Investigation of the π–π stacking interactions without direct electrostatic effects of substituents: the aromatic∥aromatic and aromatic∥anti-aromatic complexes

Abstract

Stability of the π–π stacking interactions in the ben∥substituted-ben and ben∥substituted-COT complexes was studied using the computational quantum chemistry methods (where ben and COT are benzene and cyclooctatetraene, ∥ denotes π–π stacking interaction, substituted-ben and substituted-COT are benzene and cyclooctatetraene which substituted with four ethynyl-X groups, respectively, and X = OH, CH₃, H, F, CF₃, CN and NO₂). In these complexes electron-withdrawing substituents lead to larger binding energies and electron-donating ones lead to weaker interactions compared to X = H. There are meaningful correlations between the Hammett constants and binding energies. The atoms in molecules (AIM) analysis shows that formation of these complexes is accompanied by increase in the electron charge densities at the ring critical points of the substituted-ben and substituted-COT rings which leads to increase/decrease of the π–π stacking interactions in the ben∥substituted-ben/ben∥substituted-COT complexes. The charge transfer occurs from benzene to substituted-ben in the ben∥substituted-ben complexes and from substituted-COT to benzene (with the exception of X = CN) in the ben∥substituted-COT ones. Nuclear magnetic resonance calculations demonstrate that interactions of the more aromatic substituted-ben/less anti-aromatic substituted-COT rings with benzene in the ben∥substituted-ben/ben∥substituted-COT complexes can be helpful to enhance strength of the π–π stacking interactions. Thus, regardless of ring size, the π–π stacking interaction is an aromatic–aromatic interaction and π electron cloud properties of interacting rings affect on the strength of this interaction.

Keywords:

• benzene
• cyclooctatetraene
• π–π stacking
• charge transfer
• π electron cloud

Acknowledgements

We thank the university of Sistan & Baluchestan for financial supports and Computational Quantum Chemistry Laboratory for computational facilities.