When emotion does and does not impair performance: A Garner theory of the emotional Stroop effect

Abstract

It takes people longer to name the ink colour of emotion or threat words than that of neutral words, the emotional Stroop effect (ESE). In three experiments with normal and patient populations, we show that the ESE is a special case of a generic attention model and effect entailed in Garner's speeded classification paradigm. Guided by the Garner model we demonstrate that task-irrelevant dimensions that differ in salience can produce the ESE and mimic it with neutral stimuli. When each word appears in a constant colour, as mandated in the correlation condition of the Garner design, the ESE is eliminated. This important result is consistent with the attention account of the ESE. We conclude that when emotion stimuli appear in a random fashion they interfere with task performance. However, when emotion stimuli are correlated with features of the ongoing task they help task performance not least due to their extreme salience.

Keywords:

• The emotional Stroop effect
• The Garner paradigm
• Attention
• Dimensional salience
• Performance under emotion

Acknowledgments

We thank Jan De Houwer, James R. Schmidt, and an anonymous reviewer for insightful and extremely valuable comments, which helped to improve this report.