Shifting legibility: racial ambiguity in the US racial hierarchy

ABSTRACT

Existing frameworks of assimilation and group boundaries are limited in making sense of experiences of racial ambiguity. What happens when racial groups are mistaken for other groups, and how does this phenomenon relate to the racial hierarchy? This paper investigates the on-the-ground mechanisms of racial ambiguity that formal institutions, like the Census, do not capture, yet are the lived realities for many immigrant groups. Through analysis of 120 interviews and supplemental observations, I find that the racialization of second-generation South Asians shifts between racial ambiguity and racial legibility in daily life. I present a theoretical concept – localized racialization – to reveal the transient, yet defining, racial experiences of groups residing in the racial middle. Localized racialization centres multiple factors of skin colour, intersectional status markers, and situational contexts that tether racial experiences to the local. This study’s South Asian participants reveal persistent racial dynamism at the micro-interactional level.

KEYWORDS:

• Discrimination
• immigrants
• racial ambiguity
• skin colour
• South Asians
• racial identity

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Notes

1 This article derives substantially from Radha Modi’s doctoral dissertation (see Modi 2016). The dissertation chapter this article draws from is not published elsewhere.

2 IRB University of Pennsylvania Approval #: 818557.