Abstract
The “community of practice” (CoP) has emerged as a potentially powerful unit of analysis linking the individual and the collective because it situates the role of learning, knowledge transfer, and participation among people as the central enterprise of collective action. The authors?uo; surface tensions and highlight unanswered questions regarding CoP theory, concluding that it relies on a largely normative and under-operationalized set of premises. Avenues for theory development and the empirical testing of assertions are provided.
Notes
1. Our review of the literature regarding the utilization and interpretation of CoPs involved a survey of major social science databases, including Social Science Abstracts, ERIC, Expanded Academic, Applied Science and Technology Index, Anthropology Plus, PubMed, Social Work Abstracts, Sociological Abstracts, World Wide Political Science Abstracts and Google Scholar. In total, over 230 references were reviewed. Although we took measures to ensure that this review is comprehensive, the reader should note that as with all reviews of the literature, missing references are likely.
2. SeeCitationLave & Wenger, 1991; CitationWenger, 1998; CitationHenning, 1998; CitationTrowler & Knight, 2000; CitationPereles et al., 2002; CitationAu, 2002; CitationBarab et al., 2000; CitationLathlean & le May, 2002; CitationSomekh & Pearson, 2002; CitationSwan et al., 2002; CitationGabbay et al., 2003; CitationHuang et al., 2003; CitationArdichvili et al., 2003; CitationBoud & Middleton, 2003; CitationFaber et al., 2003; CitationGallucci, 2003; CitationHodkinson & Hodkinson, 2004a; CitationStarkey et al., 2004; CitationSchnekel, 2004; CitationYoungblood, 2004; CitationZanetich, 2003; CitationBouwen & Taillieu, 2004; CitationCorso, 2004; CitationDube et al., 2005; CitationFontaine & Millen, 2004; CitationFuller et al., 2005; CitationRohde, 2004; CitationAnthony, 2007.
Lave
,
J.
and
Wenger
,
E.
1991
.
Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation
,
New York
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Wenger
,
E.
1998
.
Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity
,
Cambridge,
, UK
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Henning
,
P. H.
1998
.
Ways of learning: An ethnographic study of the work and situated learning of a group of refrigeration service technicians
.
Journal of Contemporary Ethnography
,
27
(
1
)
:
85
–
138
.
Trowler
,
P.
and
Knight
,
P. T.
2000
.
Coming to know in higher education: Theorising faculty entry to new work contexts
.
Higher Education Research & Development
,
19
(
1
)
:
27
–
42
.
Pereles
,
L.
,
Lockyer
,
J.
and
Fidler
,
H.
2002
.
Permanent small groups: Group dynamics, learning, and change
.
Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions
,
22
(
4
)
:
205
–
213
.
Au
,
K. H.
2002
.
Communities of practice: Engagement, imagination, and alignment in research on teacher education
.
Journal of Teacher Education
,
53
(
3
)
:
222
–
227
.
Branch
,
J.
2008
.
Cultivating extension communities of practice. Ph.D. dissertation
,
University of Vermont
.
Lathlean
,
J.
and
le May
,
A.
2002
.
Communities of practice: an opportunity for interagency working
.
Journal of Clinical Nursing
,
11
(
3
)
:
394
–
398
.
Somekh
,
B.
and
Pearson
,
M.
2002
.
Intercultural learning arising from Pan-European collaboration: A community of practice with a ‘hole in the middle?uo;
.
British Educational Research Journal
,
28
(
4
)
:
485
–
502
.
Swan
,
J.
,
Scarbrough
,
H.
and
Robertson
,
M.
2002
.
The construction of “communities of practice?uo; in the management of innovation
.
Management Learning
,
33
(
4
)
:
477
–
496
.
Gabbay
,
J.
,
Le May
,
A.
,
Jefferson
,
H.
,
Webb
,
D.
,
Lovelock
,
R.
,
Powell
,
J.
and
Lathlean
,
J.
2003
.
A case study of knowledge management in multi-agency consumer-informed ‘communities of practice?uo;: Implications for evidence-based policy development in health and social services
.
Health
,
7
(
3
)
:
283
–
310
.
Huang
,
J.
,
Newell
,
S.
and
Galliers
,
R. D.
.
Inter-organizational communities of practice
.
