More heat than light: plagiarism in its appearing

Abstract

This paper argues that the recent debate about plagiarism has taken on aspects of a moral panic, which reflects underlying anxieties about the state of higher education in the United Kingdom. In contrast to the moral absolutism of some commentators, we argue for the significance of posing the phenomenological question of ‘what is plagiarism in its appearing?’ We present a detailed idiographic analysis of two cases taken from a wider study of staff perceptions of plagiarism looking at the multiple meanings of plagiarism in the life‐world of individual staff. Our approach does not entail judgemental relativism; rather, it involves a proper recognition of the limitations of rule‐bound approaches to complex ethical matters. We argue for a virtues‐based approach to plagiarism, which recognises complexity, and for a more measured and collegial debate.

Acknowledgement

The authors would like to thank Professor Peter Ashworth for his comments and advice.

Notes

1. For example, Glatt Plagiarism Services Inc. (http://www.plagiarism.com).

2. For example, the JISC Plagiarism Advisory Service (http://online.northumbria.ac.uk/faculties/art/information_studies/Imri/Jiscpas/site/detect.asp).

3. The archives of the plagiarism discussion list can be found online (http://www.jiscmail.ac.uk/lists/PLAGIARISM.html).