The Infringement of the Right to Establish a Family for Jewish Spouses Who Are Mutually Proscribed from Marrying Each Other

Abstract

The article focuses on one of the most painful experiences in intimate relationships and unveils a hitherto unexplored type of human right infringement, namely the right to establish a family in Israel, purported to be a democratic state. Thousands of couples are proscribed from marrying each other every year in Israel. This paper focuses on Jewish couples consisting of male Cohanim (descendants of Jewish priests) and female divorcées, as one among other types of forbidden marriages. Four themes emerged from data analysis of narratives of 26 interviewees, which converged to a common motif of liminality of Cohen-divorcée couples. Based on empirical data, I describe the predicament attendant to this human rights violation which is transmitted to offspring of these couples. The article argues that this liminality undermines the basic rationale of the prevailing millet (personal law) system and discusses the implications of this liminality for human rights and religion-state relations.

Keywords:

• civil rights
• family law
• human rights
• inequality
• Jewish families
• mixed families
• religion

Acknowledgments

The author expresses her sincere gratitude to the editor of Marriage and Family Review and the anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments and suggestions as to how to improve the article; I am also grateful to Prof. Sylvie Fogiel-Bijaoui for her helpful comments and suggestions.