Psychophysical and physiological responses to lifting symmetrical and asymmetrical loads symmetrically and asymmetrically

Abstract

Eighteen adult males (mean age 22·6 years, weight 78·6kg and height 176·6cm) participated in a study designed to investigate the effects of symmetrical and asymmetrical lifting on the maximum acceptable weight of lift and the resulting physiological cost. Each subject performed sixty different lifting tasks involving two lifting heights, three lifting frequencies and five containers. For each lifting task, the load was lifted either symmetrically (sagittal lifting) or asymmetrically (turning 90^° while continuing to lift). The heart rate and oxygen uptake of the individuals at the maximum acceptable weight of lift were measured. At the end of the experiment, subjects also verbally indicated their preference for symmetrical and asymmetrical lifting. When lifting asymmetrically, subjects accepted approximately 8·5% less weight. There was, however, no difference in the physiological costs when lifting symmetrically or asymmetrically. Lifting asymmetrical loads also resulted in lower maximum acceptable weights. No difference in either oxygen uptake or heart rate was observed when the centre of gravity of the load was offset by 10·16 or 20·32 cm from the mid-sagittal plane in the frontal plane towards the preferred hand. All subjects indicated, verbally, that asymmetrical lifting tasks were physically more difficult to perform.