Paper presented at the Third European Conference on Organizational Knowledge, Learning and Capabilities
.
Athens, Greece.
Ardichvili
,
A.
,
Page
,
V.
and
Wentling
,
T.
2003
.
Motivation and barriers to participation in virtual knowledge-sharing communities of practice
.
Journal of Knowledge Management
,
7
(
1
)
:
64
–
77
.
Boud
,
D.
and
Middleton
,
H.
2003
.
Learning from others at work: Communities of practice and informal learning
.
Journal of Workplace Learning
,
15
(
5
)
:
194
–
202
.
Faber
,
S.
,
de Castell
,
S.
and
Bryson
,
M.
2003
.
Renal failure: Toward a sociocultural investigation of an illness
.
Culture & Activity
,
10
(
2
)
:
143
–
167
.
Gallucci
,
C.
2003
.
Communities of practice and the mediation of teachers?uo; responses to standards-based reform
.
Education Policy Analysis Archives
,
11
(
35
)
:
1
–
19
.
Hodkinson
,
H.
and
Hodkinson
,
P.
2004a
.
Rethinking the concept of community of practice in relation to schoolteachers?uo; workplace learning
.
International Journal of Training & Development
,
8
(
1
)
:
21
–
31
.
Starkey
,
K.
,
Barnett
,
C.
and
Tempest
,
S.
2004
.
“
Beyond networks and hierarchies: Latent organizations in the UK television industry
”
. In
How organizations learn: Managing the search for knowledge
,
Second
,
Edited by:
Starkey
,
K.
,
Tempest
,
S.
and
McKinlay
,
A.
259
–
270
.
London
:
Thomson
.
Starkey
,
K.
,
Barnett
,
C.
and
Tempest
,
S.
2004
.
“
Beyond networks and hierarchies: Latent organizations in the UK television industry
”
. In
How organizations learn: Managing the search for knowledge
,
Second
,
Edited by:
Starkey
,
K.
,
Tempest
,
S.
and
McKinlay
,
A.
259
–
270
.
London
:
Thomson
.
Youngblood
,
J. W.
2004
.
Learning for political party partisanship and participation
.
Dissertation Abstracts International, A: The Humanities and Social Sciences
,
65
(
6
)
:
2350
Zanetich
,
J. T.
2003
.
Knowledge management in the public sector: A case study of the intergovernmental response to the West Nile virus epidemic in New York State
.
Dissertation Abstracts International, A: The Humanities and Social Sciences
,
64
(
3
)
:
1072
Bouwen
,
R.
and
Taillieu
,
T.
2004
.
Multi-party collaboration as social learning for interdependence: Developing relational knowing for sustainable natural resource management
.
Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology
,
14
(
3
)
:
137
–
153
.
Corso
,
D. T.
2004
.
‘Smooth as butter?uo;: Practices of music learning amongst African-American children
.
Dissertation Abstracts International Section A: Humanities & Social Sciences
,
64
(
12A
)
:
4354
Dube
,
L.
,
Bourhis
,
A.
and
Jacob
,
R.
2005
.
The impact of structuring characteristics on the launching of virtual communities of practice
.
Journal of Organizational Change Management
,
18
(
2
)
:
145
–
167
.
Fontaine
,
M. A.
and
Millen
,
D. R.
2004
.
“
Understanding the benefits and impact of communities of practice
”
. In
Knowledge networks: Innovation through communities of practice
,
Edited by:
Hildreth
,
P.
and
Kimble
,
C.
1
–
13
.
York,
, UK
:
Idea Group Publishing
.
Fuller
,
A.
,
Hodkinson
,
H.
,
Hodkinson
,
P.
and
Unwin
,
L.
2005
.
Learning as peripheral participation in communities of practice: a reassessment of key concepts in workplace learning
.
British Educational Research Journal
,
31
(
1
)
:
49
–
68
.
Rohde
,
M.
2004
.
“
Find what binds: Building social capital in an Iranian NGO community system
”
. In
Social capital and information technology
,
Edited by:
Huysman
,
M.
and
Wulf
,
V.
75
–
111
.
Cambridge, MA
:
MIT Press
.
Anthony
,
T.S.
2007
.
A community just for practice: A case study of an inclusive/special education
.
Canadian Journal of Education
,
30
(
1
)
:
171
–
192
.