Abstract
Rural local government in Mexico is contested terrain, sometimes representing the state to society, sometimes representing society to the state. In Mexico's federal system, the municipality is widely considered to be the ‘most local’ level of government, but authoritarian centralization is often reproduced within municipalities, subordinating smaller, outlying villages politically, economically and socially. Grassroots civic movements throughout rural Mexico have mobilized for community self-governance, leading to a widespread, largely invisible and ongoing ‘regime transition’ at the sub-municipal level. This study analyzes this unresolved process of political contestation in the largely rural, low-income states of Guerrero, Hidalgo, Oaxaca and Chiapas.
Notes
2 For background information about rural democratization, see Fox Citation1990.
3 It is safe to say that the now enormous literature on decentralization retains a distinct urban bias, with the partial exception of the body of research on India's Panchayats, whose vast experience cannot be done justice here. For broad comparative overviews, see Crook and Manor Citation1998 and Ribot and Larson Citation2005. For recent studies that specifically focus on the democratization of a level of rural government that is closer to the village than most, the barangay in the Philippines, see Estella and Iszatt Citation2004. On accountability dynamics in Chinese village government, see Tsai Citation2007. For development studies of rural municipalities in Latin America, see Cameron Citation2005, Fox and Moguel Citation1995, Fox and Aranda Citation1996, Pallares Citation2002, Rowland Citation2001 and Tendler Citation1997. On decentralization and participation issues in Mexico more generally, see Selee and Santín del Río Citation2006.
4 In parts of rural Africa, for example, what appear to be forms of customary rule and therefore societal representation often turn out to be legacies of colonial indirect rule, state-regulated forms of top-down governance that end up competing with territorial forms of citizenship-based representation [Ribot, Citation2004.
5 Olmedo Citation1999 is one of the few specialists in Mexican municipal governance to refer explicitly to the ‘fourth level of the state’.
6 Note that the majority of rural producers in Mexico, even before the recent acceleration of social inequality, have long been sub-subsistence producers – that is, semi-proletarian. According to the most rigorous class analysis of rural Mexico, based on a reinterpretation of 1975 census data through Chayanovian categories, 63% of ejido members produced less than enough for subsistence. Of the total producer population, 86.6% were peasants, included 56% at sub-subsistence and another 16% at subsistence levels, accounting for 56% of the arable land in standardized rainfed hectares. For details, see CEPAL Citation1982: 114, 123].
7 Ejidos are government-regulated agrarian reform communities; most were created between the 1930s and 1970s, and they account for approximately one half of arable land.
8 Note that there was little peasant protest against the reforms of the constitution's agrarian provisions at the time, in part because national leaders were promised that their members' specific agrarian problems would be resolved [Fox, Citation1994b Note also that in many ejidos, internally unequal land distribution and lack of leadership accountability led many members to welcome the increased certainty associated with individual land titles. For initial overviews of the impacts of the ejido reforms, see Cornelius and Myhre Citation1998 and Randall Citation1996.
9 Personal email communication, Javier Salinas, La Jornada correspondent, 22 May 2006.
10 Note that in Mexican political discourse the term ‘pueblo’ means both ‘community’ and ‘people.’
13 Only a small fraction of local demands for new municipalities are approved, hence the focus here on the issue of sub-municipal autonomy. Because the creation of new municipalities requires the approval of the state congress, approval is unlikely in cases where the town center that would ‘lose’ subordinate territory is ruled by the same party.
14 See the photo of Altamirano in La Jornada, 4 January 1994, as well as Burguete Citation1998.
15 The Institutional Revolutionary Party or PRI (Partido Revolucionaro Institucional) exercised political power in Mexico for much of the twentieth century.
16 Some of the ideas in this section were discussed in Fox Citation2002.
18 López and Robles Camacho [2005] and personal email communication with Oaxacan municipal development specialist Fernando Melo, 15 May 2006.
19 Personal email communication, 10 April 2006 with Fernando Melo.
20 Inter-village land conflicts in Oaxaca have a long history of provoking bloody conflicts. Historians and agrarian experts stress the responsibility of federal authorities in either ignoring or exacerbating these conflicts [e.g., Dennis, Citation1987.
