On intercomponent rank tests for the bivariate two-sample location model

Abstract

The intercomponent rank test suggested by Thompson (1991a) for the bivariate two sample problem is compared with the intracomponent rank test discussed by Puri and Sen (1971) and Hettmansperger (1984) and with the Hotelling T ² test. Asymptotic relative efficiencies are discussed and the results of a simulation study are presented. Power studies show that for small sample sizes and small Type 1 error rates, say n = 5 and α = .01, the intercomponent rank test of Thompson (1991a) is somewhat liberal and the intracomponent test is quite conservative. For larger sample sizes and larger Type 1 error rates, both rank tests have improved properties under the null hypothesis. In almost all simulated cases, the intercomponent test is more powerful. In light of these studies it is suggested that the intercomponent rank test of Thompson (1991a), which has the added advantage of being easily computed with standard statistical software, is a strong competitor to the intracomponent rank test.