The challenge of the creative Third World

Abstract

This article is a contribution to recent literature on the shape of the polycentric world order. It argues that the Third World remains a valid concept for describing the interests and ideas that shape the foreign policies of many key non-Western states. However, the Third World has changed in a fundamental way. The article describes the historical emergence and contemporary manifestations of a ‘creative’ Third World in contrast to the ‘protest’ Third World of the past. It describes the nature of this shift and how it is reshaping Western leadership. It argues that the main challenge for the West is to create a coherent pluralism in international order that embraces this creative Third World.

Keywords:

• Third World
• global South
• South–South cooperation
• G20
• global governance

Notes

1. Naipaul, The Middle Passage, 254.

2. Killick, Development Economics in Action.

3. Tignor, Robert L. W. Arthur Lewis, 170, 172.

4. Lewis, Politics in West Africa, 34.

5. Sauvy, “Trois mondes, une planète”; and Solarz, ‘“Third World’.”

6. Zoellick, “The End of the Third World?”

7. United Nations, The State of South–South Cooperation, 2014.

8. United Nations, The State of South–South Cooperation, 2012.

9. Sidhu, “Resolutions.”

10. Hurrell, “Narratives of Emergence.”

11. Berger, “After the Third World?”

12. Ferdinand, “Rising Powers at the UN.”

13. Weiss and Abdenur, “Emerging Powers.”

14. Weiss and Abdenur, “Introduction,” 1751.

15. Helleiner, “Introduction.”

16. Meredith, The Fate of Africa, 92.

17. Organization of African Unity, Lagos Plan of Action.

18. McKercher, “The Center cannot Hold.”

19. Meredith, The Fate of Africa, 164, 272.

20. Naipaul, The Middle Passage, 254.

21. Fieldhouse, The West and the Third World; and Riley, “The Timing and Pace of Health Transitions.”

22. Manderson, “Public Health Developments in Colonial Malaya.”

23. Hubler, South–North Convergence.

24. Myint, “The ‘Classical Theory’ of International Trade,” 336.

25. Alden et al., The South in World Politics, 77.

26. White, “Zambia in the 1990s.”

27. Puchala, “Third World Thinking.”

28. Rajaratnam, “Speech by Mr. S. Rajaratnam.”

29. Kimura, The Nellie Massacre of 1983.

30. Prashad, The Poorer Nations, 209.

31. Republic of Indonesia, Final Documents, chap. 2, Sec. E61.

32. Isegawa, Snakepit.

33. “Author changes his Mind.”

34. De Soto et al., El Otro Sendero.

35. De Soto, The Other Path.

36. Cardoso, Charting a New Course.

37. Gilley, The Right to Rule, 118.

38. Berman, Terror and Liberalism.

39. Mishra, Exit Wounds.

40. Harris, The End of the Third World; and Arnold, The End of the Third World.

41. Dubash and Morgan, The Rise of the Regulatory State.

42. Reddy, Global Innovation.

43. Smith et al., “The Oligarchic Diffusion of Public Policy.”

44. Van der Boor and Braguinsky, Innovation and Diffusion.

45. McDonald and Ruiters, Alternatives to Privatization.

46. Morphet, “Multilateralism and the Non-Aligned Movement,” 528.

47. Richmond and Tellidis, “Emerging Actors in International Peacebuilding”; and Braveboy-Wagner, The Foreign Policies of the Global South.

48. Allan and Dauvergne, “The Global South in Environmental Negotiations.”

49. Binder and Meier, “Opportunity Knocks.”

50. Akpınar, “Turkey’s Peacebuilding in Somalia”; and Russo et al., “Brazil–Africa Technical Cooperation in Health.”

51. Esteves and Assunção, “South–South Cooperation.”

52. Cammack, “The G20,” 7.

53. Toye, “Assessing the G77.”

54. Golub, “From the New International Economic Order,” 1002.

55. Kupchan, No one’s World, 8.

56. Fraundorfer, Brazil’s Emerging Role in Global Governance.

57. Ashoff, “Triangular Cooperation.”

58. Abdenur and Fonseca, “The North’s Growing Role,” 1486.

59. Mahadevan, “India–US Relations”; and Vickery, The Eagle and the Elephant.