21 For context, however, it is worth noting that while the percentage of female mayors in Oaxaca's indigenous municipalities is very low, it is also low throughout Mexico. A recent UN study found that only 3.5% of Mexico's municipalities are governed by women, one of the lowest rates in Latin America [Anzar, Citation2005.
22 On the changing roles of migrants in indigenous community governance, see Kearney and Besserer Citation2004 and Robles Camacho 1994.
23 For further discussion of the impacts of municipal social funds on local democratization, based on a representative sample of rural municipalities in the state of Oaxaca, see Fox and Aranda Citation1996. This study also addresses the role of World Bank projects in Mexico's rural municipal policy process. For broader context on the World Bank in rural Mexico during the 1990s, see Fox Citation1997, Citation2000.
25 See ‘Ley Orgánica del Municipio Libre del Estado de Guerrero,’ Arts. 198, 203B. accessible at www.pads.com.mx
27 The municipality includes 87 villages and the population numbers over 20,000, of which 68% non-Spanish speaking and 65% is illiterate [Tlachinollan, Citation2004: 21]. For a gender analysis of this local democratic struggle, see Rodríguez Cabrera Citation2005.
29 The state government appeared tolerant at first, but quickly became unsupportive. For example, in one case the state police jailed community police for jailing someone who had made death threats against a relative, and only freed them in response to a mass protest [Habana, Citation2002.
30 In San Luis Acatlán, the decision of the municipal authorities to put some community police leaders on the payroll provoked others to occupy the town hall in protest, to defend the principle of unpaid community service [Habana de los Santos, Citation2003b.
31 Cited in Bellinghausen Citation2006b. He also quotes local leaders who note that ‘the maa'phaa do not like to be called “tlapanecos,” because it means “dirty face.” They also deplore that the soldiers have raped their daughters, sisters and wives ‘as revenge because we are building popular power.’
32 Personal email communication, 6 April 2006.
35 This account is from Juan Cisneros, a rural development practitioner with two decades of public sector and NGO experience in Hidalgo (interviews, Mexico City, April and August, 2001).
36 As one autonomous municipal leader put it: ‘indigenous pueblos and civil society named authorities to be able to deal with the most urgent problems in the zone … The main goal is to show the government that with or without resources [from the state] we can promote sustainable development [and to] demonstrate to the government how to administer justice, taking into account the voice of the people, and that it be the communities themselves that can make decisions on development and the mandate of their authorities’[cited in Rodríguez Castillo, [n.d.].
37 The former position was associated with indigenous rights experiences in Oaxaca, while the latter position was associated with a non-Zapatista political formation, the ANIPA, which promoted the formation of Autonomous Multi-Ethnic Regions in their areas of influence in Chiapas, such as the Tojola'bal region.
38 See Hernández and Vera Citation1998: 80–86] also cited in López Monjardin and Rebolledo Millán, Citation1999. For a broad overview of post-San Andrés Accords political conflicts over indigenous rights reforms, including the beginning of the Fox administration, see Hernández Castillo, et al. Citation2004
39 For detailed descriptions of government hostilities, from the point of view of Zapatista municipal leaders, see the communiqués at www.laneta.apc.org/enlacecivil.
40 The EZLN is the Zapatista Army of National Liberation (Ejército Zapatista de Liberación Nacional).
41 Personal communication, Araceli Burguete, 10 April 2006. On formal elections in this region, see Viquiera and Sonnleitner Citation2000.
42 For a detailed study of this process in north-central municipalities of Chilón and Sitalá, in the context of broader racial and class conflict, see Bobrow-Strain Citation2007.
43 See Chiapas Media Project [2004].
44 Personal communication, Araceli Burguete, 10 April 10, 2006.
Cornwall
,
Andrea
.
‘Making Spaces, Changing Places: Situating Participation in Development,’
.
IDS Working Paper
.
(Institute of Development Studies, Sussex University)
.
No.170
Cornwall
,
Andrea
.
2004
.
“
‘Spaces for Transformation? Reflections on Issues of Power and Difference in Participation in Development,’
”
. In
Participation: From Tyranny to Transformation?
,
Edited by:
Hickey
,
Samuel
and
Mohan
,
Giles
.
London
:
Zed Press
.
