Picture description in neurologically normal adults: Concepts and topic coherence

Abstract

Background: Evaluation of discourse is recognised as an important component in the diagnosis and management of adult acquired communication disorders. Picture description is a common and practical data elicitation procedure that has provided insights into the discourse of many adult groups. Such data may be analysed from several linguistic and pragmatic perspectives and, as is commonly the case with discourse measures, the usefulness of such data is limited by a paucity of relevant normative information.

Aim: To determine the influences of age, education, and gender on the concepts and topic coherence of the picture description of non‐brain‐damaged adults.

Methods & Procedures: A total of 225 adults described the “cookie theft” picture (Goodglass, Kaplan, & Barresi, 2001). Responses were analysed for presence and completeness of concepts (Nicholas & Brookshire, 1995) and topic coherence (Mentis & Prutting, 1991), modified (Brady, Mackenzie, & Armstrong 2003).

Outcomes & Results: Both analyses, concept and topic coherence, confirmed education level as a highly important variable affecting the performance of non‐brain‐damaged adults. The number of concepts used accurately and completely, and the amount of topic subdivision, increased with amount of education (both with and without adjustment for age and gender). Clear influences of age or gender were not demonstrated, although some trends in favour of women and younger age were noted, and for one of the seven assessed concepts there was a steady reduction in the odds of being accurate and complete with every 5‐year age increase.

Conclusions: Recognition of the impact of education is essential in the assessment and diagnosis of communication difficulty.

The authors are grateful to all who participated in this study.

Notes

The authors are grateful to all who participated in this study.