THE ENLIGHTENMENT AND THE REDEFINITION OF POLITICAL LOYALTIES

Abstract

This article discusses the study of modernization in the conceptions of political identities and loyalties in Scandinavia in the late 18th century. Opening with a review of recent Scandinavian research on political cultures, the language of politics and emerging nationalism in the 18th century, it locates the ensuing case studies in this burgeoning field and also in a wider, European and comparative context. The construction of identities and loyalties among the nobility, the clergy, burghers, civil servants and peasants is examined. The author argues that, despite much of apparent continuity of values, there was a surprising degree of potential for innovation within Scandinavian political cultures in the Age of the Enlightenment. He emphasizes the need to study past political thought in the appropriate contexts of entire realms and North‐Western Europe as a whole and not just in the context of present‐day nation states. He also suggested that – due to the common traditions of representative government, unusually well‐preserved archival sources and the intensity of scholarly work on the 18th century in Scandinavia – Scandinavian cases should more frequently be used as objects of comparison in international studies of 18th‐century political cultures.

Notes

1. Nordin, Ett fattigt men fritt folk.

2. Manninen, Valistus ja kansallinen identiteetti.

3. Karlsson & Lindberg, eds, Nationalism och nationell identitet.

4. Sennefelt, Den politiska sjukan.

5. Alm, Kungsord i elfte timmen.

6. Nygård, Kustaa III; Tandefelt, Gustaf III inför sina undersåtar.

7. Skuncke & Tandefelt, eds, Riksdag, kaffehus och predikstol.

8. Hallberg, Ages of Liberty.

9. Cavallin, I kungens och folkets tjänst.

10. Karonen, Patruunat ja poliitikot.

11. Wolff, Vänskap och makt.

12. Ihalainen, Protestant Nations Redefined.

13. Reuterswärd, Ett massmedium för folket; Östlund, Lyckolandet; Winton, Frihetstidens politiska praktik.

14. Saastamoinen, “Johdatus poliittisiin käsitteisiin”.

15. Lindberg, Den antika skevheten.

16. Feldbæk, Nærhed og adskillelse 1720–1814; Engelhardt, “De patriotiske selskaber”.

17. “Demokratisk teori og historik praksis.” University of Oslo. See http://www.hf.uio.no/iakh/forskning/forskningsprosjekter/demokrati/.

18. Özkirimli, Contemporary Debates on Nationalism; Lawrence, Nationalism; Pakkasvirta & Saukkonen, eds., Nationalismit.

19. Gelderen & Skinner, Republicanism.

20. Ihalainen, Protestant Nations Redefined; Ihalainen, “Svenska kyrkan”; Ihalainen, “The Enlightenment Sermon” and literature cited there.

21. Sivonen, “Me inkerikot, vatjalaiset ja karjalaiset”.