Mapping the field of Higher Education Research using PhD examination reports

ABSTRACT

The PhD is the highest formal qualification and signifies a scholar’s rite of passage as a legitimate contributor of new knowledge in a field. Examiner reports make claims about what is legitimate in a thesis and what is not and thus articulate the organising principles through which participation in a field is measured. The authors analysed 39 examiners’ reports on 13 PhDs produced over a five-year period by scholars from the Higher Education Research doctoral studies programme at Rhodes University in South Africa. Drawing on aspects of Karl Maton’s Legitimation Code Theory (LCT), this study uses the dimensions of LCT:Specialisation and LCT:Semantics to explore what kinds of knowledge, skills and procedures and what kinds of knowers are validated in the field of Higher Education Research through the examination process. The study found that despite concerns in the literature about the a-theoretical nature of the Higher Education Studies field, examiners valued high-level theoretical and meta-theoretical engagement as well as methodological rigour. In addition, examiners prized the ability to demonstrate a strong ideological position, to use a clear doctoral voice, and to recognise the axiological drive of the field. The analysis showed that examiners were interested in strong contextualisation of the problem-spaces in higher education in South Africa but also commented positively on candidates’ ability to move from troubling an issue within its context to being able to abstract findings so as to contribute to the field as a whole.

KEYWORDS:

• Higher Education Research
• Higher Education Studies
• doctoral
• PhD examination
• Legitimation Code Theory

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.

Notes

1 For an overview of the scope of the research published since 2002 by colleagues, Sid Bourke, Allyson Holbrook, Terry Lovat and others, see https://www.newcastle.edu.au/research-and-innovation/centre/sorti/publications/research-into-phd-examination.