Against racial medicine

ABSTRACT

Some scholars claim that recent studies of human genetic variation validate the existence of human biological races and falsify the idea that human races are socially constructed misconceptions. They assert that analyses of DNA polymorphisms unambiguously partition individuals into groups that are very similar to lay conceptions of race. Furthermore, they propose that this partitioning allows us to identify specific loci that can explain contemporary health disparities between the supposed human races. From this, it appears that racial medicine has risen again. In this essay Graves and Rose construct a case against racial medicine. Biological races in other species are strongly differentiated genetically. Because human populations do not have such strong genetic differentiation, they are not biological races. Nonetheless, the lack of population genetic knowledge among biomedical researchers has led to spuriously racialized human studies. But human populations are not genetically disjoint. Social dominance may lead to medical differences between socially constructed races. In order to resolve these issues, medicine should take both social environment and population genetics into account, instead of dubious ‘races’ that inappropriately conflate the two.

Keywords:

• biomedicine
• human classification
• genetics
• race
• racial medicine
• racial profiling

Notes

¹Charles B. Davenport, ‘The hereditary factor in pellagra’ (1917), quoted in Allan Chase, The Legacy of Malthus: The Social Costs of the New Scientific Racism (New York: Alfred A. Knopf 1977), 203.

²James H. Jones, Bad Blood: The Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment (New York: The Free Press and London: Collier Macmillan 1981), 28.

³Robert S. Schwartz, ‘Racial profiling in medical research’, and Alistair J. J. Wood, ‘Racial differences in responses to drugs—pointers to genetic differences’, New England Journal of Medicine, vol. 344. no. 18, May 2001, 1392–3 and 1393–6, respectively.

⁴Sally Satel, ‘I am a racially profiling doctor’, New York Times Sunday Magazine, 5 May 2002.

⁵Armand Marie Leroi, ‘A family tree in every gene’, New York Times, 14 Mach 2005, A23; A. W. F. Edwards, ‘Human genetic diversity: Lewontin's fallacy’, Bioessays, vol. 25, no. 8, August 2003, 798–801.

⁶Ashley Montagu, Man's Most Dangerous Myth: The Fallacy of Race, rev. 5th edn (New York: Oxford University Press 1974).

⁷C. Loring Brace, ‘Region does not mean “race”—reality versus convention in forensic anthropology’, Journal of Forensic Sciences, vol. 40, no. 2, March 1995, 29–33.

⁸Sewall Wright, Evolution and the Genetics of Populations. Vol. 4: Variability within and among Natural Populations (Chicago: University Chicago Press 1978).

⁹Robert H. Podolsky and Timothy P. Holtsford, ‘Population structure of morphological traits in Clarkia dudleyana: I. Comparison of F_st between allozymes and morphological traits’, Genetics, vol. 140, no. 2, June 1995, 733–44.

¹⁰Jeffrey C. Long and Rick A. Kittles, ‘Human genetic diversity and the non-existence of biological races’, Human Biology, vol. 75, no. 4, August 2003, 449–71.

¹¹Henrik Kaessmann, Victor Wiebe and Svante Pääbo, ‘Extensive nuclear DNA sequence diversity among chimpanzees’, Science, vol. 286, 5 November 1999, 1159–62.

¹²Sonya M. Clegg, Sandie M. Degnan, Jiro Kikkawa, Craig Moritz, Arnaud Estoup and Ian P. F. Owens, ‘Genetic consequences of sequential founder events by an island-colonizing bird’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 99, no. 12, June 2002, 8127–32.

¹³Vincent Sarich and Frank Miele, Race: The Reality of Human Differences (Boulder, CO and Oxford: Westview 2004).

¹⁴J. Barley, A. Blackwood, M. Miller, N. D. Markandu, N. D. Carter, S. Jeffery, F. P. Cappuccio, G. A. MacGregor and G. A. Sagnella, ‘Angiotensin converting enzyme gene I/D polymorphism, blood pressure and the renin-angiotensin system in Caucasian and Afro-Caribbean peoples’, Journal of Human Hypertension, vol. 10, no. 1, January 1996, 31–5; Hong-Guang Xie, C. Michael Stein, Richard B. Kim, James V. Gainer, Gbenga Sofowora, Victor Dishy, Nancy J. Brown, Robert E. Goree, Jonathan L. Haines and Alastair J. J. Wood, ‘Human β2-adrenergic receptor polymorphisms: no association with essential hypertension in black and white Americans’, Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics, vol. 67, no. 6, June 2000, 670–5.

¹⁵Hua Tang, Tom Quertermous, Beatriz Rodriguez, Sharon L. R. Kardia, Xiaofeng Zhu, Andrew Brown, James S. Pankow, Michael A. Province, Steven C. Hunt, Eric Boerwinkle, Nicholas J. Schork and Neil J. Risch, ‘Genetic structure, self-identified race/ethnicity, and confounding in case-control association studies’, American Journal of Human Genetics, vol. 76, no. 2, February 2005, 268–75.