Cornwall
Andrea
Vera Schattan
Coelho
Spaces for Change? The Politics of Citizen Participation in New Democratic Arenas
London
Verso
2007
Fox
,
Jonathan
.
1994a
.
“
‘Targeting the Poorest: The Role of the National Indigenous Institute in Mexico's National Solidarity Program,’
”
. In
Transforming State-Society Relations in Mexico: The National Solidarity Strategy
,
Edited by:
Cornelius
,
Wayne
,
Craig
,
Ann
and
Fox
,
Jonathan
.
La Jolla, CA
:
UCSD, Center for U.S./Mexican Studies
.
Fox
,
Jonathan
.
1996
.
‘How Does Civil Society Thicken? The Political Construction of Social Capital in Rural Mexico,’
.
World Development
,
24
(
6
)
Fox
,
Jonathan
.
2007
.
Accountability Politics: Power and Voice in Rural Mexico
,
Oxford
:
Oxford University Press
.
Cooke
,
Bill
and
Kothari
,
Uma
.
2001
.
Participation: The New Tyranny?
,
London
:
Zed Press
.
Hickey
Samuel
Giles
Mohan
Participation: From Tyranny to Transformation?
London
Zed Press
2004
Fox
Jonathan
The Challenge of Rural Democratisation: Perspectives from Latin America and the Philippines
London
Frank Cass Publishers
1990
Crook
,
Richard C.
and
Manor
,
James
.
1998
.
Democracy and Decentralisation in South Asia and West Africa: Participation, Accountability and Performance
,
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University
.
Ribot
Jesse
Ann
Larson
Decentralisation of Natural Resources: Experiences in Africa, Asia and Latin America
London
Frank Cass Publishers
2005
Estrella
Marisol
Nina
Iszatt
Beyond Good Governance: Participatory Democracy in the Philippines
Manila
Institute for Popular Democracy
2004
Tsai
,
Lily
.
2007
.
Accountability without Democracy: Solidarity Groups and Public Goods Provision in China
,
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Cameron
,
John D.
2005
.
‘Municipal Democratisation in Rural Latin America: Methodological Insights from Ecuador,’
.
Bulletin of Latin American Research
,
24
(
3
)
Fox
,
Jonathan
and
Moguel
,
Julio
.
1995
.
“
‘Pluralism and Anti-Poverty Policy in Mexico: The Experience of Left Opposition Municipal Governments,’
”
. In
Opposition Government in Mexico: Past Experiences and Future Opportunities
,
Edited by:
Rodríguez
,
Victoria
and
Ward
,
Peter
.
Albuquerque, NM
:
University of New Mexico Press
.
Fox
,
Jonathan
and
Aranda
,
Josefina
.
1996
.
Decentralization and Rural Development in Mexico: Community Participation in Oaxaca's Municipal Funds Program
,
La Jolla, CA
:
University of California, San Diego, Center for US-Mexican Studies Contemporary Monograph Series
.
Pallares
,
Amalia
.
2002
.
From Peasant Struggles to Indian Resistance: The Ecuadorian Andes in the Late Twentieth Century
,
Norman, OK
:
University of Oklahoma Press
.
Rowland
,
Alison
.
2001
.
‘Population as a Determinant of Decentralization Outcomes: Illustrations from Small Municipalities in Mexico and Bolivia,’
.
World Development
,
29
No.8
Tendler
,
Judith
.
1997
.
Good Government in the Tropics
,
Baltimore, MD
:
The Johns Hopkins University Press
.
Rodríguez
,
Carlos
.
2006
.
“
‘Experiencias municipales de participación y deliberación en Mexico: hacia la construcción de una democracia territorial de proximidad,’
”
. In
Democracia y ciudadanía: Participación ciudadana y deliberación pública en gobiernos locales mexicanos
,
Edited by:
Selee
,
Andrew
and
Río
,
Leticia Santín del
.
Washington, DC
:
Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, Latin America Programme/Ágora
.
Ribot
,
Jesse
.
2004
.
Waiting for Democracy: The Politics of Choice in Natural Resource Decentralization
,
Washington, DC
:
World Resources Institute
.
CEPAL
.
1982
.
Economía campesina y agricultura empresarial [tipología de productores del agro mexicano
,
Mexico City
:
Siglo XXI
.
Fox
,
Jonathan
.
1994b
.
