Using Inverse Probability Weighting Estimators to Evaluate Various Propensity Scores When Treatment Switching Exists

Abstract

In this paper, we conduct a Monte Carlo simulation study to evaluate three propensity score (PS) scenarios for estimating an average treatment effect (ATE) in observational studies when treatment switching exists: (a) ignoring treatment switching in subjects (UPS), (b) removing subjects with treatment switching (RPS), and (c) adjusting for treatment switching effect (APS) with two inverse probability weighting estimators, IPW1 and IPW2. We evaluate these six estimators in terms of bias, mean squared error (MSE), empirical standard error (ESE), and coverage probability (CP) under various simulation scenarios. Simulation results show that the IPW2 estimator with RPS has relatively good performance.

Keywords:

• Average treatment effect
• Observational studies
• Propensity score
• Treatment switching

Mathematics Subject Classification:

• 62P10