One output function: a misconception of students studying digital systems – a case study

Abstract

Background:

Learning processes are usually characterized by students’ misunderstandings and misconceptions. Engineering educators intend to help their students overcome their misconceptions and achieve correct understanding of the concept. This paper describes a misconception in digital systems held by many students who believe that combinational logic circuits should have only one output.

Purpose:

The current study aims to investigate the roots of the misconception about one-output function and the pedagogical methods that can help students overcome the misconception.

Sample:

Three hundred and eighty-one students in the Departments of Electrical and Electronics and Mechanical Engineering at an academic engineering college, who learned the same topics of a digital combinational system, participated in the research.

Design and method:

In the initial research stage, students were taught according to traditional method – first to design a one-output combinational logic system, and then to implement a system with a number of output functions. In the main stage, an experimental group was taught using a new method whereby they were shown how to implement a system with several output functions, prior to learning about one-output systems. A control group was taught using the traditional method. In the replication stage (the third stage), an experimental group was taught using the new method. A mixed research methodology was used to examine the results of the new learning method.

Results:

Quantitative research showed that the new teaching approach resulted in a statistically significant decrease in student errors, and qualitative research revealed students’ erroneous thinking patterns.

Conclusions:

It can be assumed that the traditional teaching method generates an incorrect mental model of the one-output function among students. The new pedagogical approach prevented the creation of an erroneous mental model and helped students develop the correct conceptual understanding.

Keywords:

• conceptual change
• digital electronics
• electrical engineering education
• misconception