Abstract
Farmers who produce multiple outputs are portfolio managers in the sense that they use inputs to balance expected economic return and variance of return. This article estimates the structure of the stochastic multioutput production technology in Norwegian dairy farming, allowing for a more flexible specification of the technology than previous studies. We find that an increase in input levels leads primarily to higher output variability, and that inputs also influence the covariance of shocks between outputs. Risk reducing effects of inputs on outputs are primarily present in the covariance functions. Technical change leads to shifts in the profit distribution over the data period, but no welfare improvement for risk averse farmers.
Acknowledgements
Comments from participants at a seminar at the Norwegian Agricultural Economics Research Institute, J. Brian Hardaker, Subal C. Kumbhakar and an anonymous referee are gratefully acknowledged. This research was funded by the Research Council of Norway.
Notes
1 Econometric studies of production risk in agriculture using a primal model approach include Just and Pope (Citation1979), Griffiths and Anderson (Citation1982), Antle (Citation1983), Antle and Goodger (Citation1984), Nelson and Preckel (Citation1989), Wan and Anderson (Citation1990), Wan et al. (Citation1992), Kumbhakar (Citation1993), Traxler et al. (Citation1995), Regev et al. (Citation1997), Roberts et al. (Citation2004), Di Falco et al. (Citation2007), Groom et al. (Citation2008), Serra et al. (Citation2006, Citation2009) and Shankar et al. (Citation2008), while aquaculture has been studied by Asche and Tveteras (Citation1999) and Tveteras (Citation1999, Citation2000).
2 The state contingent approach (Chambers and Quiggin, Citation2001) has been introduced as an alternative to the traditional parametric stochastic production function approaches such as the JP specification belongs. Full application of the state contingent approach is very data demanding (Just, Citation2003), and empirical study based on this approach has only recently appeared in the agricultural economics literature (O’Donnell and Griffiths, Citation2006; Chavas, Citation2008).
3 See Just and Pope (Citation1978) for other requirements for a risky production technology.
4 Examples of multi-output technology estimation in the absence of production risk is given in Nehring et al. (Citation2005).
5 An input is allocable when the amount of the input used in producing output yj
can be distinguished from the amount of the same input used in producing yk
(j ≠ k) (Beattie and Taylor, Citation1985).
6 However, the subjective weighting of the marginal effects is determined by the producer's degree of risk aversion, i.e. the size of dU*/dVar(π).
7 Driscoll et al. (Citation1992) compare the flexibility properties of the TL and GL. Tveteras (1999, Citation2000) estimate both translog and GL mean production functions. Several studies have employed the more restrictive CD specification for the mean function, e.g. Hallam et al. (Citation1989) and Wan et al. (Citation1992) in their multi-output JP functions. They were then forced to estimate the CD nonlinearly in order not to violate the JP postulates.
8 The first element of z, z
0, is taken as unity. This implies that Var(ε) = exp(β
0).
10 The estimated parameters are not reported here due to space considerations, but are available from the authors upon request.
Just
,
RE
and
Pope
,
RD
.
1979
.
Production function estimation and related risk considerations
.
American Journal of Agricultural Economics
,
61
:
276
–
84
.
Griffiths
,
WE
and
Anderson
,
JR
.
1982
.
Using time-series and cross-section data to estimate a production function with positive and negative marginal risks
.
Journal of the American Statistical Association
,
77
:
529
–
36
.
Antle
,
JM
.
1983
.
Testing the stochastic structure of production: a flexible moment-based approach
.
Journal of Business and Economic Statistics
,
1
:
192
–
201
.
Antle
,
JM
and
Goodger
,
WJ
.
1984
.
Measuring stochastic technology: the case of Tulare milk production
.
American Journal of Agricultural Economics
,
66
:
342
–
50
.
Nelson
,
CH
and
Preckel
,
PV
.
1989
.
The conditional beta distribution as a stochastic production function
.
American Journal of Agricultural Economics
,
71
:
370
–
8
.
Wan
,
GH
and
Anderson
,
JR
.
1990
.
Estimating risk effects in Chinese foodgrain production
.
Journal of Agricultural Economics
,
41
:
85
–
93
.
Wan
,
GH
,
Griffiths
,
WE
and
Anderson
,
JR
.
1992
.
Using panel data to estimate risk effects in seemingly unrelated production functions
.
Empirical Economics
,
17
:
35
–
49
.
Kumbhakar
,
SC
.
1993
.
Production risk, technical efficiency, and panel data
.
Economics Letters
,
41
:
11
–
16
.
Traxler
,
G
,
Falck-Zepeda
,
J
,
Ortiz-Monasterio
,
RJI
and
Sayre
,
K
.