“
’The Politics of Mexico's New Peasant Economy,’
”
. In
The Politics of Economic Restructuring: State-Society Relations and Regime Change in Mexico
,
Edited by:
Cook
,
Maria Lorena
,
Middlebrook
,
Kevin J.
and
Molinar
,
Juan
.
La Jolla, CA
:
UCSD, Center for U.S./Mexican Studies
.
Cornelius
Wayne
David
Myhre
The Transformation of Rural Mexico
La Jolla, CA
University of California San Diego, Center for US-Mexican Studies
1998
Randall
Laura
Reforming Mexico's Agrarian Reform
Armonk, NY
M. E. Sharpe
1996
Burguete Cal y Mayor
,
Araceli
.
1998
.
“
‘Poder local y autonomía indígena en Chiapas: Rebeliones comunitarias y luchas municipales,’
”
. In
Espacios disputados: Transformaciones rurales en Chiapas
,
Edited by:
Ramos
,
María Eugenia Reyes
,
Viveros
,
Reyna Moguel
and
Van der Haar
,
Gemma
.
Mexico City
:
Universidad Autónoma Metropolitana – Xochimilco/Ecosur
.
Fox
,
Jonathan
.
2002
.
‘La relación recíproca entre la participación ciudadana y la rendición de cuentas: La experiencia de los Fondos Municipales en el México rural,’
.
Política y Gobierno
,
9
(
1
)
Muñoz
,
Alma
.
2005
.
‘Vacío legal impide comprobar el uso de recursos del ramo 33,’
.
La Jornada
,
28 November
Díaz Montes
,
Fausto
.
2002
.
“
‘Comportamiento electoral en los municipios indígenas de Oaxaca, 1992–1998,’
”
. In
Dilemas de la democracia en México
,
Edited by:
Hémond
,
Aline
and
Recondo
,
David
.
Mexico City
:
Instituto Federal Electoral/Centro Francés de Estudios Mexicanos y Centroamericanos
.
EDUCA
.
2005
.
Diez voces a diez años: Reflexiones sobre los usos y costumbres a diez años del reconocimiento legal
,
Oaxaca
:
Servicios para una Educación Alternativa, A.C.
.
Flores Cruz
,
Cipriano
.
2002
.
“
‘Sistema electoral de los pueblos indígenas de Oaxaca,’
”
. In
Dilemas de la democracia en México
,
Edited by:
Hemond
,
Aline
and
Recondo
,
David
.
Mexico City
:
Instituto Federal Electoral/Centro Francés de Estudios Mexicanos y Centroamericanos
.
Hernández Navarro
,
Luis
.
1999
.
“
‘Reaffirming Ethnic Identity and Reconstituting Politics in Oaxaca,’
”
. In
Subnational Politics and Democratization in Mexico
,
Edited by:
Cornelius
,
Wayne
,
Eisenstadt
,
Todd
and
Hindley
,
Jane
.
La Jolla, CA
:
Center for U.S./Mexican Studies
.
Velásquez
,
María Cristina
.
2000a
.
El nombramiento: Las elecciones por usos y costumbres en Oaxaca
,
Oaxaca
:
Instituto Electoral de Oaxaca
.
Velásquez
,
María Cristina
.
2000b
.
“
‘Frontiers of Municipal Governability in Oaxaca, Mexico: The Legal Recognition of Usos y Costumbres in the Election of Indigenous Authorities,’
”
. In
The Challenge of Diversity: Indigenous Peoples and Reform of the State in Latin America
,
Edited by:
Assies
,
Willem
,
van de Haar
,
Gemma
and
Hoekama
,
A.
Amsterdam
:
Thela Thesis
.
Assies
,
Willem
,
Sevilla
,
Luis Ramírez
and
Patiño
,
María del Carmen Ventura
.
2006
.
‘Autonomy Rights and the Politics of Constitutional Reform in Mexico,’
.
Latin American and Caribbean Ethnic Studies
,
1
(
1
)
Dennis
,
Philip
.
1987
.
Intervillage Conflict in Oaxaca
,
New Brunswick, NY
:
Rutgers University Press
.
Anzar
,
Nelda Judith
.
2005
.
‘Presiden mujeres solo 3.53% de alcaldías en Mexico: Unifem,’
.
