Alarm effectiveness in driver-centred collision-warning systems

Abstract

The potential use of systems that seek to communicate a warning of impending collision directly to the driver is examined. Technological advances in collisionwarning systems include reliable, low-cost radars, sensors with low noise levels, and the development of accurate detection algorithms for particular crash types, e.g. rearend collisions. However, fundamental practical constraints make perfect sensor detection difficult to achieve. Imperfect detection conflates the false alarm rate and experience with other technologies confirms driver aversion to false warnings. Although sensitive alarm systems with high detection rates and low false alarm rates have been developed, the posterior probability of a collision given an alarm can be quite low because of the low base rate of collision events. As a result, only a small proportion of alarms will represent true collision scenarios. These and other factors can conspire to reduce alarm effectiveness in collision-warning systems. The problem is illustrated analytically and potential solutions are advanced.

Keywords:

• Alarms
• Collision-warning Systems
• Driver Reaction
• Intelligent Travel Systems (ITS)
• False Alarms
• Posterior Probability
• Human-centred Design.