Syrian diaspora mobilization: vertical coordination, patronage relations, and the challenges of fragmentation in the pursuit of transitional justice

ABSTRACT

The 2011 Syrian uprising saw the rise of several Syrian diaspora organizations seeking transitional justice (TJ). In this article, we ask why these organizations have been unable to present a coherent and unified TJ agenda. We show how a sequence of mechanisms (transnational brokerage, vertical coordination, and patronage relations) have led to fragmentation in the pursuit of justice. The analysis is divided into two sections. First, we discuss the onset of patronage relations made possible by brokered alliances and vertical coordination. Fuelled by differing conceptions of justice and confidence that the regime would quickly fall, organizations proliferated and fragmented. Second, we show how the entrenchment of patronage relations has largely precluded horizontal coordination, even as groups shifted strategy in the wake of changing conditions in Syria. We then argue that collaborative efforts among diaspora groups have largely failed to overcome the rigid patronage relations established early in the mobilization phase.

KEYWORDS:

• Syria
• transitional justice
• diaspora
• brokerage
• patronage
• vertical coordination

Acknowledgements

The authors are grateful for the constructive feedback provided on previous drafts by the editorial staff of Ethnic & Racial Studies, special issue editors Maria Koinova and Dženeta Karabegović, and three anonymous reviewers.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.