104
Views
29
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Research

Gentamicin coating of nanotubular anodized titanium implant reduces implant-related osteomyelitis and enhances bone biocompatibility in rabbits

, , &
Pages 5461-5471 | Published online: 31 Jul 2017

Figures & data

Figure 1 Change patterns of the body temperature, weight and WBC in rabbits of all four groups from day 0 to day 42. (A) The body temperature increased gradually from day 1 to day 3, decreased gradually from day 3 to day 14 and remained stable from day 14 to day 42. The body temperature of NTATi-G and Ti-G groups was lower than Ti groups on day 3 (P<0.05), and no significant difference was found among four groups from day 3 to day 42. (B) The weight of rabbits decreased from day 1 to day 3 and reached the lowest on day 3. Rabbits in NTATi-G and Ti-G groups were heavier on day 3 than NTATi and Ti groups (P<0.05). The weight increased gradually afterward, and there was no difference among four groups from day 3 to day 42. (C) The WBC in NTATi and Ti groups increased gradually from day 1 to day 3 and decreased gradually from day 3 to day 42, whereas in NTATi-G and Ti-G group, WBC increased gradually from day 1 to day 7 and decreased gradually from day 7 to day 42. Besides, the WBC count in NTATi-G was significantly less than in NTATi and Ti groups on days 3, 35 and 42 (P<0.05), and WBC count in Ti-G group was less than in NTATi and Ti groups on days 3, 21 and 42 (P<0.05).

Abbreviations: WBC, white blood cell; NTATi-G, nanotubular anodized titanium coated with gentamicin; Ti-G, titanium coated with gentamicin; NTATi, nanotubular anodized titanium uncoated with gentamicin; Ti, titanium uncoated with gentamicin.

Figure 1 Change patterns of the body temperature, weight and WBC in rabbits of all four groups from day 0 to day 42. (A) The body temperature increased gradually from day 1 to day 3, decreased gradually from day 3 to day 14 and remained stable from day 14 to day 42. The body temperature of NTATi-G and Ti-G groups was lower than Ti groups on day 3 (P<0.05), and no significant difference was found among four groups from day 3 to day 42. (B) The weight of rabbits decreased from day 1 to day 3 and reached the lowest on day 3. Rabbits in NTATi-G and Ti-G groups were heavier on day 3 than NTATi and Ti groups (P<0.05). The weight increased gradually afterward, and there was no difference among four groups from day 3 to day 42. (C) The WBC in NTATi and Ti groups increased gradually from day 1 to day 3 and decreased gradually from day 3 to day 42, whereas in NTATi-G and Ti-G group, WBC increased gradually from day 1 to day 7 and decreased gradually from day 7 to day 42. Besides, the WBC count in NTATi-G was significantly less than in NTATi and Ti groups on days 3, 35 and 42 (P<0.05), and WBC count in Ti-G group was less than in NTATi and Ti groups on days 3, 21 and 42 (P<0.05).Abbreviations: WBC, white blood cell; NTATi-G, nanotubular anodized titanium coated with gentamicin; Ti-G, titanium coated with gentamicin; NTATi, nanotubular anodized titanium uncoated with gentamicin; Ti, titanium uncoated with gentamicin.

Figure 2 Representative radiographs of four experimental groups on days 1, 21 and 42. Periosteal reaction, osteolysis, soft tissue swelling and deformity were observed in NTATi and Ti groups on day 21 and became more obvious on day 42 after surgery; meanwhile, spontaneous fracture and sequestrum formation were not observed in these groups. We did not observe obvious radiography signs of osteomyelitis on day 21, but slight periosteal reaction, osteolysis or soft tissue swelling was observed in some rabbits on day 42 in NTATi-G and Ti-G groups after surgery.

Abbreviations: NTATi-G, nanotubular anodized titanium coated with gentamicin; Ti-G, titanium coated with gentamicin; NTATi, nanotubular anodized titanium uncoated with gentamicin; Ti, titanium uncoated with gentamicin.

Figure 2 Representative radiographs of four experimental groups on days 1, 21 and 42. Periosteal reaction, osteolysis, soft tissue swelling and deformity were observed in NTATi and Ti groups on day 21 and became more obvious on day 42 after surgery; meanwhile, spontaneous fracture and sequestrum formation were not observed in these groups. We did not observe obvious radiography signs of osteomyelitis on day 21, but slight periosteal reaction, osteolysis or soft tissue swelling was observed in some rabbits on day 42 in NTATi-G and Ti-G groups after surgery.Abbreviations: NTATi-G, nanotubular anodized titanium coated with gentamicin; Ti-G, titanium coated with gentamicin; NTATi, nanotubular anodized titanium uncoated with gentamicin; Ti, titanium uncoated with gentamicin.

Table 1 Mean score of radiographic assessment on days 0, 21 and 42

Table 2 Microbiological results and bone weight determined on the day of sacrifice

Figure 3 Results of microbiological evaluation in four groups on day 42. (A) Bacterial colony formation of implants on agar plates. (B) Bacterial colony formation of bone tissues on agar plates.

Abbreviations: NTATi-G, nanotubular anodized titanium coated with gentamicin; Ti-G, titanium coated with gentamicin; NTATi, nanotubular anodized titanium uncoated with gentamicin; Ti, titanium uncoated with gentamicin.

