL
:
Human Kinetics
.
Sage
,
G.
1998
.
Power and Ideology in American Sport: A Critical Perspective
,
Champaign, IL
:
Human Kinetics
.
Gould
,
D.
,
Feltz
,
D.
and
Weiss
,
M.
1985
.
Motives for Participating in Competitive Youth Swimming
.
International Journal of Sport Psychology
,
16
(
2
)
:
126
–
40
.
Klint
,
K.
and
Weiss
,
M.
1986
.
Dropping In and Dropping Out: Participation Motives of Current and Former Youth Gymnasts
.
Canadian Journal of Applied Sport Sciences
,
11
(
2
)
:
106
–
14
.
Gill
,
D.
,
Gross
,
J.
and
Huddleston
,
S.
1983
.
Participation Motivation in Youth Sports
.
International Journal of Sport Psychology
,
14
(
1
)
:
1
–
14
.
Weiss
,
M.
and
Petlichkoff
,
L.M.
1989
.
Children's Motivation for Participation in and Withdrawal from Sport: Identifying the Missing Links
.
Pediatric Exercise Science
,
1
(
3
)
:
195
–
211
.
Linder
,
K.
,
Johns
,
D.
and
Butcher
,
J.
1991
.
Factors in Withdrawal from Youth Sport: A Proposed Model
.
Journal of Sport Behavior
,
14
(
1
)
:
3
–
18
.
Donnelly
,
P.
1996
.
Prolympism: Sport Monoculture as Crisis and Opportunity
.
Quest
,
48
(
1
)
:
25
–
42
.
Ingham
,
A.
,
Chase
,
M.
and
Butt
,
J.
2002
.
From the Performance Principle to the Developmental Principle: Every Kid a Winner?
.
Quest
,
54
(
4
)
:
308
–
31
.
Kerckhoff
,
A.
1976
.
The Status Attainment Process
.
Social Forces
,
55
(
1
)
:
365
–
81
.
Ingham
,
A.
,
Blissmer
,
B.
and
Davidson
,
K.
1999
.
The Expendable Prolympic Self: Going Beyond the Boundaries of the Sociology and Psychology of Sport
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
16
(
3
)
:
236
–
68
.
Gould
,
D.
1987
.
“
Understanding Attrition in Youth Sport
”
. In
Advances in Pediatric Sport Sciences: Behavioral Issues
,
Edited by:
Gould
,
D.
and
Weiss
,
M.
61
–
85
.
Champaign, IL
:
Human Kinetics
.
Sapp, M., and J. Haubenstricker. ‘Motivation for Joining and Reasons for Not Continuing in Youth Sport Programs in Michigan’. Paper presented at the American Alliance for Health, Physical Education, Recreation and Dance meetings, Kansas City, MO, 1978.
Leonard
,
W.
1996
.
The Odds of Transiting from One Level of Sports Participation to Another
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
13
(
3
)
:
288
–
99
.
Coakley
,
J.
1983
.
Leaving Competitive Sport: Retirement or Rebirth?
.
Quest
,
35
(
1
)
:
1
–
11
.
Bouton
,
J.
1970
.
Ball Four
,
New York
:
Dell Publishing
.
Brandmeyer
,
G.
and
Alexander
,
L.
1982
.
“
Dealing with Tempered Dreams: Reflections of Aging Ballplayers on Careers that used to be
”
. In
Proceedings of the Conference on Career Patterns and Career Contingencies in Sport
,
Edited by:
Ingham
,
A.
and
Broom
,
E.
454
–
61
.
Vancouver
:
University of British Columbia
.
Haerle
,
R.
1975
.
“
Career Patterns and Career Contingencies of Professional Baseball Players: An Occupational Analysis
”
. In
Sport and Social Order
,
Edited by:
Ball
,
D.
and
Loy
,
J.
461
–
519
.
Reading, MA
:
Addison-Wesley
.
Hill
,
P.
and
Lowe
,
B.
1974
.
The Inevitable Metathesis of the Retiring Athlete
.
International Review for the Sociology of Sport
,
9
(
3
)
:
5
–
29
.
Johnson
,
W.
July 1972
.
After the Golden Moment
.
Sports Illustrated
,
37
:
28
–
41
.
Lerch
,
S.
1981
.