¹⁶Sarah A. Tishkoff and Kenneth K. Kidd, ‘Implications of biogeography of human populations for “race” and medicine’, Nature Genetics, vol. 36, no. 11 (Supplement), November 2004, S21–S27.

¹⁷Inbal Kedar-Barnes and Rozen Paul, ‘The Jewish people: their ethnic history, genetic disorders and specific cancer susceptibility’, Familial Cancer, vol. 3, nos 3–4, September 2004, 193–9.

¹⁸David Hinds, Laura Stuve, Geoffrey Nilsen, Eran Halperin, Eleazar Eskin, Dennis Ballinger, Kelly Frazer and David Cox, ‘Whole-genome patterns of common DNA variation in three human populations’, Science, vol. 307, 18 February 2005, 1072–9.

¹⁹Luigi Luca Cavalli-Sforza, Paolo Menozzi and Alberto Piazza, The History and Geography of Human Genes (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press 1994). See also Alan R. Templeton, ‘The genetic and evolutionary significance of human races’, in Jefferson M. Fish (ed.), Race and Intelligence: Separating Science from Myth (Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum 2002); Frank B. Livingstone, ‘On the non-existence of human races’, Current Anthropology, vol. 3, no. 3, June 1962, 279–81.

²⁰Templeton, ‘The genetic and evolutionary significance of human races’.

²¹Lynn B. Jorde and Steph en P. Wooding, ‘Genetic variation, classification, and race’, Nature Genetics, vol. 36, no. 11 (Supplement), November 2004, S28–S33.

²²A. Arnaiz-Villena, K. Dimitroski, A. Pacho, J. Moscoso, E. Gómez-Casado, C. Silvera-Redondo, P. Varela, M. Blagoevska, V. Zdravkovska and J. Martínez-Laso, ‘HLA genes in Macedonians and the sub-Saharan origin of the Greeks’, Tissue Antigens, vol. 57, no. 2, February 2001, 118–27.

²³John H. Relethford, ‘Apportionment of global human genetic diversity based on craniometrics and skin color’, American Journal of Physical Anthropology, vol. 118, no. 4, August 2002, 393–8.

²⁴Vicente Navarro, ‘Race or class versus race and class: mortality differentials in the United States’, The Lancet, vol. 336, no. 8725, 1990, 1238–40; Ichiro Kawachi, Norman Daniels and Dean E. Robinson, ‘Health disparities by race and class: why both matter’, Health Affairs, vol. 24, no. 2, March–April 2005, 343–52.

²⁵Moumita Sinha, Emma K. Larkin, Robert C. Elston and Susan Redline, ‘Self-reported race and genetic admixture’, New England Journal of Medicine, vol. 354, no. 4, January 2006, 421–2.

²⁶Jay S. Kaufman and Susan A. Hall, ‘The slavery hypertension hypothesis: dissemination and appeal of modern race theory’, Epidemiology, vol. 14, no. 1, January 2003, 111–26.

²⁷Joseph L. Graves, Jr, The Race Myth: Why We Pretend Race Exists in America (New York: Dutton 2005), 126.

²⁸James F. Wilson, Michael E. Weale, Alice C. Smith, Fiona Gratrix, Benjamin Fletcher, Mark G. Thomas, Neil Bradman and David B. Goldstein, ‘Population genetic structure of variable drug response’, Nature Genetics, vol. 29, no. 3, November 2001, 265–9; Sarah K. Tate and David B. Goldstein, ‘Will tomorrow's medicines work for everyone?’, Nature Genetics, vol. 36, no. 11 (Supplement), November 2004, S34–S42.

²⁹Elissa S. Epel, Elizabeth H. Blackburn, Jue Lin, Firdaus S. Dhabhar, Nancy E. Adler, Jason D. Morrow and Richard M. Cawthon, ‘Accelerated telomere shortening in response to life stress’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 101, no. 49, December 2004, 17312–15.

³⁰Jen'nan Ghazal Read, Michael O. Emerson and Alvin Tarlov, ‘Implications of black immigrant health for U.S. racial disparities in health’, Journal of Immigrant Health, vol. 7, no. 3, July 2005, 205-12; Jen'nan Ghazal Read and Michael O. Emerson, ‘Racial context of origin, black immigration, and the U.S. black/white health disparity’, Social Forces, vol. 84, no. 1, September 2005, 183–201.

³¹Steven H. Woolf, Robert E. Johnson, George E. Fryer, Jr, George Rust and David Satcher, ‘The health impact of resolving racial disparities: an analysis of US mortality data’, American Journal of Public Health, vol. 94, no. 12, December 2004, 2078–81.