Effect of the Extraction Period on the Routine Assessment of Soil P Status by Ion‐Exchange Resin Membranes

Abstract

The cation–anion exchange resin membrane (CAERM) system is one of the most promising alternative methodologies for the assessment of soil phosphorus (P) availability. Nevertheless, the CAERM method has a recommended period of extraction (16 h) that limits its applicability. With the aim to improve the use of CAERM in routine laboratory work, seven extraction times were studied and compared for repeatability and biological accuracy, using 150 samples of soils and covering a wide range of properties. The results showed dissimilar quantities of extractable P, according to the nature of soils and the period of extraction time. On average of all soils, values of extractable P ranged from a 2.4 mg kg⁻¹ and 26.7 mg kg⁻¹ in 0.25‐h and 16‐h extraction times, respectively. Relative to the repeatability aspects, the results reveal a tendency of increasing results with the decrease of the period of extraction, showing coefficient variation (CV) values ranging from 5% (16 h) to 14% (0.25 h). All the extraction periods tested for the CAERM presented highly significant values of r (0.824–0.943) between extractable P and each of the three biological parameters: relative yield of ryegrass, P content, and P uptake. Considering the three biological parameters simultaneously, the best results were obtained for extraction periods of 8 h, 2 h, and 4 h. Based on the results, and considering both practical and accuracy aspects, it is conclude that 2 h of extraction is a valid alternative to the 16‐h standard extraction period for the CAERM methodology.

Keywords:

• Exchange resins
• methods
• phosphorus
• soil testing

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The authors thank L. Fernandes, M. Arrobas, and C. Travassos for supplying some of the data related to the ryegrass pot experiment in this study.