“
The Adjustment to Retirement of Professional Baseball Players
”
. In
Sociology of Sport: Diverse Perspectives
,
Edited by:
Greendorfer
,
S.
and
Yiannakis
,
A.
138
–
48
.
West Point, NY
:
Leisure Press
.
McPherson
,
B.
1984
.
Sport Participation Across the Life-cycle: A Review of the Literature and Suggestions for Further Research
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
1
(
3
)
:
213
–
30
.
Rosenberg
,
E.
1980
.
“
Geronotological Theory and Athletic Retirement
”
. In
Sociology of Sport: Diverse Perspectives
,
Edited by:
Greendorfer
,
S.
and
Yiannakis
,
A.
118
–
26
.
West Point, NY
:
Leisure Press
.
Rosenberg
,
E.
1984
.
“
Athletic Retirement as Social Death: Concepts and Perspectives
”
. In
Sport and the Sociological Imagination
,
Edited by:
Theberge
,
N.
and
Donnelly
,
P.
245
–
58
.
Fort Worth, TX
:
Texas Christian University Press
.
Rozin
,
S.
1979
.
One Step from Glory: On the Fringe of Professional Sports
,
New York
:
Simon & Schuster
.
Curtis
,
J.
and
Ennis
,
R.
1988
.
Negative Consequences of Leaving Competitive Sport? Comparative Findings for Former Elite-level Hockey Players
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
5
(
2
)
:
87
–
106
.
Bookbinder
,
H.
1955
.
Work Histories of Men Leaving a Short Life-span Occupation
.
Personnel and Guidance Journal
,
34
:
164
–
7
.
November
Lerch
,
S.
1981
.
“
The Adjustment to Retirement of Professional Baseball Players
”
. In
Sociology of Sport: Diverse Perspectives
,
Edited by:
Greendorfer
,
S.
and
Yiannakis
,
A.
138
–
48
.
West Point, NY
:
Leisure Press
.
Reynolds
,
M.
1981
.
“
The Effects of Sport Retirement on the Job Satisfaction of the Former Football Player
”
. In
Sociology of Sport: Diverse Perspectives
,
Edited by:
Greendorfer
,
S.
and
Yiannakis
,
A.
127
–
37
.
West Point, NY
:
Leisure Press
.
Coakley
,
J.
1983
.
Leaving Competitive Sport: Retirement or Rebirth?
.
Quest
,
35
(
1
)
:
1
–
11
.
Curtis
,
J.
and
Ennis
,
R.
1988
.
Negative Consequences of Leaving Competitive Sport? Comparative Findings for Former Elite-level Hockey Players
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
5
(
2
)
:
87
–
106
.
McPherson
,
B.
1984
.
Sport Participation Across the Life-cycle: A Review of the Literature and Suggestions for Further Research
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
1
(
3
)
:
213
–
30
.
Greendorfer
,
S.
and
Blinde
,
E.
1985
.
Retirement from Intercollegiate Sport: Theoretical and Empirical Considerations
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
2
(
2
)
:
101
–
10
.
Curtis
,
J.
and
Ennis
,
R.
1988
.
Negative Consequences of Leaving Competitive Sport? Comparative Findings for Former Elite-level Hockey Players
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
5
(
2
)
:
87
–
106
.
Curtis
,
J.
and
Ennis
,
R.
1988
.
Negative Consequences of Leaving Competitive Sport? Comparative Findings for Former Elite-level Hockey Players
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
5
(
2
)
:
87
–
106
.
Curtis
,
J.
and
Ennis
,
R.
1988
.
Negative Consequences of Leaving Competitive Sport? Comparative Findings for Former Elite-level Hockey Players
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
5
(
2
)
:
87
–
106
.
Curtis
,
J.
and
Ennis
,
R.
1988
.
Negative Consequences of Leaving Competitive Sport? Comparative Findings for Former Elite-level Hockey Players
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
5
(
2
)
:
87
–
106
.
Ball
,
D.
1976
.
Failure in Sport
.
American Sociological Review
,
41
(
4
)
:
726
–
39
.
Garfinkle
,
H.
1956
.
Conditions of Successful Degradation Ceremonies
.
American Journal of Sociology
,
61
(
4
)
:
420
–
4
.
Goffman
,
E.
1952
.
Cooling the Mark Out: Some Adaptations to Failure
.
Psychiatry
,
15
(
4
)
:
451
–
63
.
Ball
,
D.
