Local calibration of remotely sensed rainfall from the TRMM satellite for different periods and spatial scales in the Indus Basin

Abstract

The availability of accurate rainfall data at proper temporal and spatial scales is vital for knowledge of renewable water resources and safe withdrawals for irrigation. Rain gauge networks in mountainous basins such as the Indus are sparse and insufficient to plan withdrawals and water management applications. Satellite rainfall estimates can be used as an alternative source of information but need area-specific calibration and validation due to the indirect nature of the radiation measurements. In this study, a calibration protocol is worked out for rainfall data from the Tropical Rainfall Measuring Mission (TRMM) satellite because uncalibrated TRMM rainfall data are inaccurate for use in rainfall–runoff studies and in soil water balance studies. Two alternative techniques, regression analysis (RA) and geographical differential analysis (GDA), were used to calibrate TRMM rainfall data for different periods and spatial distributions. The validity of these techniques was tested using Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency and the standard error of estimate. The GDA technique proved to be better, with higher efficiency and smaller error in complex mountainous terrains. The deviation between TRMM data and rain gauge data was decreased considerably from 10.9% (pre-calibration at 625 km²) to 6.1% (post-calibration at 3125 km²) for annual time periods. For monthly periods, the deviation of 34.9% (pre-calibration at 625 km²) was decreased to 15.4% (post-calibration at 3125 km²). Calibration can be improved further if more rain gauges are available. The GDA technique can be applied to calibrate TRMM rainfall data in regions with limited rain gauge data and can provide a sufficiently accurate estimate of the key hydrological process that can be used in water management applications.

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by the fellowship programme of the Higher Education Commission, Pakistan. The authors would like to acknowledge the Pakistan Meteorological Department for providing rainfall data. The authors also thank the anonymous reviewers for their constructive comments that helped to improve the quality of the manuscript.