1995
.
Production risk and the evolution of varietal technology
.
American Journal of Agricultural Economics
,
77
:
1
–
7
.
Regev
,
U
,
Gotsch
,
N
and
Rieder
,
P
.
1997
.
Are fungicides, nitrogen and plant growth regulators risk-reducing? Empirical evidence from Swiss wheat production
.
Journal of Agricultural Economics
,
48
:
167
–
78
.
Roberts
,
RK
,
Walters
,
JT
,
Larson
,
JA
,
English
,
BC
and
Howard
,
DD
.
2004
.
Effects of disease, nitrogen source, and risk on optimal nitrogen fertilization timing in winter wheat production
.
Agronomy Journal
,
96
:
792
–
9
.
Di Falco
,
S
,
Chavas
,
JP
and
Smale
,
M
.
2007
.
Farmer management of production risk on degraded lands: the role of wheat variety diversity in the Tigray region, Ethiopia
.
Agricultural Economics
,
36
:
147
–
56
.
Groom
,
B
,
Koundouri
,
P
,
Nauges
,
C
and
Thomas
,
A
.
2008
.
The story of the moment: risk averse Cypriot farmers respond to drought management
.
Applied Economics
,
40
:
315
–
26
.
Serra
,
T
,
Zilberman
,
D
,
Goodwin
,
BK
and
Featherstone
,
A
.
2006
.
Effects of decoupling on the mean and variability of output
.
European Review of Agricultural Economics
,
33
:
269
–
88
.
Serra
,
T
,
Zilberman
,
D
,
Gil
,
JM
and
Featherstone
,
A
.
2009
.
The effects of decoupling on land allocation
.
Applied Economics
,
41
:
2323
–
33
.
Shankar
,
B
,
Bennett
,
R
and
Morse
,
S
.
2008
.
Production risk, pesticide use and GM crop technology in South Africa
.
Applied Economics
,
40
:
2489
–
500
.
Asche
,
F
and
Tveteras
,
R
.
1999
.
Modeling production risk with a two-step procedure
.
Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics
,
24
:
424
–
39
.
Tveteras
,
R
.
1999
.
Production risk and productivity growth: some findings for Norwegian salmon aquaculture
.
Journal of Productivity Analysis
,
12
:
161
–
79
.
Tveteras
,
R
.
2000
.
Flexible panel data models for risky production technologies with an application to salmon aquaculture
.
Econometric Reviews
,
19
:
367
–
89
.
Chambers
,
RG
and
Quiggin
,
J
.
2001
.
Uncertainty, Production, Choice, and Agency: The State-Contingent Approach
,
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Just
,
RE
.
2003
.
Risk research in agricultural economics: opportunities and challenges for the next twenty-five years
.
Agricultural Systems
,
75
:
123
–
59
.
O’Donnell
,
CJ
and
Griffiths
,
WE
.
2006
.
Estimating state-contingent production frontiers
.
American Journal of Agricultural Economics
,
88
:
249
–
66
.
Chavas
,
JP
.
2008
.
A cost approach to economic analysis under state-contingent production uncertainty
.
American Journal of Agricultural Economics
,
90
:
435
–
46
.
Just
,
RE
and
Pope
,
RD
.
1978
.
Stochastic specification of production functions and economic implications
.
Journal of Econometrics
,
7
:
67
–
86
.
Nehring
,
R
,
Fernandez-Cornejo
,
J
and
Banker
,
D
.
2005
.
Off-farm labour and the structure of US agriculture: the case of corn/soybean farms
.
Applied Economics
,
37
:
633
–
49
.
Beattie
,
BR
and
Taylor
,
CR
.
1985
.
The Economics of Production
,
New York
:
John Wiley & Sons
.
Driscoll
,
P
,
McGuirk
,
A
and
Alwang
,
J
.
1992
.
Testing hypotheses of functional structure: some rules for determining flexibility of restricted production models
.
American Journal of Agricultural Economics
,
74
:
100
–
8
.
Tveteras
,
R
.
2000
.
Flexible panel data models for risky production technologies with an application to salmon aquaculture
.
Econometric Reviews
,
19
:
367
–
89
.
Hallam
,
A
,
Hassan
,
RM
and
D’Silva
,
B
.
1989
.
Measuring stochastic technology for the multi-product firm: the irrigated farms of Sudan
.
Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics
,
37
:
495
–
512
.
Wan
,
GH
,
Griffiths
,
WE
and
Anderson
,
JR
.
1992
.
Using panel data to estimate risk effects in seemingly unrelated production functions
.
Empirical Economics
,
17
:
35
–
49
.