La Jornada
,
31 August
Kearney
,
Michael
and
Besserer
,
Federico
.
2004
.
“
‘Oaxacan Municipal Governance in Transnational Context,’
”
. In
Indigenous Mexican Migrants in the United States
,
Edited by:
Fox
,
Jonathan
and
Rivera-Salgado
,
Gaspar
.
La Jolla, CA
:
University of California, San Diego, Center for Comparative Immigration Studies & Center for U.S./Mexican Studies
.
Fox
,
Jonathan
and
Aranda
,
Josefina
.
1996
.
Decentralization and Rural Development in Mexico: Community Participation in Oaxaca's Municipal Funds Program
,
La Jolla, CA
:
University of California, San Diego, Center for US-Mexican Studies Contemporary Monograph Series
.
Fox
,
Jonathan
.
1997
.
‘The World Bank and Social Capital: Contesting the Concept in Practice,’
.
Journal of International Development
,
9
(
7
)
Fox
,
Jonathan
.
2000
.
“
‘Los flujos y reflujos de préstamos sociales y ambientales del Banco Mundial en México,’
”
. In
Las nuevas fronteras del siglo XXI: Dimensiones culturales, políticas y socioeconómicas de las relaciones Mexico-Estados Unidos
,
Edited by:
Béjar
,
Alejandro Alvarez
,
Klahn
,
Norma
,
Manchon
,
Federico
and
Castillo
,
Pedro
.
Mexico City
:
UNAM/La Jornada Ediciones
.
Bartra
,
Armando
.
1996
.
Guerrero bronco. Campesinos, ciudadanos y guerrilleros en la Costa Grande
,
México, DF
:
Sinfiltro
.
Bartra
Armando
Crónicas del sur: Utopías campesinas en Guerrero
Mexico City
Editorial Era
2000
Dehouve
,
Danièle
.
2001
.
Ensayo de geopolítica indígena: Los municipios tlapanecos
,
Mexico City
:
CIESAS/Editorial Miguel Angel Porrúa
.
Espinosa Damian
,
Gisela
.
1998
.
Organización rural y lucha cívica en el Norte de Guerrero
,
Mexico
:
Universidad Autónoma Metropolitana – Xochimilco
.
Hébert
,
Martin
.
2003
.
“
‘Communal Interest and Political Decision-Making in an Emerging Mexican Indigenous Movement,’
”
. In
Consensus Decision-Making, Northern Ireland and Indigenous Movements
,
Edited by:
Coy
,
Patrick
.
Vol.
24
,
Amsterdam
:
JAI, Research in Social Movements, Conflict and Change
.
Johnson
,
Jennifer
.
2005
.
‘Appropriating Citizenship, Resources, Discourses and Political Mobilization in Contemporary Rural Mexico,’
,
University of Chicago
:
Sociology Department
.
Unpublished PhD thesis
Yaworsky
,
William
.
2005
.
‘At the Whim of the State: Neoliberalism and Nongovernmental Organizations in Guerero, Mexico,’
.
Mexican Studies/Estudios Mexicanos
,
21
(
2
)
Tlachinollan
.
2004
.
Decimo Informe, Centro de Derechos Humanos de la Montana ‘Tlachinollan,' junio de 2003- mayo 2004’
,
Tlapa de Comonfort
.
www.tlachinollan.org, June
Tlachinollan
.
2004
.
Decimo Informe, Centro de Derechos Humanos de la Montana ‘Tlachinollan,' junio de 2003- mayo 2004’
,
Tlapa de Comonfort
.
www.tlachinollan.org, June
Rodríguez Cabrera
,
Veronica
.
2005
.
“
‘El liderazgo femenino en zonas indígenas: El caso del Rancho Nuevo la Democracia, Guerrero,’
”
. In
Transformaciones del campo mexicano: Una mirada desde los estudios de género, Los actores sociales frente al desarrollo rural
,
Edited by:
Arcozzi-Masino
,
Paola Sesia
and
Martelo
,
Emma Zapata
.
Vol.
5
,
Mexico City
:
Asociación Mexicana de Estudios Rurales/Editorial Praxis
.
Cruz Rueda
,
Elisa
.
2006
.
