Invisible. Inaudible. Marginalised: unique languages in a superdiverse translanguaging-classroom

ABSTRACT

In the present study (Schwarzl, Lena. 2020. “Ein mehrperspektivischer Blick in das Translanguaging-Klassenzimmer – selbstbezogene Überzeugungen und Klassenklima im Fokus” [A Multi-Perspective Look into the Translanguaging Classroom - Focusing on Self-Centered Beliefs and Classroom Climate]. Doctoral diss., University of Vienna. https://utheses.univie.ac.at/detail/56757#), translanguaging was implemented in a primary (4th grade) and in a lower secondary school class (5th grade) in Vienna and evaluated using a mixed-methods design. Data was collected in two questionnaire surveys with the pupils, consisting mainly of variables measuring self-related beliefs on pupils’ home languages. Lessons were regularly observed using an ethnographic approach (altogether 130 h). Insights into two teachers’ perspectives were gained by using semi-structured interviews. The questionnaire was analyzed with SPSS (mostly descriptive analyses), the ethnographic fieldnotes were coded into categories and transformed into a detailed description, and text analysis was used for the interviews. The results highlight that the superdiverse linguistic repertoires of pupils strongly challenged the implementation of translanguaging pedagogy because pupils who knew languages shared by many of their peers most benefitted socio-emotionally from the implementation of translanguaging. Pupils who did not know those languages, however, barely got the chance to use their home languages in class and some of them reacted with strong frustration. In sum, these results show how translanguaging pedagogy can serve as a resource and as a barrier, depending on whether linguistic competences are shared in class and valued by teachers.

KEYWORDS:

• Translanguaging
• superdiversity
• marginalised languages
• self-related beliefs
• mixed methods

Acknowledgements

I want to deeply thank the collaborating teachers and pupils for participating in this study.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Notes

1 For English and Music it was the same teacher.

2 For further insights into the results please consider Schwarzl (2020).

3 Pseudonyms are used for all names in the article.