The dynamics of barter between the Russians and Alaska Natives, 1741–1867

Abstract

This article explores the dynamics of barter/trade between Russians and Alaska natives under the Russian Empire. During the first stage of colonization, the Russians (unlike the English and French) did not tend to barter/trade. They preferred to take the main riches of Alaska, especially valuable furs, on their own, or to obtain them by exploiting local people in hunting parties, deploying non-economic coercion to work and debt bondage. Moreover, the trade between the Russians and natives was complicated by the high cost of delivery, the chronic deficit of commodities, a relatively narrow assortment and the prohibition of selling firearms and alcohol (with a few exceptions). The paper demonstrates the formation of three different systems of barter/trade with their own dynamics during Russian colonization of Alaska. Though relatively profitable overall, the Russian fur trade in Alaska was less effective than similar operations run by their competitors, French, American and British traders. The development of the fur trade had a dramatic negative effect on the fate of many native peoples. Nevertheless, it improved indigenous standards of living through its influence on material culture and contributed to a decrease in the number of intertribal conflicts.

Keywords:

• Alaska natives
• Russian colonization
• Russian America
• barter trade
• commercial competition
• material culture

View correction statement:

Erratum

Notes

Another discussion based on material presented in this article was previously published in Russian in Antropologicheskii Forum, 29 (2016), 66–98.

This article was originally published with errors. This version has been corrected. Please see Erratum (https://doi.org/10.1080/04308778.2017.1411647).

1. V. T. Ryazanov, Ekonomicheskoe razvitie Rossii XIX–XX vv. [The Economic Development of Russia in the 19th–20th Centuries] (St. Petersburg: Nauka, 1998), pp. 316–318.

2. Issledovaniya russkikh na Tikhom okeane v pervoi polovine XVIII–XIX v. [Russian Investigations in the Pacific Ocean in the First Half of the 18th–19th Century], vol. 2: Russkie ekspeditsii po izucheniyu severnoi chasti Tikhogo okeana vo vtoroi polovine XVIII v. (Sb. dok.) [Russian Expeditions for the Study of the Northern Part of the Pacific Ocean in the Second Half of the 18th Century (Collection of Documents)], compiled by T. S. Fedorova, L. V. Glazunova, and G. N. Fedorova (Moscow: Nauka, 1989), pp. 86, 89–91.

3. K. T. Khlebnikov, Russkaya Amerika v neopublikovannykh zapiskakh K. T. Khlebnikova [Russian America in the Unpublished Notes of K. T. Khlebnikov], compilation, introduction, and commentary by R. G. Lyapunova and S. G. Fedorova (Leningrad: Nauka, 1979), p. 174.

4. I. E. Veniaminov, Zapiski ob ostrovakh Unalashkinskogo otdela [Notes on the Islands of the Unalaska District] (St. Petersburg: Tip. Imp. Akad. nauk, 1840), pt. 2, p. 53.

5. Khlebnikov, p. 41.

6. A. L. Crowell, Archaeology and the Capitalist World System: A Study from Russian America (New York: Plenum Press, 1997), pp. 52, 219, 221, 230.

7. A. V. Grinëv, ‘Tuzemtsy Alyaski, russkie promyshlenniki i Rossiisko-Amerikanskaya kompaniya: sistema ekonomicheskikh vzaimootnoshenii’ [Natives of Alaska, Russian Promyshlenniki, and the Russian-American Company: The System of Economic Interrelations], Etnograficheskoe obozrenie [Ethnographic Review], 3 (2000), 77–80.

8. OR RGB – Otdel rukopisei Rossiiskoi gosudarstvennoi biblioteki [Department of Manuscripts of the Russian State Library], f. 204, k. 32, d. 4, l. 1 ob., 5 ob., 30–30 ob. Pis’ma, nastavleniya, predpisaniya i instruktsii A. A. Baranova [Letters, Guidelines, Regulations, and Instructions of A. A. Baranov], 1801–1805 gg.

9. P. Drucker, Cultures of the North Pacific Coast (San Francisco: Chandler Publishing Company, 1965), p. 194.

10. Issledovaniya russkikh na Tikhom okeane v pervoi polovine XVIII–XIX v. [Russian Investigations in the Pacific Ocean in the First Half of the 18th–19th Century], vol. 3: Rossiisko-amerikanskaya kompaniya i izuchenie Tikhookeanskogo Severa, 1799–1815 (Sb. dok.) [The Russian-American Company and the Study of the North Pacific Ocean, 1799–1815 (Collection of Documents)], compiled by L. I. Spiridonova et al. (Moscow: Nauka, 1994), p. 164.

