The social component of mortality decline: An investigation in south India employing alternative methodologies

Abstract

This paper reports on research in which an attempt is made to explore and explain the impact of social changes on mortality decline. The work has been part of a four-year project in nine villages of Karnataka, South India, and anthropological as well as survey approaches have been used. In the study area mortality continued to fall long after control of the major epidemic diseases had been achieved, although no addition had been made to the existing modern medical facilities. These facilities still attract only a fraction of the patients that might be expected from the experience of countries in which mortality is low and disproportionately few very young or old persons attend. It was found that most treatment given followed neither the methods of modern nor those of ayurvedic medicine, and that the identification of the type of illness and subsequent treatment depended on the fundamental belief system of the villages. The change to modern medicine is one aspect of the secularization of society. Social, especially educational change, alters not only beliefs about treatment, but also the power structure involved in deciding the timing and type of treatment given. The type of treatment is also partly determined by its cost. Components of mortality decline, such as nutrition, which do not depend on the treatment of disease, were also explored. The paper concludes that social change has almost certainly played a major role in the reduction of mortality in many societies.

This research constitutes part of a joint project of the Population Centre, Bangalore, India, and the Department of Demography, Australian National University. Most of the funding has come from the two institutions, but other support, especially for the analysis, has been provided by the Ford Foundation and by a Population Council International Research Award. The project has benefited from the research assistance of Pat Quiggin in Canberra, and also in Karnataka and/or Canberra from Wendy Cosford, Jennie Widdowson, A. Shariff, M. Guruswamy, K. N. M. Raju, P. N. Sushama, Sheila Mouli, S. K. Potnis, P. S. Reddy, S. Begum and P. Ananda Shetty.

This research constitutes part of a joint project of the Population Centre, Bangalore, India, and the Department of Demography, Australian National University. Most of the funding has come from the two institutions, but other support, especially for the analysis, has been provided by the Ford Foundation and by a Population Council International Research Award. The project has benefited from the research assistance of Pat Quiggin in Canberra, and also in Karnataka and/or Canberra from Wendy Cosford, Jennie Widdowson, A. Shariff, M. Guruswamy, K. N. M. Raju, P. N. Sushama, Sheila Mouli, S. K. Potnis, P. S. Reddy, S. Begum and P. Ananda Shetty.

Notes

This research constitutes part of a joint project of the Population Centre, Bangalore, India, and the Department of Demography, Australian National University. Most of the funding has come from the two institutions, but other support, especially for the analysis, has been provided by the Ford Foundation and by a Population Council International Research Award. The project has benefited from the research assistance of Pat Quiggin in Canberra, and also in Karnataka and/or Canberra from Wendy Cosford, Jennie Widdowson, A. Shariff, M. Guruswamy, K. N. M. Raju, P. N. Sushama, Sheila Mouli, S. K. Potnis, P. S. Reddy, S. Begum and P. Ananda Shetty.

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Pat Caldwell

The authors are the principal investigators of the joint project.