“
‘Sistema de Seguridad Publica Indígena Comunitaria,’
”
. In
Analisis interdisciplinario del Convenio 169 de la OIT. IX Jornadas Lascasianas
,
Edited by:
Cifuentes
,
José Emilio Rolando Ordóñez
.
Mexico City
:
Instituto de Investigaciones Jurídicas, National Autonomous University of Mexico
.
Habana
,
Misael
.
2003a
.
‘Policía Comunitaria, opción en Guerrero ante ola de inseguridad,’
.
La Jornada
,
2 November
Johnson
,
Jennifer
.
2005
.
‘Appropriating Citizenship, Resources, Discourses and Political Mobilization in Contemporary Rural Mexico,’
,
University of Chicago
:
Sociology Department
.
Unpublished PhD thesis
Johnson
,
Jennifer
.
2007
.
“
‘Deregulating Markets, Re-regulating Crime: Extralegal Policing and the Penal State in Mexico,’
”
. In
Deciphering the Global: Its Spaces, Scales and Subjects
,
Edited by:
Sassen
,
Saskia
.
London and New York
:
Routledge
.
Rojas
,
Rosa
.
2005
.
‘Reducen hasta 95% de delincuencia en seis municipios de Guerrero,’
.
La Jornada
,
27 September
Rowland
,
Alison
.
‘Local Responses to Public Insecurity in Mexico: A Consideration of the Policia Comunitaria in the Montana and Costa Chica of Guerrero,’
.
paper presented at the Latin American Studies Association
.
Dallas.
Tlachinollan
.
2004
.
Decimo Informe, Centro de Derechos Humanos de la Montana ‘Tlachinollan,' junio de 2003- mayo 2004’
,
Tlapa de Comonfort
.
www.tlachinollan.org, June
Dehouve
,
Danièle
.
2001
.
Ensayo de geopolítica indígena: Los municipios tlapanecos
,
Mexico City
:
CIESAS/Editorial Miguel Angel Porrúa
.
Habana
,
Misael
.
2002
.
‘Otorgan libertad total a los policías comunitarios de la Montaña, Guerrero,’
.
La Jornada
,
14 February
Habana
,
Misael
.
2003b
.
‘Siguen retenidos 6 funcionarios de Guerrero que supervisaban obras en San Luís Acatlán,’
.
La Jornada
,
13 December
Bellinghausen
,
Hermann
.
2006b
.
“Los partidos políticos no son buenos; solo dividen,”
.
La Jornada
,
18 April
Schryer
,
Frans
.
1990
.
Ethnicity and Class Conflict in Rural Mexico
,
Princeton, NJ
:
Princeton University Press
.
Hernández Navarro
Luis
Ramón
Vera
Acuerdos de San Andrés
Mexico City
Editorial Era
1998
Hernández Castillo
Rosalva Aída
Sarela
Paz
Maria Teresa
Sierra
El Estado y los indígenas en tiempos del PAN: neoindigenismo, legalidad e identidad
Mexico City
Editorial Miguel Angel Porrúa/CIESAS
2004
Viquiera
,
Juan Pedro
and
Sonnleitner
,
Willibald
.
2000
.
Democracia en tierras indígenas: Las elecciones en Los Altos de Chiapas [1991–1998]
,
Mexico City
:
CIESAS/Colegio de Mexico/IFE
.
Bobrow-Strain
,
Aaron
.
2007
.
Intimate Enemies: Landowners, Power, and Violence in Chiapas
,
London and Durham, NC
:
Duke University Press
.
Additional information
Notes on contributors
Jonathan Fox
This article is a revised and abridged version of a chapter entitled ‘Decentralizing Decentralization: Mexico's Invisible Fourth Level of the State,’ from Fox (2007). The author is grateful for input from two reviewers, as well as the following Mexican activists and analysts Xóchitl Bada (Michoacán), Araceli Burguete (Chiapas), Juan Cisneros (Hidalgo, San Luis Potosí), Matoui Domínguez Escobedo (Veracruz), Carlos García (Guerrero), Flavio Lazos (Querétaro) and Fernando Melo (Oaxaca). Thanks also to Raju Das, Tom Brass, Jennifer Franco, Kent Eaton, Xóchitl Leyva and Jennifer Johnson for comments on earlier versions. All translations from Spanish are by the author.