11. AVPRI – Arkhiv vneshnei politiki Rossiiskoi imperii [Archive of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Empire], F. Gl. arkhiv I-7, 1802, op. 6, d. 1. Papka No. 35, l. 3 ob.–4. Pis’ma i doneseniya N. P. Rezanova [Letters and Reports of N. P. Rezanov], 1802–1806 gg.

12. V. N. Berkh, ‘Predislovie’ [Preface], A. Mackenzie, Puteshestvie po Severnoi Amerike k Ledovitomu moryu i Tikhomu okeanu sovershennoe gospodami Khernom i Makenziem s prisovokupleniem opisaniya: mekhovoi torgovli v Kanade proizvodimoy, vsekh zverey v Amerike obitayushchikhsya, nravov i obyknovenii vnutrennikh dikikh [Voyage through the Continent of North America to the Arctic and Pacific Oceans, Carried Out by Mr. Hearne and Mr. Mackenzie with a Description of the Fur Trade in Happening in Canada, All the Animals Living in America, the Mores and Customs of the Inland Savages], trans. from English on Kodiak Island (St. Petersburg: Morskaya tip., 1808), p. VII.

13. G. I. Davydov, Dvukratnoe puteshestvie v Ameriku morskikh ofitserov Khvostova i Davydova, pisannoe sim poslednim [A Two-fold Voyage to America by the Naval Officers Khvostov and Davydov, Written by the Latter] (St. Petersburg: Morskaya Tip., 1810), pt. 1, pp. 176–177.

14. K. L. Arndt, ‘Tapping the Trade of the Middle Yukon,’ in Bering and Chirikov: The American Voyages and Their Impact, ed. by O. W. Frost (Anchorage, AK: Alaska Historical Society, 1992), pp. 323–328; J. W. VanStone, ‘The Russian Fur Trade in Southeast Alaska,’ in Bering and Chirikov: The American Voyages and Their Impact, ed. by O. W. Frost (Anchorage, AK: Alaska Historical Society, 1992), pp. 314–321.

15. Khlebnikov, pp. 79, 80; ass. = assignatsiya a term that designates banknote rubles. One banknote ruble was roughly equivalent to 1/3 of a silver ruble (ser. or serebryanyi = silver). Thus, one silver ruble was roughly equivalent to 2.65 ass. (banknote) rubles. – Trans.

16. Khlebnikov, pp. 58, 59, 80.

17. K istorii Rossiisko-amerikanskoi kompanii (Sb. dok. materialov) [On the History of the Russian-American Company (Collection of Documentary Materials)], eds. by P. I. Pavlov et al. (Krasnoyarsk: Krasnoyarskii gos. arkhiv; Krasnoyarskii gos. ped. in-t, 1957), p. 33.

18. Khlebnikov, p. 41; K. T. Khlebnikov, Russkaya Amerika v ‘Zapiskakh’ Kirilla Khlebnikova: Novo-Arkhangel’sk [Russian America in the ‘Notes’ of Kirill Khlebnikov: Novo-Arkhangel’sk], compilation, preface, commentary, and index by S. G. Fedorova (Moscow: Nauka, 1985), p. 105.

19. NARS – National Archives and Record Service, Washington, DC, USA, roll 28, pp. 57–57 ob., Doneseniya glavnogo pravitelya Rossiiskikh kolonii v Amerike, ot 17 yanvarya 1822 do 24 dekabrya 1823 g. [Reports of the Governor of the Russian Colonies in America, from 17 January 1822 to 24 December 1823].

20. P. A. Tikhmenev, Istoricheskoe obozrenie obrazovaniya Rossiisko-Amerikanskoi kompanii i deistvii eya do nastoyashchago vremeni [Historical Review of the Formation of the Russian-American Company and its Activities up to the Present Time] (St. Petersburg: Tip. Eduarda Veimara, 1861), pt. 1, pp. 319–322.

