Abstract
This article presents an analysis of real wages, inflation and labour productivity interrelationships using cointegration, Granger causality and, most importantly, structural change tests. Applications of tests to Australian data over the 1965 to 2007 period corroborate the presence of a structural break in 1985 and show that a 1% increase in manufacturing sector real wages led to an increase in manufacturing sector productivity of between 0.5% and 0.8%. Comparable estimates for the effect of inflation on manufacturing sector productivity have limited statistical significance. Granger causality test results suggest that real wages and inflation both Granger cause productivity in the long run.
Acknowledgements
The authors are grateful to Professors B. Bhaskara Rao, Dimitris Christopoulos, Erinc Yeldan, Jack Strauss, Peter Howells and Toni Mora for comments on earlier drafts. All errors are the authors’ responsibility.
Notes
1 In addition to those discussed elsewhere in this article the list includes: Geary (Citation1976), Denny and May (Citation1977), Gordon (1984, 1988), Buck and Fitzroy (Citation1988), Crafts (Citation1992), De Gregorio (Citation1992), Sbordone and Kuttner (Citation1994), Smyth (Citation1995), Cameron et al. (Citation1996), Feijo (Citation1997), Palokangas (Citation1997), Hondroyiannis and Papapetrou (Citation1998), Freeman and Yerger (Citation2000), Blanchard and Katz (Citation1999), Fountas et al. (Citation1999), Ghali (Citation1999), Tsionas (Citation2003b), Dritsakis (Citation2004), L’horty and Rault (Citation2004), Hsu (Citation2005), Mahadevan and Asafu-Adjaye (Citation2006) and Bildirici and Alp (Citation2008).
2 Our productivity measure is output per hour per worker which is calculated as total industrial output (in monetary terms) divided by the total industrial employment. Nominal wages are deflated by the consumer price index to provide a measure of workers’ real purchasing power.
3 For more details on these tests, see Rao and Kumar (2007, 2009) and Kumar (Citation2009).
4 See Gregory and Hansen (Citation1996a) for the tabulated critical values of cointegration tests with unknown breaks using the EG method.
5 Due to short sample biases, we ignored the sub-sample estimations. However, in any other situation where quarterly or monthly data is used, it would be prudent to estimate cointegrating equations using sub-sample periods considering the break dates from the structural break tests.
6Further investigation is necessary to identify whether this is due to: (1) higher real wages increasing the opportunity cost of job loss that can stimulate greater work effort to avoid redundancy, (2) higher real wages putting upward pressure on labour costs and causing firms to substitute labour for capital, thereby increasing in the marginal productivity of labour, (3) greater capital stocks increasing the demand for (typically high skilled) labour, thereby increasing the real wage, and stimulating productivity or (4) domestic pressures on real wages stimulating a movement towards the adoption of capital.
7It could also be because, it should be inflation expectations rather than actual inflation which drive investment decisions and therefore future productivity.
Geary
,
P
.
1976
.
World prices and the inflationary process in a small open economy: the case of Ireland
.
The Economic and Social Review
,
7
:
391
–
400
.
Denny
,
M
and
May
,
D
.
1977
.
The existence of a real value added function in the Canadian manufacturing sector
.
Journal of Econometrics
,
5
:
55
–
69
.
Buck
,
AJ
and
Fitzroy
,
F
.
1988
.
Inflation and productivity growth in the federal republic of Germany
.
Journal of Post Keynesian Economics
,
10
:
428
–
44
.
Crafts
,
N
.
1992
.
Productivity growth reconsidered
.
Economic Policy
,
10
:
387
–
426
.
De Gregorio
,
J
.
1992
.
The effects of inflation on economic growth: lessons from Latin America
.
European Economic Review
,
36
:
417
–
25
.
Rao
,
BB
and
Kumar
,
S
.
2009
.
Cointegration, structural breaks and demand for money in Bangladesh
.
Applied Economics
,
41
:
1277
–
83
.
Sbordone
,
A
and
Kuttner
,
K
.
1994
.
Does inflation reduce productivity?
.
Economic Perspectives
,
18
:
2
–
14
.
Cameron
,
N
,
Hum
,
D
and
Simpson
,
W
.
1996
.
Stylized facts and stylized illusions: inflation and productivity revisited
.
Canadian Journal of Economics
,
29
:
152
–
62
.
Feijo
,
C
.
1997
.
Growth and inflation in the Brazilian industrial sector in the 1970s: a post Keynesian model
.
Journal of Post Keynesian Economics
,
19
:
437
–
60
.
Mora
,
T
,
Lopez-Tamayo
,
J
and
Surinach
,
J
.
2005
.
Are wages and productivity converging simultaneously in Euro-area countries?
.
Applied Economics
,
37
:
2001
–
8
.
Hondroyiannis
,
G
and
Papapetrou
,
E
.
1998
.
Temporal causality and the inflation-productivity relationship: evidence from eight low inflation OECD countries
.
International Review of Economics and Finance
,
7
:
117
–
35
.
Freeman
,
DG
and
Yerger
,
DB
.
2000
.
Does inflation lower productivity? Time series evidence on the impact of inflation on labour productivity in 12 OECD nations
.
Atlanta Economic Journal
,
28
:
315
–
32
.
Blanchard
,
OJ
and
Katz
,
L
.
1999
.
Wage dynamics: reconciling theory and evidence
.
American Economic Review
,
89
:
69
–
74
.
Fountas
,
S
,
Lally
,
B
and
Lin
,
J
.
1999
.
The relationship between inflation and wage growth in the Irish economy
.
Applied Economics Letters
,
6
:
317
–
21
.
Ghali
,
KH
.
1999
.
Wage growth and the inflation process: a multivariate cointegration analysis
.
Journal of Money, Credit and Banking
,
31
:
417
–
31
.
Tsionas
,
EG
.
2003a
.
Inflation and productivity in Europe: an empirical investigation
.
Empirica
,
30
:
39
–
62
.
Dritsakis
,
N
.
2004
.
A causal relationship between inflation and productivity: an empirical approach for Romania
.
American Journal of Applied Sciences
,
1
:
121
–
8
.
L’horty
,
Y
and
Rault
,
C
.
2004
.
Inflation, minimum wage and other wages: an econometric study of French macroeconomic data
.
Applied Economics
,
36
:
36277
–
90
.
Hsu
,
PF
.
2005
.
Inter-industry wage premiums and industry-specific productivity in Taiwan
.
Applied Economics
,
37
:
1523
–
33
.
Mahadevan
,
R
and
Asafu-Adjaye
,
J
.
2006
.
Is there a case for low inflation-induced productivity growth in selected Asian economies?
.
Contemporary Economic Policy
,
24
:
249
–
61
.
Bildirici
,
M
and
Alp
,
EA
.
2008
.
The relationship between wages and productivity: TAR unit root and TAR cointegration approach
.
International Journal of Applied Econometrics and Quantitative Studies
,
5
:
93
–
110
.
Kumar
,
S
.
2009
.
Structural breaks and exports in Philippines
.
Global Economy Journal
,
9
:
1
–
8
.
Gregory
,
AW
and
Hansen
,
B. E. (GH)
.
1996a
.
Residual-based tests for cointegration in models with regime shifts
.
Journal of Econometrics
,
70
:
99
–
126
.