Enhanced recall of disgusting relative to frightening photographs is not due to organisation

ABSTRACT

Previous research has shown that disgusting photographs are better remembered than frightening photographs, even when the two image types have equivalent valence and arousal. However, this work did not control for potential differences in organisation between the disgusting and frightening stimuli that could account for enhanced memory for disgusting photographs. The current research therefore tested whether differences in recall between disgusting and frightening photographs persist when differences in organisation are eliminated. Using a set of disgusting and frightening photographs matched for interrelatedness, Study 1 found that participants recalled more disgusting photographs than frightening photographs. This effect was mediated by increased attention to the disgusting photographs. Study 2 used Latent Semantic Analysis to further interrogate the relatedness of the photographs, providing converging evidence that organisation does not account for enhanced recall of disgusting photographs. Taken together, these results suggest that dimensional models of emotion cannot fully account for emotion’s effects on episodic memory. Instead, disgust appears to enhance recall via a distinctive, attention-mediated mechanism.

KEYWORDS:

• Emotion
• memory
• disgust
• fear
• relatedness
• organisation

Acknowledgements

I would like to thank Carlos Barretto, Daniel Scannell, Najuma Abdullah and Michael Ianello for assistance with data collection and coding of recall responses.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.