21. Veniaminov, pp. 236–238.

22. Khlebnikov, Russkaya Amerika v ‘Zapiskakh’ Kirilla Khlebnikova, p. 142. Koloshi or Kolyuzhi – the Russian term for Indians of the Northwest coast of America. The Tlingit formed the majority group, the term was used interchangeably to mean all Indians and specifically the Tlingit. See: A. V. Grinëv, ‘Ob etnonime kóloshi’ [On the Ethnonym ‘Koloshi’], Etnograficheskoe obozrenie [Ethnographic Review], 1 (1986), 104–108.

23. [PSZRI 1830] Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossiiskoi imperii, s 1649 goda. Sobr. 1-e: S 1649 po 12 dekabrya 1825 g. [The Complete Collection of Laws of the Russian Empire, from 1649. Collection No. 1: From 1649 to 12 December 1825] (St. Petersburg: Tip. II Otd. sobst. E. I. V. kantselyarii, 1830), vol. 39, p. 253; vol. 40, p. 74.

24. NARS, roll 33, p. 213 ob.

25. Khlebnikov, Russkaya Amerika v ‘Zapiskakh’ Kirilla Khlebnikova, p. 140.

26. NARS, p. 36 ob.; roll 42, pp. 454, 455.

27. Khlebnikov, Russkaya Amerika v ‘Zapiskakh’ Kirilla Khlebnikova, pp. 137, 140, 141, 205.

28. Ibid., p. 137.

29. Khlebnikov, Russkaya Amerika v neopublikovannykh zapiskakh, p. 58.

30. T. Vaughan and B. Holm, Soft Gold: The Fur Trade & Cultural Exchange on the Northwest Coast of America (Portland, OR: Oregon Historical Society, 1990), pp. 39–40.

31. L. A. Zagoskin, Puteshestviya i issledovaniya leitenanta Lavrentiya Zagoskina v Russkoi Amerike v 1842–1844 gg., editing, annotating and commentary by M. B. Chernenko, G. A. Agranat, and E. E. Blomkvist (Moscow: Gos. izd-vo geogr. lit., 1956), p. 280.

32. Khlebnikov, Russkaya Amerika v neopublikovannykh zapiskakh, p. 235.

33. Tikhmenev, pp. 287–288; Zagoskin, pp. 68–69, 109.

34. D. J. Ray, The Eskimos of Bering Strait, 1650–1898 (Seattle, WA and London: University of Washington Press, 1992), pp. 121–141.

35. Zagoskin, pp. 58, 182.

36. I. V. Furugel’m, Otchet po upravleniyu Rossiisko-Amerikanskimi koloniyami s 1859 po 1863 god kapitana 1 ranga Furugel’ma [Report on the Management of the Russian-American Colonies from 1859 to 1863 of Captain of 1st Rank Furugel’m] (St. Petersburg: Tip. Eduarda Treimana, 1864), pp. 4, 24–26.

37. J. S. Galbraith, The Hudson’s Bay Company as an Imperial Factor, 1821–1869 (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1957), pp. 159–160.

38. F. Whymper, Travel and Adventure in the Territory of Alaska (Ann Arbor, MI: Xerox Company, 1966), pp. 189, 225.

39. K. L. Arndt, ‘Russian-American Company Trade on the Middle Yukon River, 1839–1867,’ in Russia in North America. Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Russian America. Sitka, Alaska: August 19–22, 1987, ed. by R. A. Pierce (Kingston, ON: The Limestone Press, 1990), pp. 180–192; T. J. Turck and D. L. Lehman Turck, ‘Trading Posts along the Yukon River: Noochuloghoyet Trading Post in Historical Context,’ Arctic, 45.1 (1992), 51–61.

40. Zagoskin, p. 263.

41. Ibid., p. 153.

42. Ibid., pp. 197, 280.

43. Ibid., p. 183.

44. Ibid., p. 236.

45. [PSZRI 1845] Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossiiskoi imperii. Sobr. 2-e: S 12 dekabrya 1825 goda po 28 fevralya 1881 goda: V 55 t. s ukaz [The Complete Collection of Laws of the Russian Empire. Collection No. 2: From 12 December 1825 to 28 February 1881: In 55 vols. with index] (St. Petersburg: Tip. II Otd. sobst. E. I. V. kantselyarii, 1845), vol. 19, pp. 628–629.

