ABSTRACT
This paper examines 126 research articles from three comparative education journals to chart the development of knowledge within comparative education on the Soviet Union and post-Soviet countries. Thematic, theoretical, discursive, and methodological aspects of scholarship are linked with changing geopolitical realities in a systematic analysis of scholarship published since the late 1950s. A new framework of multi-layered colonialism is introduced to explore different features of the double disadvantage that comparative education knowledge production on post-Soviet countries has faced – Russian imperialism and Western academic colonialism. The paper contributes to comparative education knowledge creation by historicising our understanding of Western academic output and outlining a potential future direction in the development of knowledge on post-Soviet systems, policies, and practices of education.
Disclosure statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author.
Note on contributor
Maia Chankseliani is an Associate Professor of Comparative and International Education at the Department of Education at the University of Oxford, UK. Her research interests focus on education and training policies and practices, and how these influence individual opportunities.
Notes
1 CER – 59 years (1957–2015)/59 articles; CE – 52 years (1964–2015)/40 articles; Compare – 41 years (1975–2015)/27 articles.
2 Only two studies looked at borrowing in the post-Soviet context – Lisovskaya and Karpov (Citation1999) and Elliott and Tudge (Citation2007).
4 Not everyone, however, shares the view that comparative study of Soviet education did not have any impact on the development of the field. For example, Steiner-Khamsi (Citation2006b) argues that the Cold War influenced several characteristics of American and German comparative and international education; she mentions the dominance of area studies and international development in American CIE and the absence of development studies in German comparative education (Steiner-Khamsi Citation2006b, 22–23).
5 I grouped authors into three categories: USA, Western Europe/Canada/Israel/Australia, Eastern Europe, and post-Soviet countries. Those who originally come from Eastern Europe but worked in the first category countries were coded as Eastern European. For example, George Bereday and Joseph Zajda were coded as Eastern European because of their Polish origin. All those who come from post-Soviet countries and work in the first category countries were coded as post-Soviet. For example, Nicholas Hans was coded as post-Soviet because of his Russian origin and Iveta Silova was coded as post-Soviet because of her Latvian origin.
6 The proportions differed by journal. Compare had the highest concentration (74% of all articles analysed) of authors from institutions located in the USA, Western Europe, Canada, Israel, Australia or HK, who did not have biographical links with the region. CER, on the other hand, had the highest concentration (20% of all articles analysed) of authors from post-Soviet countries per se.
8 In fact, Grozny University was located in Grozny, the capital of Chechen-Ingush Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic.
11 According to the coding system I have used, these are the authors from the USA, Western Europe, Canada, Israel or Australia.
Lisovskaya, Elena, and Vyacheslav Karpov. 1999. “New Ideologies in Postcommunist Russian Textbooks.” Comparative Education Review 43 (4): 522–543. doi: 10.1086/447582 Elliott, Julian, and Jonathan Tudge. 2007. “The Impact of the West on Post-Soviet Russian Education: Change and Resistance to Change.” Comparative Education 43 (1): 93–112. doi:10.1080/03050060601162420. Carey, Henry F., and Rafal Raciborski. 2004. “Postcolonialism: A Valid Paradigm for the Former Sovietized States and Yugoslavia?” East European Politics and Societies 18 (2): 191–235. doi:10.1177/0888325403259918. Ferro, Marc. 1997. Colonization: A Global History. London: Taylor & Francis. Kappeler, Andreas. 2001. The Russian Empire: A Multiethnic History. Harlow: Pearson Education. Khalid, Adeeb. 2007. “Introduction: Locating the (Post-) Colonial in Soviet History.” Central Asian Survey 26 (4): 465–473. doi:10.1080/02634930802017895. Lazarus, Neil. 2012. “Spectres Haunting: Postcommunism and Postcolonialism.” Journal of Postcolonial Writing 48 (2): 117–129. doi:10.1080/17449855.2012.658243. Moore, David. 2006. “Is the Post- in Postcolonial the Post- in Post-Soviet? Toward a Global Postcolonial Critique.” In Baltic Postcolonialism, edited by Violeta Kelertas, 111–128. New York: Rodopi. Steiner-Khamsi, Gita. 2006b. “The Development Turn in Comparative Education.” European Education 38 (3): 19–47. doi:10.2753/EUE1056-4934380302. Steiner-Khamsi, Gita. 2006b. “The Development Turn in Comparative Education.” European Education 38 (3): 19–47. doi:10.2753/EUE1056-4934380302. Bigelow, Karl W. 1961. “Some Comparative Reflections on Soviet and Chinese Higher Education.” Comparative Education Review 4 (3): 169–173. doi: 10.1086/444852 Dobson, Richard, and Michael Swafford. 1980. “The Educational Attainment Process in the Soviet Union: A Case Study.” Comparative Education Review 24 (2): 252–269. doi: 10.1086/446119 Yanowitch, Murray, and Norton Dodge. 