1976
.
Failure in Sport
.
American Sociological Review
,
41
(
4
)
:
726
–
39
.
Ball
,
D.
1976
.
Failure in Sport
.
American Sociological Review
,
41
(
4
)
:
726
–
39
.
Ball
,
D.
1976
.
Failure in Sport
.
American Sociological Review
,
41
(
4
)
:
726
–
39
.
Scott
,
J.
1990
.
A Matter of Record: Documentary Sources in Social Research
,
London
:
Polity Press
.
Linder
,
K.
,
Johns
,
D.
and
Butcher
,
J.
1991
.
Factors in Withdrawal from Youth Sport: A Proposed Model
.
Journal of Sport Behavior
,
14
(
1
)
:
3
–
18
.
Ebaugh
,
H.
1988
.
Becoming an Ex: The Process of Role Exit
,
Chicago, IL
:
University of Chicago Press
.
Drahota
,
J.
and
Eitzen
,
S.
1998
.
The Role Exit of Professional Athletes
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
15
(
3
)
:
263
–
78
.
Drahota
,
J.
and
Eitzen
,
S.
1998
.
The Role Exit of Professional Athletes
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
15
(
3
)
:
263
–
78
.
Ebaugh
,
H.
1988
.
Becoming an Ex: The Process of Role Exit
,
Chicago, IL
:
University of Chicago Press
.
Taylor
,
J.
and
Ogilvie
,
B.
2001
.
“
Career Termination among Athletes
”
. In
Handbook of Sport Psychology
,
Edited by:
Singer
,
R.
,
Hausenblas
,
H.
and
Janelle
,
C.
672
–
91
.
New York
:
John Wiley
.
Drahota
,
J.
and
Eitzen
,
S.
1998
.
The Role Exit of Professional Athletes
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
15
(
3
)
:
263
–
78
.
Taylor
,
J.
and
Ogilvie
,
B.
2001
.
“
Career Termination among Athletes
”
. In
Handbook of Sport Psychology
,
Edited by:
Singer
,
R.
,
Hausenblas
,
H.
and
Janelle
,
C.
672
–
91
.
New York
:
John Wiley
.
Taylor
,
J.
and
Ogilvie
,
B.
2001
.
“
Career Termination among Athletes
”
. In
Handbook of Sport Psychology
,
Edited by:
Singer
,
R.
,
Hausenblas
,
H.
and
Janelle
,
C.
672
–
91
.
New York
:
John Wiley
.
Patton
,
M.
1990
.
Qualitative Evaluation and Research Methods
,
Newbury Park, CA
:
Sage
.
McCracken
,
G.
1988
.
The Long Interview
,
London
:
Sage Publications
.
McCracken
,
G.
1988
.
The Long Interview
,
London
:
Sage Publications
.
Kvale
,
S.
1996
.
Interviews: An Introduction to Qualitative Research
,
London
:
Sage Publications
.
Flick
,
U.
2002
.
An Introduction to Qualitative Research
,
London
:
Sage
.
Lincoln
,
Y.
and
Guba
,
E.
1985
.
Naturalistic Inquiry
,
Beverly Hills, CA
:
Sage
.
Tesch
,
R.
1990
.
Qualitative Research: Analysis Types and Software Tools
,
New York
:
Falmer Press
.
Denzin
,
N.K.
and
Lincoln
,
Y.S.
1998
.
Strategies of Qualitative Inquiry
,
California
:
Sage
.
McCracken
,
G.
1988
.
The Long Interview
,
London
:
Sage Publications
.
Connell
,
R.
1995
.
Masculinities
,
Cambridge
:
Polity Press
.
Mills
,
C.
1959
.
The Sociological Imagination
,
New York
:
Oxford University Press
.
Williams
,
R.
1977
.
Marxism and Literature
,
New York
:
Oxford University Press
.
Thompson
,
E.
1978
.
The Poverty of Theory and Other Essays
,
New York
:
Monthly Review Press
.
Giddens
,
A.
1982
.
Profiles and Critiques in Social Theory
,
Berkeley, CA
:
University of California Press
.
Willis
,
P.
1980
.
“
Notes on Method
”
. In
Culture, Media, Language
,
Edited by:
Hall
,
S.
,
Hobson
,
D.
,
Lowe
,
A.
and
Willis
,
P.
88
–
95
.
London
:
Hutchinson
.
