Conceptualizing Direct Action as a Form of Participation in Development: A South African Case

Abstract

The scholarly focus on participation in development is highly biased towards analyses of ‘invited’ (Cornwall, 2004) participatory spaces, those that have been induced by governments or international agencies. However, there is a growing body of literature that investigates ‘invented’ participatory spaces—more autonomous spaces which have been created at the grassroots level. The available scholarship on ‘invented’ participatory spaces, however, has not sufficiently raised the application of direct action (violent or non-violent) as a means by which marginalized actors can claim power, thereby exercising citizenship from below. Direct action, it will be argued, presents distinct possibilities for creating the conditions in which a transformative approach to development can be achieved. This article draws primarily from interviews with and observations of the Alexandra Vukuzenzele Crisis Committee (AVCC) in the context of the flagship African National Congress (ANC) R1.3 billion Alexandra Renewal Project (ARP). In so doing, it highlights the limitations and possibilities posed by the AVCC's occupation of houses as a form of direct action that can transform the development process.

Notes

Interview with Dale McKinley, APF leader, Johannesburg: 13 May 2008.

Interview with Abner Matshayana, AVCC member, Alexandra: 31 October 2007.

Interview with Fredah Dlamini, Chairperson of AVCC, East Bank: 4 September 2007.

Interview with Fredah Dlamini, Chairperson of AVCC, East Bank: 4 September 2007.

Interview with Fredah Dlamini, Chairperson of AVCC, East Bank: 4 September 2007.

Interview with Fredah Dlamini, Chairperson of AVCC, East Bank: 4 September 2007.

Interview with Fredah Dlamini, Chairperson of AVCC, East Bank: 4 September 2007.

Interview with Fredah Dlamini, Chairperson of AVCC, Alexandra: 31 October 2007.

Interview with Julian Baskin, Director of the ARP, Wynberg: 9 October 2007.

Interview with Fredah Dlamini, Chairperson of AVCC, East Bank: 4 September 2007.

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Luke Sinwell

Luke Sinwell's research interests include the politics and conceptualization of participatory development and governance, social movements and housing struggles, non-violent direct action as a method to transform power relations, ethnographic research methods and action research. He is currently a postdoctoral fellow at the University of Johannesburg. He is grateful to Noor Nieftagodien (previously his Ph.D. advisor at Witwatersrand University) and for the support provided by the programme called ‘The Voices of the Poor in Urban Governance: Participation, Mobilization and Politics in South African Cities’.