Computer-based animations and static graphics as medical student aids in learning home safety assessment: a randomized controlled trial

Abstract

Background: Although animations may intuitively seem more effective than static graphics for teaching, there is no clear-cut evidence for the superiority of simple computer-based animations in medical education.

Aims: We investigated whether simple animations are better than static graphics as an aid to medical students in learning home safety assessment, an important part of geriatric curriculum.

Methods: We used two versions of an interactive online module, one that depicted common home safety issues in static graphics and the other in animations. We randomized first-year medical students who agreed to participate into two groups. After the module, students completed a cognitive burden scale and a standardized competency assessment test in which they had to identify the salient home safety issues and give recommendations based on the hazards. We also captured time spent on task.

Results and conclusions: We found no significant differences between the groups in the cognitive burden level, competency assessment scores, and time spent on task. The much cheaper-to-produce static graphics were equally effective as simple animations in this medical education scenario.

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Renuka Tunuguntla

RENUKA TUNUGUNTLA, MD, is an advanced geriatric medicine fellow at the Miami VAHCS GRECC.

Osvaldo Rodriguez

OSVALDO RODRIGUEZ, MD, is assistant professor of medicine and co-director of the VAHCS Home-Based Primary Care program.

Jorge G. Ruiz

JORGE G. RUIZ, MD, is associate professor of medicine, director of the geriatric medicine fellowship program, and GRECC education director.

Syeda S. Qadri

SYEDA S. QADRI, PhD, is an educational researcher at the Stein Gerontological Institute.

Michael J. Mintzer

MICHAEL J. MINTZER, MD, is professor of medicine and director of the UMMSM Longitudinal Curriculum in Geriatrics, Pain Management, and Palliative Care.

Maria H. Van Zuilen

MARIA H. VAN ZUILEN, PhD, is assistant professor of medicine and co-director of the UMMSM Longitudinal Curriculum in Geriatrics, Pain Management, and Palliative Care.

Bernard A. Roos

BERNARD A. ROOS, MD, is professor of medicine, neurology, and exercise and sport sciences and director of the Geriatrics Institute and GRECC.