Teacher–pupil interaction: A study of hidden beliefs in conclusion phases

Abstract

This article is a contribution to the characterization of teacher–pupil interactions during scientific inquiry. Attention is paid to conclusion phases, as it is at this point in the interaction that a pupil’s production is to be accepted or rejected. Sixteen sessions taught by eight teachers in junior high schools and high schools were recorded, transcribed and analysed. In interpreting the teacher–pupil interactions, the presence of hidden epistemological and pedagogical beliefs in the conclusion phases have been discerned. The conclusion phase corresponds to a dogmatic (versus constructivist) view of science and the teaching of science if the pupil’s production is judged for its veracity in relation to the teacher’s scientific knowledge (versus its validity in relation to knowledge shared by both pupil and teacher). A discussion follows on the conditions for the teacher’s building a relationship between this aspect of his/her practice and his/her beliefs. The impact of this research on teacher training is also considered.

Notes

* Equipe PAEDI, Institut Universitaire de Formation des Maîtres de Clemont‐Ferrand, 20 av. Raymond Bergougnan, Clement‐Ferrand, Cedex 2, 63039, France. Email: [email protected]

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Ludovic Morge*

* Equipe PAEDI, Institut Universitaire de Formation des Maîtres de Clemont‐Ferrand, 20 av. Raymond Bergougnan, Clement‐Ferrand, Cedex 2, 63039, France. Email: [email protected]