Willis
,
P.
1980
.
“
Notes on Method
”
. In
Culture, Media, Language
,
Edited by:
Hall
,
S.
,
Hobson
,
D.
,
Lowe
,
A.
and
Willis
,
P.
88
–
95
.
London
:
Hutchinson
.
Donnelly
,
P.
1996
.
Prolympism: Sport Monoculture as Crisis and Opportunity
.
Quest
,
48
(
1
)
:
25
–
42
.
Ingham
,
A.
,
Blissmer
,
B.
and
Davidson
,
K.
1999
.
The Expendable Prolympic Self: Going Beyond the Boundaries of the Sociology and Psychology of Sport
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
16
(
3
)
:
236
–
68
.
Ingham
,
A.
,
Chase
,
M.
and
Butt
,
J.
2002
.
From the Performance Principle to the Developmental Principle: Every Kid a Winner?
.
Quest
,
54
(
4
)
:
308
–
31
.
Elias
,
N.
2000
.
The Civilising Process
,
Oxford
:
Blackwell
.
Revised ed.
Elias
,
N.
2000
.
The Civilising Process
,
Oxford
:
Blackwell
.
Revised ed.
Elias
,
N.
2000
.
The Civilising Process
,
Oxford
:
Blackwell
.
Revised ed.
Freud
,
A.
1966
.
The Ego and the Mechanisms of Defense
,
London
:
Hogarth Press
.
Bourdieu
,
P.
1989
.
Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgment of Taste
,
London
:
Routledge
.
Ingham
,
A.
,
Chase
,
M.
and
Butt
,
J.
2002
.
From the Performance Principle to the Developmental Principle: Every Kid a Winner?
.
Quest
,
54
(
4
)
:
308
–
31
.
Macpherson
,
C.
1973
.
Democratic Theory: Essays in Retrieval
,
Oxford
:
Clarendon Press
.
Ingham
,
A.G.
1985
.
From Public Issues to Personal Trouble: Well-being and the Fiscal Crisis of the State
.
Sociology of Sport Journal
,
2
(
1
)
:
43
–
55
.
Ingham
,
A.G.
2004
.
“
The Sportification Process: A Biographical Analysis Framed by the Work of Marx, Weber, Durkheim and Freud
”
. In
Sport and Modern Social Theorists
,
Edited by:
Giulianotti
,
R.
11
–
32
.
London
:
Palgrave
.
Young
,
M.
1958
.
The Rise of the Meritocracy, 1870–2033: The New Elite of our Social Revolution
,
New York
:
Random House
.
Clark
,
B.
1960
.
The “Cooling-out” Function in Higher Education
.
American Journal of Sociology
,
65
(
5
)
:
569
–
76
.
Clark
,
B.
1960
.
The “Cooling-out” Function in Higher Education
.
American Journal of Sociology
,
65
(
5
)
:
569
–
76
.
Clark
,
B.
1960
.
The “Cooling-out” Function in Higher Education
.
American Journal of Sociology
,
65
(
5
)
:
569
–
76
.
Anderson
,
P.
1980
.
Arguments within English Marxism
,
London
:
New Left Books
.
Parkin
,
F.
1971
.
Class Inequality and Political Order
,
London
:
Paladin
.
Nicholls
,
J.
1978
.
The Development of the Concepts of Effort and Ability, Perception of Academic Attainment, and the Understanding that Difficult Tasks Require more Ability
.
Child Development
,
49
(
3
)
:
800
–
14
.
Nicholls
,
J.
1984
.
Achievement Motivation: Conceptions of Ability, Subjective Experience, Task Choice, and Performance
.
Psychological Review
,
91
(
3
)
:
328
–
46
.
Ingham
,
A.G.
2004
.
“
The Sportification Process: A Biographical Analysis Framed by the Work of Marx, Weber, Durkheim and Freud
”
. In
Sport and Modern Social Theorists
,
Edited by:
Giulianotti
,
R.
11
–
32
.
London
:
Palgrave
.
Crompton
,
R.
and
Gubbay
,
J.
1977
.
Economy and Class Structure
,
London
:
Macmillan
.
Ingham
,
A.
,
Chase
,
M.
and
Butt
,
J.
2002
.
From the Performance Principle to the Developmental Principle: Every Kid a Winner?
.
Quest
,
54
(
4
)
:
308
–
31
.