Figure 3 Results of microbiological evaluation in four groups on day 42. (A) Bacterial colony formation of implants on agar plates. (B) Bacterial colony formation of bone tissues on agar plates.Abbreviations: NTATi-G, nanotubular anodized titanium coated with gentamicin; Ti-G, titanium coated with gentamicin; NTATi, nanotubular anodized titanium uncoated with gentamicin; Ti, titanium uncoated with gentamicin.

Figure 4 Photomicrographs of longitudinal sections from proximal tibiae, with toluidine blue staining. The bone volume (black arrowheads) in NTATi-G group was greater than Ti-G group; meanwhile, there was little bone formation in NTATi and Ti groups. Typical signs of infections (red arrows) were observed in NTATi and Ti histological slices, while NTATi-G and Ti-G groups showed no signs of apparent bone infection.

Abbreviations: NTATi-G, nanotubular anodized titanium coated with gentamicin; Ti-G, titanium coated with gentamicin; NTATi, nanotubular anodized titanium uncoated with gentamicin; Ti, titanium uncoated with gentamicin.

Figure 4 Photomicrographs of longitudinal sections from proximal tibiae, with toluidine blue staining. The bone volume (black arrowheads) in NTATi-G group was greater than Ti-G group; meanwhile, there was little bone formation in NTATi and Ti groups. Typical signs of infections (red arrows) were observed in NTATi and Ti histological slices, while NTATi-G and Ti-G groups showed no signs of apparent bone infection.Abbreviations: NTATi-G, nanotubular anodized titanium coated with gentamicin; Ti-G, titanium coated with gentamicin; NTATi, nanotubular anodized titanium uncoated with gentamicin; Ti, titanium uncoated with gentamicin.

Table 3 Mean pathological scores on the day of sacrifice

Figure 5 Photomicrographs of longitudinal sections from the proximal tibiae, with hematoxylin and eosin staining. Column A (A1D1), overview of signs of osteomyelitis in the proximal metaphysis. Magnification, ×20. Column B (A2D2), moderate-to-severe inflammation with massive enlargement and destruction of the bone tissue (black arrow) and chronic inflammatory cells (red arrows) in the NTATi and Ti groups and mild inflammation in the NTATi-G and Ti-G groups. Magnification, ×40. Column C (A3D3), moderate-to-severe inflammation with intramedullary abscesses and acute or chronic inflammatory cells (red arrows) around necrotic bony trabeculae (black arrow) and fibrosis (yellow arrows) in the NTATi and Ti groups, and mild inflammation in the NTATi-G and Ti-G groups. Magnification, ×100.

Abbreviations: NTATi-G, nanotubular anodized titanium coated with gentamicin; Ti-G, titanium coated with gentamicin; NTATi, nanotubular anodized titanium uncoated with gentamicin; Ti, titanium uncoated with gentamicin.

Figure 5 Photomicrographs of longitudinal sections from the proximal tibiae, with hematoxylin and eosin staining. Column A (A1–D1), overview of signs of osteomyelitis in the proximal metaphysis. Magnification, ×20. Column B (A2–D2), moderate-to-severe inflammation with massive enlargement and destruction of the bone tissue (black arrow) and chronic inflammatory cells (red arrows) in the NTATi and Ti groups and mild inflammation in the NTATi-G and Ti-G groups. Magnification, ×40. Column C (A3–D3), moderate-to-severe inflammation with intramedullary abscesses and acute or chronic inflammatory cells (red arrows) around necrotic bony trabeculae (black arrow) and fibrosis (yellow arrows) in the NTATi and Ti groups, and mild inflammation in the NTATi-G and Ti-G groups. Magnification, ×100.Abbreviations: NTATi-G, nanotubular anodized titanium coated with gentamicin; Ti-G, titanium coated with gentamicin; NTATi, nanotubular anodized titanium uncoated with gentamicin; Ti, titanium uncoated with gentamicin.

Figure S1 Scanning electron micrographs of the titanium surface after anodization. (A) NTATi surface under high magnification, scale bar 200 nm. (B) Length of the NTATi under high magnification, scale bar 500 nm. (C) Energy dispersive spectrum of NTATi samples revealed the existence of Ti, O and Na; atom% of Ti:O is about 1:2. The condition used for anodization was 60 V for 30 min in 0.09 M NH4F in ethylene glycol solution containing 10 vol% water.

Abbreviations: NTATi, nanotubular anodized titanium uncoated with gentamicin; Ti, titanium uncoated with gentamicin; O, oxide; Na, sodium.

Figure S1 Scanning electron micrographs of the titanium surface after anodization. (A) NTATi surface under high magnification, scale bar 200 nm. (B) Length of the NTATi under high magnification, scale bar 500 nm. (C) Energy dispersive spectrum of NTATi samples revealed the existence of Ti, O and Na; atom% of Ti:O is about 1:2. The condition used for anodization was 60 V for 30 min in 0.09 M NH4F in ethylene glycol solution containing 10 vol% water.Abbreviations: NTATi, nanotubular anodized titanium uncoated with gentamicin; Ti, titanium uncoated with gentamicin; O, oxide; Na, sodium.