1968. “Social Class and Education: Soviet Findings and Reactions.” Comparative Education Review 12 (3): 248–267. doi: 10.1086/445363 Glanzer, Perry L. 2009. “Religion, Education, and the State in Post-Communist Europe: Making Sense of the Diversity of New Church-State Practices.” Comparative Education Review 53 (1): 89–111. doi: 10.1086/593170 Grant, Nigel. 1975. “Developments in Higher Education in the Socialist Countries of Europe.” Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 5 (1): 25–33. doi:10.1080/03057927509408814. Hogan-Brun, Gabrielle. 2007. “Language-in-education across the Baltic: Policies, Practices and Challenges.” Comparative Education 43 (4): 553–570. doi:10.1080/03050060701611946. Jahn, Harvey R. 1975. “USA/USSR: Two Worlds Apart?” Comparative Education Review 19 (3): 451–467. doi: 10.1086/445852 McLean, Martin. 1992. The Promise and Perils of Educational Comparison. London: Tufnell. Ben-Ari, E., and J. van Bremen. 2005. “Asian Anthropologies and Anthropologies in Asia.” In Asian Anthropology, edited by Jan van Bremen, Eyal Ben-Ari, and Farid Alatas, 3–39. Anthropology of Asia Series (Richmond upon Thames, London, England). London: Routledge. Connell, Raewyn. 2007. Southern Theory: The Global Dynamics of Knowledge in Social Science. Cambridge: Polity. Kuwayama, Takami. 2004. Native Anthropology: The Japanese Challenge to Western Academic Hegemony. Japanese Society Series. Melbourne, VC: Trans Pacific. Takayama, Keita. 2011. “A Comparativist’s Predicaments of Writing about ‘other’ Education: A Self-Reflective, Critical Review of Studies of Japanese Education.” Comparative Education 47 (4): 449–470. doi:10.1080/03050068.2011.561542. Dobson, Richard, and Michael Swafford. 1980. “The Educational Attainment Process in the Soviet Union: A Case Study.” Comparative Education Review 24 (2): 252–269. doi: 10.1086/446119 Grant, Nigel. 1992. “Education in the Soviet Union: The Last Phase.” Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 22 (1): 69–80. doi:10.1080/0305792920220107. Heyneman, Stephen P. 1997. “Education and Social Stability in Russia: An Essay.” Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 27 (1): 5–18. doi:10.1080/0305792970270102. Higgins, Janet M. D. 1976. “Problems of the Selection and Professional Orientation of Soviet Pegagogical Students.” Comparative Education 12 (2): 157–162. doi:10.1080/0305006760120206. Janmaat, Jan Germen. 2007. “The Ethnic ‘other’ in Ukrainian History Textbooks: The Case of Russia and the Russians.” Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 37 (3): 307–324. doi:10.1080/03057920701330180. Kravetz, Nathan. 1980. “Education of Ethnic and National Minorities in the USSR: A Report on Current Developments.” Comparative Education 16 (1): 13–23. doi:10.1080/0305006800160103. Mercer, Justine, and Victoria Pogosian. 2013. “Higher Education Leadership in Russia: A Case Study of Mid-Level Academic Management at an Elite State University.” Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 43 (2): 184–202. doi:10.1080/03057925.2012.685585. Vogel, Albert W. 1959. “Indoctrination of Teachers of English in the Soviet Pedagogical Institute.” Comparative Education Review 3 (2): 32–35. doi: 10.1086/444804 Bigelow, Karl W. 1961. “Some Comparative Reflections on Soviet and Chinese Higher Education.” Comparative Education Review 4 (3): 169–173. doi: 10.1086/444852 Groth, Alexander J. 1987. “Third World Marxism-Leninism: The Case of Education.” Comparative Education 23 (3): 329–344. doi:10.1080/0305006870230307. Judge, Jon. 1975. “Education in the USSR: Russian or Soviet?” Comparative Education 11 (2): 127–136. doi:10.1080/0305006750110203. Mitter, Wolfgang. 1987. “The Teacher and the Bureaucracy: Some Considerations Concluded from a Soviet Case.” Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 17 (1): 47–60. doi:10.1080/0305792870170106. Raggatt, Peter. 1977. “School and Work: Some Ideological Considerations.” Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 7 (2): 83–91. doi:10.1080/0305792770070202. Roucek, Joseph S. 1960. “Juvenile Delinquency and Crime in the Soviet Bloc.” Comparative Education Review 3 (3): 40–47. doi: 10.1086/444816 Zajda, Joseph. 1988. “The Moral Curriculum in the Soviet School.” Comparative Education 24 (3): 389–404. doi:10.1080/0305006880240310. Bray, Mark, and Nina Borevskaya. 2001. “Financing Education in Transitional Societies: Lessons from Russia and China.” Comparative Education 37 (3): 345–365. doi: 10.1080/03050060120067820 Bulajeva, Tatjana, and Gabrielle Hogan-Brun. 2010. “Introducing Early Foreign Language Education in the Baltic Context.” Comparative Education 46 (1): 79–97. doi:10.1080/03050060903538715. Carnoy, Martin, Tatiana Khavenson, and Alina Ivanova. 2015. “Using TIMSS and PISA Results to Inform Educational Policy: A Study of Russia and Its Neighbours.” Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 45 (2): 248–271. doi:10.1080/03057925.2013.855002. Gershunsky, Boris S., and Robert T. Pullin. 1990. “Current Dilemmas for Soviet Secondary Education: An Anglo-Soviet Analysis.” Comparative Education 26 (2–3): 307–318. doi:10.1080/0305006900260212. McLean, Martin, and Natalia Voskresenskaya. 1992. “Educational Revolution from Above: Thatcher’s Britain and Gorbachev’s Soviet Union.” Comparative Education Review 36 (1): 71–90. doi: 10.1086/447082