Relationships between four methods of organic carbon determination in leaves of nitrogen‐fixing trees and lignite‐based organic fertilizers

Abstract

Organic carbon (OC) in leaves of seven nitrogen (N₂)‐fixing trees and fifteen lignite‐based fertilizers was measured by loss‐on‐ignition (LOI at 500°C), wet oxidation by the Walkley‐Black method (CWB), Tinsley Dichromate Method (CTS), and dry combustion method using a LECO SC444 Carbon/ Sulphur Resistance Furnace Analyzer (CTO). There were significant differences in the capabilities of the methods in measuring OC from the organic materials with the quantity measured in the following order: LOI > CTO > CTS > CWB. A highly significant difference between LOI and CTO values suggested that components other than organic carbon (C) were removed by LOI since CTO gives total C value. The result also showed that N content in the organic materials was highly correlated with OC measured by individual methods. The LOI, CWB, and CTS were significantly correlated with CTO. The regression equations which were specific for either plant leaves or lignite‐based fertilizers indicated that any of the methods could be used to predict total C in the organic materials with a high degree of precision. In addition to the regression approach, an estimated correction factor of 1.4550 would be more appropriate to predict CTO from CWB for plant leaves than the 1.30 factor usually used for estimating oxidizable C in soils when CWB method is used. Also, a factor of 0.36180 could be used to estimate total C from LOI method for lignite fertilizers instead of merely regarding the difference in weight loss as the total organic matter.