46. Prilozheniya k dokladu Komiteta ob ustroistve russkikh amerikanskikh kolonii [Appendices to the Report of the Committee about the Arrangement of the Russian American Colonies] (St. Petersburg: Tip. Dep-ta vneshnei torgovli, 1863), pp. 49–50.

47. Ibid., p. 61.

48. P. N. Golovin, ‘Iz putevykh zametok P. N. Golovina s predisloviem V. Rimskogo-Korsakova’ [From the Travel Notes of P. N. Golovin with a Preface by V. Rimsky-Korsakov], Morskoi sbornik [Maritime Collection], 65.5 (1863), 180.

49. RGAVMF – Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi arkhiv Voenno-morskogo flota [Russian State Archive of the Naval Fleet], f. 17, op. 1, d. 261, l. 90. Makarov Stepan Osipovich. Dnevniki, zapisnye knizhki [Makarov, Stepan Osipovich. Diaries, Notebooks] 1862–1879 gg.

50. O. D. Yakimov, ‘Nikolai Militov – igumen kenaiskoi pravoslavnoi missii’ [Nikolai Militov – Abbot of the Kenai Orthodox Mission], in Russkaya Amerika i Dal’nii Vostok (konets XVIII v.–1867g.): K 200-letiyu obrazovaniya Rossiisko-Amerikanskoi kompanii: Mat-ly mezhdunar. nauch. konf. (Vladivostok, 11–13 oktyabrya 1999g.) [Russian America and the Far East (End of the 18th Century–1867): On the 200th Year of the Formation of the Russian-American Company: Materials for the International Science Conference (Vladivostok, 11–13 October 1999)], ed. by A. R. Artem’ev (Vladivostok: In-t istorii, arkheologii i etnografii narodov Vostoka DVO RAN, 2001), p. 227.

51. P. A. Tikhmenev, Istoricheskoe obozrenie obrazovaniya Rossiisko-Amerikanskoi kompanii i deistvii eya do nastoyashchago vremeni [Historical Review of the Formation of the Russian-American Company and its Activities up to the Present Time], (St. Petersburg: Tip. Eduarda Veimara, 1863), pt. 2, pp. 370, 377–378.

52. Otchet Rossiisko-amerikanskoi kompanii Glavnago Pravleniya za 1860 g. [Report of the Board of Directors of the Russian-American Company for 1860] (St. Petersburg: Tip. Shtaba inspektora po inzh. chasti, 1861), pp. 44–45, 49–59, 61–62.

53. Furugel’m, pp. 28–30.

54. NARS, roll 63, p. 81 ob.

55. NARS, roll 38, p. 349 ob.

56. NARS, roll 35, p. 124 ob.

57. PSZRI, p. 638.

58. Khlebnikov, Russkaya Amerika v ‘Zapiskakh’ Kirilla Khlebnikova, p. 82.

59. Issledovaniya russkikh na Tikhom okeane v pervoi polovine XVIII–XIX v. [Russian Investigations in the Pacific Ocean in the First Half of the 18th–19th Century], vol. 5: Rossiisko-amerikanskaya kompaniya i izuchenie Tikhookeanskogo Severa, 1841–1867 (Sb. dok.) [The Russian-American Company and the Study of the North Pacific Ocean, 1841–1867 (Collection of Documents)], compiled by T. S. Fedorova, A. Yu. Petrov, and A. V. Grinëv (Moscow: Nauka, 2010), p. 392.

60. J. R. Gibson, “Russian Dependence upon the Natives of Alaska,” in Russia’s American Colony, ed. by S. F. Starr (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1987), pp. 77–104.

61. NARS, roll 56, p. 123.

62. NARS, roll 46, p. 323 ob.

63. Veniaminov, pp. 295, 296, 299.

64. O. E. Kotzebue, Novoe puteshestvie vokrug svetav 1823–1826 gg. [New Voyage around the World 1823–1826] (Moscow: Nauka, 1959), p. 214.

65. M. E. Krauss, ‘Yazyki korennogo naseleniya Alyaski: Proshloe, nastoyashchee i budushchee’ [Languages of the Native Population of Alaska: Past, Present, and Future], in Traditsionnye kul’tury Severnoi Sibiri i Severnoi Ameriki [Traditional Cultures of Northern Siberia and North America], eds. by V. P. Alekseev et al. (Moscow: Nauka, 1981), p. 157.